Active Users:114 Time:27/05/2020 07:54:34 AM
That was how I read it Camilla Send a noteboard - 31/10/2011 01:21:25 PM
I'm just curious if I was the only one who made the assumption, based on my understanding of Tolstoy, that he is comparing and contrasting male infidelity through the brother and female infidelity through the sister, and implying that female infidelity is unacceptable while male infidelity is tolerable. It is possible (though I personally think unlikely) that he was trying to compare and contrast purely physical dalliances with full-blown affairs, without reference to the sex of the adulterer. I just didn't take that away from the novel. It was more "Boys will be boys, but you women had better watch yourselves".


I don't think the two are in conflict. The use of female adultery in the one and male in the other, as I read it, says something about the ``essential'' natures of men and women, which perhaps serves as a justification for the idea that men and women should behave in different ways. But I should note that it has been many years since I read it. Do you consider Vronsky's relationship with Anna as simply a dalliance on his part? Or do you think he is treated differently because he is not married?

As for the opium part, I think that Tolstoy did a very good job of showing, without explicitly stating it, that the opium was making Anna more and more erratic.


Yes.

I was also unclear whether Anna had simply had an abortion when she was sick that made her incapable of having more children or whether she had had a full hysterectomy. How did you read that point? The original text was censored at that spot and so it's hard to tell what exactly was meant.


I don't remember. Sorry.
*MySmiley*
structured procrastinator
Reply to message
Анна Каренина (Anna Karenina) by Lev Tolstoy - 26/10/2011 03:21:35 PM 6659 Views
It's a nice book - 26/10/2011 06:04:48 PM 861 Views
i've read a (tiny) bit of russian literature, but war and peace was a struggle - 28/10/2011 09:56:17 PM 941 Views
War and Peace is a different animal. - 29/10/2011 05:11:02 AM 778 Views
I loved this. I didn't expect to, but it is beautifully written. - 30/10/2011 10:32:09 AM 832 Views
I think this was the first Tolstoy I read. - 31/10/2011 09:51:18 AM 925 Views
So do you think Tolstoy is comparing male infidelity and female infidelity? - 31/10/2011 01:03:41 PM 807 Views
That was how I read it - 31/10/2011 01:21:25 PM 908 Views

Reply to Message