Finally, there was the Ghost Ship which allowed one confirmed pirate (or the Serial Killer) to participate in the game again.


Where I screwed up was with the Treasure Hunters' Oath - their win condition was originally going to be that they had to kill anyone who broke the Oath, and that they would be given a night kill to do so if the opportunity arose, but I figured it would be harsh on them if someone else killed the person first, so I changed it to simply say that the oathbreakers (or, Ranagrande, if he learned about it via parrot) had to be dead by game's end. I screwed up because I didn't consider the Ghost Ship in this, Darth_Katie was technically allowed to reveal it because she was already dead, which upset game balance significantly.

I also had the idea, shortly after starting the game, that if someone revealed the truth about the Treasure event, those who had been betrayed could be offered to work for the ninjas - they were free to accept and have their win condition change to simply having the ninjas win, or they could pursue their present objectives. They would not become ninjas, wouldn't learn the identity of any of them nor participate in their night kill, but the ninjas would be able to send them one message each night with whatever information they chose to impart. This is what I considered implementing after Napoleon's disappearance.