Active Users:82 Time:25/06/2022 08:06:49 AM
This is possibly the worst argument for a good idea I've ever seen. CalmB4theStorm - 27/04/2004 01:57:12 AM

While I completely agree with the irrationality of the double standard when it comes to breast baring, this is a horrible horrible argument for it.

First, the tone of the essay is exactly the "femi-nazi" attitude that is ridiculed and dismissed by many immediately. The only people who will actually finish reading this is the people that agree with the issue to some extent. "Preaching to the choir" as it were.

Second, the author uses completely ridiculous arguments to try to eliminate this double standard. The problem is not how breasts of "certain size shall be deemed unaesthetic" or any similar reason, it is the conception that women's breasts are sex organs and men's are not. And perhaps rightfully so.

Men's breasts are completely useless and only exist because women need them, while we all know (or should at least) women's breats are far more functional. Women and men are fundamentally different in some respects, and if we choose to make one of these areas where the difference is apparent taboo, then a double standard is inevitable. In the end, we are forced to choose between equality and the deep seated tradition that is our society's standards. And of course, societal standards, even ridiculous ones, nearly always win.

Perhaps it is not possible to demand equality when nature forces fundamental differences on us. Not all persons are created equal in every respect. However, if we believe that all persons should be treated equally under the law, then laws such as this should be the first be eradicated.

But the process for doing this is quite difficult as long as society believes that they are just laws. Many women don't feel that they should bare their breasts in public even if they think this is unjust (a challenge for those women who have read this far: take off your shirt and bra and go walk down the street for a few minutes). As long this attitude prevails there will not be any change as female breasts will always be sexual objects, and the ban on displaying said objects is a very old taboo indeed.

So basically, I'm telling all women to take off their shirts. Except hopefully, this time I won't get slapped.

"Ask her to wait a moment — I am almost done."
-- Gauss, when told, while working, that his wife was dying.

This message last edited by CalmB4theStorm on 4/27/2004 at 1:58:04 AM.

View/create new replies Sign up for a premium account to add posts to a list of favourites!
Political Exposure: The Breast - 26/04/2004 02:50:18 PM 235 Views
Umm... - 26/04/2004 02:56:28 PM 35 Views
**giggles** - 26/04/2004 03:02:20 PM 23 Views
Sheesh. - 26/04/2004 03:07:24 PM 28 Views
I think that the author takes the "right to breastfeed" for granted *NM* - 26/04/2004 03:11:13 PM 4 Views
Oh and btw... - 26/04/2004 04:53:16 PM 18 Views
Re: Oh and btw... - 26/04/2004 05:08:01 PM 15 Views
TAKE IT OFF! - 28/04/2004 02:19:25 PM 4 Views
Well - I don't at all agree with the reasoning - 26/04/2004 03:11:08 PM 27 Views
Re: Well - I don't at all agree with the reasoning - 26/04/2004 08:39:27 PM 6 Views
Re: Well - I don't at all agree with the reasoning - 27/04/2004 01:58:13 AM 5 Views
I like this. *NM* - 26/04/2004 03:22:00 PM 5 Views
Well then, just for you, - 26/04/2004 03:54:10 PM 19 Views
sweet!!! *NM* - 27/04/2004 01:43:48 AM 3 Views
- 27/04/2004 01:51:41 AM 7 Views
*calls police* - 28/04/2004 01:25:12 AM 3 Views
She's a little extreme in some of her asides, but she does have a pt. - 26/04/2004 03:31:05 PM 19 Views
This kind of diatribe sickens me almost as much as the Religious Right - 26/04/2004 03:40:43 PM 41 Views
Ooh, that's harsh. - 26/04/2004 03:52:46 PM 25 Views
Oh, it was entertaining, but in a 1960s Leftist way - 26/04/2004 04:59:46 PM 17 Views
*is improper* - 26/04/2004 04:38:11 PM 29 Views
Dont forget gay dance clubs - 26/04/2004 07:00:53 PM 14 Views
heh. and a story - 26/04/2004 04:40:34 PM 29 Views
Re: heh. and a story - 26/04/2004 04:44:38 PM 19 Views
Hahahahaha! - 27/04/2004 01:16:44 AM 7 Views
If women are indeed 53% of the populace, then let them vote. - 26/04/2004 07:04:05 PM 17 Views
Somehow, I don't think that - 26/04/2004 08:36:21 PM 11 Views
Think about what you're saying though. - 27/04/2004 01:41:31 PM 5 Views
This is possibly the worst argument for a good idea I've ever seen. - 27/04/2004 01:57:12 AM 12 Views