If you look their records for the same point in their NFL career they are about the same and Tebow has his college career to break the tie. In their second year both had taken a bad team to the playoffs and won one playoff game but Tebow has a Heisman Trophy and two National Championship rings. They did it in different ways but they both had very similar win loss records and both were players no one expected to be starting a playoff game. Now if you want to argue that Brady is a more talented player I would agree but they idea that Brady has accomplished more is false.

I am still not sure why you are confusing talent with likability. TO was one of the more talented players in the game but he was an asshole and no one liked him. I think from a personality point of view Brady is less likable than Tebow. Tebow is humble and Brady comes off as an arrogant pretty boy.