Active Users:181 Time:19/05/2024 12:46:38 PM
There seems to be some overlap. - Edit 2

Before modification by Joel at 18/01/2012 01:09:50 PM

Because all of your posts include random tangents about "hacking the Pentagon." SOPA and PIPA have nothing to do with that. SOPA stands for "Stop Online Piracy Act."

You really ought to educate yourself on this bill before commenting on its necessity and inevitability.

Mainly because of the issues of data access, site removal and the emphasis on "foreign" sites. It boils down to accessing and disseminating proprietary data, which includes that under commercial copyright, but also a host of other proprietary data that is or can be accessed and distributed by the same people using the same illegal means, from bank PINs to weapons schematics. The main difference is how much criminal prosecution already possible in those last two examples.

In terms of the means and intermediary sites involved, however, many of the same principles apply. I am not sure what, if any, legal repercussions there would be a to a site or its operators if it "facilitated" people obtaining or distributing the blueprints for an MX missile, but under the proposed legislation would impose significant criminal penalties for that as surely as for facilitating mpeg downloads.

As far as the necessity, the ease with which I CAN (NOT have) already obtain copyrighted material online at no cost establishes that.

As far as inevitability, establishing that is more a matter of researching public knowledge than these specific bills.

Again, I did NOT say these specific bills are inevitable; I said A new law is inevitable, which it is, for all the above reasons.

Return to message