Active Users:273 Time:29/03/2024 12:24:26 PM
Think Alana - 24/01/2003 12:37:06 PM

this just seems insane to me. suing companies for "crimes" committed 140 years ago at a time when they were perfectly within the law to be doing what they were doing. i think its dangerous to apply modern moral standards to the past.

Well, they weren't all "perfectly within the law." As it was illegal to participate in the slave trade in all English colonies after circa 1830s. And slavery was illegal in the northern U.S. States well before the Civil War (I'm sure you remember the Dred Scott case?) So, technically, these companies knowingly operated where slavery was both legal and illegal. They weren't unaware of what they were doing.


edit: just to perfectly clear, i do not now, nor have i ever, supported the idea that slavery was a good or moral thing. but again, that's something we've decided now. back then, it was a raging topic of debate. i for one am certainly glad the practice of slavery was ended in the u.s.

Again, remember, slavery was illegal in various parts of the U.S. well before 1864 (i.e. Bloody Kansas).

Also, I must point out, that it is curious to me that no one seems to think that maybe these women - and the lawsuit in general - is trying to make a larger point.

  • One: To remind us that much of the economic strength of these companies in the suit was achieved through slave labor


  • Two: To remind us that African-Americans still face hurdles as a result of slavery (i.e. KKK, poverty, unemployment, etc.) [I hasten to add that many other groups deal with this, as well.]


  • Three: That there are people who are very much alive today that can remember a time when life was much more difficult, and that we should honor and respect them. For they are harbingers of history, and to call them "dumb hos" as Chorabliss did above, is disgraceful


  • Four: To get a conversation like this going in the first place. We cannot expect one month a year to represent hundreds of years of history - for blacks OR whites. Slavery was a very real, lived experience, and to say that "Gee, whatever, its over now and that was, like, a long time ago" negates the enormous impact it had on the development of the U.S., the Civil Rights movement, and the significance of Colin Powell being able to occupy such a position of power.



  • Alright, obviously I could go on here.....but my main point is, critically think about what may be going on with this case, and maybe, just maybe, you won't be so quick to judge.

    Okay - one more point....I, personally, believe repairations are not a viable answer. I believe that it is much more vital to inform the public of the impact of slavery on our society. That is not a "you don't/can't understand" statement, either. Until I really started studying historic era archaeology, I had no idea, either. But I am hard-pressed to come up with anything in our current society whose roots do not stem from our colonial and antebellum era activities. Whether "good" or "bad", to not understand it is the real crime, in my eyes. So take a moment and think about what is being said, rather than assuming.


    Alana

    Trying not to choke on hope.




    View/create new replies Sign up for a premium account to add posts to a list of favourites!
    Texas suit targets 100 companies tied to slave trade - 24/01/2003 07:32:28 AM 262 Views
    does not click! - 24/01/2003 07:35:30 AM 34 Views
    good lord - 24/01/2003 12:15:04 PM 27 Views
    i will not, you are incorrect - 24/01/2003 07:46:02 PM 19 Views
    ... - 24/01/2003 08:06:37 PM 19 Views
    you dont know me and i dont know you - 24/01/2003 08:48:06 PM 23 Views
    Exactly - 24/01/2003 09:03:53 PM 13 Views
    sure why not - 24/01/2003 09:18:12 PM 13 Views
    interesting.... - 24/01/2003 07:37:23 AM 38 Views
    i'm not sure if they acted within the law - 24/01/2003 07:39:35 AM 26 Views
    Well for one thing, these aren't actual slaves. - 24/01/2003 07:54:45 AM 24 Views
    *nods* excellent points *NM* - 24/01/2003 08:01:33 AM 4 Views
    The Nazi's were breaking international law and committing war crimes - 24/01/2003 08:21:04 AM 22 Views
    time is the issue - 24/01/2003 08:26:26 AM 22 Views
    Not really - 24/01/2003 08:48:28 AM 25 Views
    I respectfully disagree *NM* - 24/01/2003 06:15:16 PM 4 Views
    Feel free - 26/01/2003 02:28:37 AM 7 Views
    meh - 26/01/2003 09:45:42 PM 5 Views
    The gap in time is a secondary issue - 24/01/2003 09:44:28 AM 11 Views
    silly - 24/01/2003 08:17:16 AM 25 Views
    why is this necessary? - 24/01/2003 08:19:00 AM 22 Views
    well, 'cause i assume a couple of white guys.... - 24/01/2003 08:21:05 AM 21 Views
    not necessarily. - 24/01/2003 08:43:00 AM 15 Views
    well, i do agree with you in that.... - 24/01/2003 05:30:11 PM 7 Views
    i am most disagreeable. - 24/01/2003 05:42:25 PM 6 Views
    Any bets on whether the Honorable Gary Bledsoe... - 24/01/2003 08:51:23 AM 23 Views
    no doubt he's working pro bono...it's all about healing, after all *NM* - 24/01/2003 11:39:49 AM 10 Views
    Those laywers - such idealists the lot of 'em. *NM* - 24/01/2003 12:19:57 PM 7 Views
    LOL - 24/01/2003 05:31:26 PM 10 Views
    I have one question... - 24/01/2003 10:07:36 AM 24 Views
    *shrugs™* - 24/01/2003 05:33:14 PM 8 Views
    I agree with you, Lit-Dog. - 24/01/2003 11:14:26 AM 18 Views
    Re: Texas suit targets 100 companies tied to slave trade - 24/01/2003 11:23:34 AM 13 Views
    Theres a reason that there is a staute of Limitations. *NM* - 24/01/2003 12:06:58 PM 7 Views
    Think - 24/01/2003 12:37:06 PM 29 Views
    While I don't doubt for a minute that you subscribe to the... - 24/01/2003 01:03:06 PM 21 Views
    Tis true - 24/01/2003 01:30:35 PM 15 Views
    If they were smart... - 24/01/2003 01:45:49 PM 12 Views
    Ahem - read more carefully.... - 24/01/2003 01:50:38 PM 16 Views
    My understanding though... - 24/01/2003 01:54:57 PM 11 Views
    Well.... - 24/01/2003 02:00:55 PM 11 Views
    Hmmm..... - 24/01/2003 01:07:12 PM 18 Views
    a few minor points. - 24/01/2003 01:28:54 PM 14 Views
    The South is far from the only bed of Racism. - 24/01/2003 01:49:36 PM 10 Views
    which explains - 24/01/2003 01:51:57 PM 10 Views
    It also might explain... - 24/01/2003 01:56:12 PM 13 Views
    i am jack's complete lack of surprise. - 24/01/2003 01:58:43 PM 10 Views
    don't worry darlin', i do think - 24/01/2003 06:41:59 PM 10 Views
    Oi vay - 24/01/2003 08:12:31 PM 8 Views
    so if i don't agree with you.... - 24/01/2003 08:28:29 PM 8 Views
    You must agree with me.... - 24/01/2003 08:49:32 PM 13 Views
    hehehe, another topic it is! - 25/01/2003 07:24:16 PM 6 Views
    I just don't see why they'd try, they can't possibly win. *NM* - 24/01/2003 02:05:50 PM 4 Views
    Things like this - 24/01/2003 05:46:46 PM 17 Views
    I agree with you darlin' - 24/01/2003 05:53:47 PM 10 Views