Active Users:617 Time:09/06/2026 04:58:57 PM
Eh. Devaluation is overrated. Legolas Send a noteboard - 09/05/2013 11:21:16 PM

View original postSpain, Italy, France and Greece are all dragging because they can't devalue their currencies to offset too much public sector spending. Cyprus already has a euro that differs from the rest of Europe (i.e., you can't spend it freely), Slovenia is probably next in terms of needing a bailout, and the common currency is causing nothing but common misery.

It was always kind of a cop-out and next best alternative to serious measures to improve your competitiveness. And it risks setting off competitive devaluation cycles.

I'm sure several of those countries are regretting having joined the euro, and not without reason, but leaving it will carry its own costs and in the short run it'll make things worse in each case, not better. And in the long run devaluation doesn't really help the economy at the end of the day. It's only in the middle-long term that there would be a benefit, but either way, it wouldn't save them from having to pass the reforms they have to pass. After all, the euro may force these countries to face their issues more directly than they otherwise would have, but it's not as if the euro causes those issues. Their badly organized labour markets and other economic institutions do.

As you can tell, I'm more in favour of the opposite answer, like many Belgians, I guess. We need more Europe, not less.

View original postHowever, I think Europe has gotten too complicated. The sentiment that it needs to go back to being nothing more than a trading union is the right one. Otherwise, it ties the hands of local politicans who know better how to help their constituents with idiotic regulations promulgated by half-educated "technocrats" in Brussels.

It's undeniable that there is a democratic deficit when it comes to those technocrats that you mention. But the local politicians that you also mention should look in the mirror when it comes to finding the ones responsible for that. Their classic game of blaming Europe for all the bad while claiming credit for all the good got old a long time ago. The debacle last month with the carbon emission permit trading scheme is a good illustration of what is wrong with Europe - in itself the ETS was a good plan, and plenty of countries around the globe were following its example. But it was crippled by politicians too obsessed with the short term when it came to determining the amount of permits to be issued, and then killed last month by similarly short-sighted votes in the European Parliament (although I suppose the bright side is that at least the European Parliament had sufficient authority that they were the ones who made the horrible decision, that's progress of a kind).

Whether in the USA or in Europe, subsidiarity is key. The EU is no doubt involved in some things it shouldn't be involved in, but for other things, such as environmental policy or indeed this idea of a European banking union, it simply makes sense to have policy on the EU level rather than national levels. And yes, if we want a single market, a single currency makes sense as well. We need more Europe, but a better Europe, with a European Parliament that actually has teeth, and for which parties are elected based on their European policies, rather than based on the whims of the national politics. In much the same way that so many Americans vote quite differently in national politics from how they vote in local politics.

Reply to message
London Mayor - leaving Europe a shot in the arm for democracy - 09/05/2013 05:06:26 PM 590 Views
As endorsements go, "not fatal" seems kind of lukewarm. - 09/05/2013 07:59:44 PM 348 Views
Europe may be limping along, but the euro needs to be dumped. - 09/05/2013 10:46:36 PM 327 Views
Eh. Devaluation is overrated. - 09/05/2013 11:21:16 PM 381 Views
It really sounds like you want to scrap individual nations..... - 10/05/2013 04:19:23 AM 332 Views
That's going a bit far. - 10/05/2013 09:02:32 AM 323 Views
Question..... - 10/05/2013 02:52:08 PM 310 Views
That really depends. - 10/05/2013 05:30:39 PM 337 Views
Oh, Boris. *NM* - 10/05/2013 08:46:02 AM 165 Views
Heh, yes. - 10/05/2013 03:01:00 PM 348 Views

Reply to Message