Active Users:268 Time:29/03/2024 06:50:12 AM
Merel, yes. Kind of odd to see a Dutch name popping up in a Norse setting, but okay. Legolas Send a noteboard - 25/02/2016 10:00:45 PM

View original postIt's definitely disturbing. I recall her being written as very bitter and spiteful and I wonder if it was just meant to be a problem in their marriage of miscommunication/misunderstanding. Eddings, IMO, wasn't very good at writing that kind of thing.

Yes. Having just reread the whole series - and with a very critical eye after that incident - their whole development really makes very little sense. If he wasn't prepared to tackle it seriously, which while potentially interesting wouldn't have fit very well in the series, cutting the whole plotline would have been better. Now it just comes across as rampant misogynism.
View original postBut it's ok because it wasn't his fault he basically turned into a bear! (That was him, yes? It has been quite a few years since I read them.) Blame Cherek Bear-Shoulders.

Nope, this one is when he's all human, shortly before the first time he shape-changes. She's making creepy predictions - in fact, predicting the shape-changing - and he just hurls a spear at her heart. She dodges it, but still.
View original postI am going to have to reread them sometime soon with a critical eye and decide whether I want my children to read them as young as I did (10).

I must've been a similar age myself. For me the main objection from that perspective, even more than the violence which is hard to avoid in fantasy, is Eddings' outdated take on female characters and romance. Almost every woman in the series seems to have confusing and manipulating men as her main goal, and there's something rather immature about Eddings' most common kind of relationship, where the woman sets her sights on a clueless male character and then manipulates him until he finally falls in love with her. Especially since the women don't usually do too much else beyond that - from a Bechdel test perspective, this series is rather lacking. Polgara is the obvious exception on both counts, but then she's basically a demi-goddess.

I'm afraid it won't just be about when you want your children to read them, but also about whether your children will still be interested. Some children's or YA books have the gift of remaining relevant to every new generation (Roald Dahl, say), but I don't think Eddings' books really fall into that category.

Reply to message
Happy 2016! What are you reading in January and February? - 01/01/2016 03:04:47 PM 1234 Views
As soon as it comes out... - 03/01/2016 09:33:29 AM 881 Views
I've decided that 2016 is the year that I make a sizeable dent in the classics - 04/01/2016 02:09:57 PM 946 Views
I would start with Mansfield Park as it's the most boring. - 05/01/2016 03:38:00 PM 865 Views
Thanks for the advice. - 05/01/2016 03:56:02 PM 764 Views
Seconded. Every likeable character in Mansfield Park is, apparently, considered a villain. - 05/01/2016 06:29:45 PM 816 Views
Persuasion is the best. - 05/01/2016 09:30:15 PM 864 Views
Interesting. Care to elaborate? - 05/01/2016 10:14:28 PM 888 Views
I think it's mostly the relationships. - 10/01/2016 08:44:38 PM 742 Views
Hmm. I have to disagree with you. - 06/01/2016 07:21:57 AM 838 Views
Re: Hmm. I have to disagree with you. - 10/01/2016 08:45:29 PM 960 Views
Have decided to take a break from First Man In Rome. - 23/01/2016 11:48:53 AM 933 Views
Still on a break. Now on Jim Butcher - The Aeronaut's Windlass. - 11/02/2016 02:31:02 PM 998 Views
I am now reading a parenting book since my children are feral. - 22/02/2016 02:38:14 PM 1044 Views
I reread 'the magicians' - 18/02/2016 04:57:56 PM 789 Views
UGH. - 22/02/2016 02:37:25 PM 1111 Views
Fantasy rereads, for a change - feeling nostalgic, I guess. - 23/02/2016 08:17:45 PM 990 Views
Re: Fantasy rereads, for a change - feeling nostalgic, I guess. - 24/02/2016 01:42:39 PM 991 Views
It wasn't exactly a major plot point or anything. But it was ugly. - 24/02/2016 08:43:04 PM 1070 Views
Merill? Merith? Something like that? - 25/02/2016 07:45:18 PM 1190 Views
Merel, yes. Kind of odd to see a Dutch name popping up in a Norse setting, but okay. - 25/02/2016 10:00:45 PM 886 Views
I'm re reading JSA Corey'sThe Expanse - 25/02/2016 05:51:16 PM 1131 Views

Reply to Message