That there's a scene in GoT where Cat is on a boat, and we get a full description of Riverrun. This happens before she meets Hoster, etc.
True, that is a scene that can easily be given a miss. What's the point of showing her entry to the castle?
And you're right about the book to screen stuff, of course.
You can always introduce him then. And given the sort of realism Martin appears to be going for, dramatic rescues which are such staples of other fantasy are highly unlikely. In another series, Tyrion's agents would have rescued Jaime from Riverrun easily, Arya & Yoren would have swept Ned from the block, Arya & the Hound would have brought a timely warning of the Freys' & Bolton's treachery, and so on. But I think anything further Brynden could accomplish could be transferred to one of Lady Stoneheart's band, who would have similar motivations.
Rescuing Edmure is just one option. Another possibility is that maybe Robb named Jon his heir, and the Blackfish knew of this, and has gone North to his "King". Or maybe he's hunting for Arya or Sansa, having given up Edmure as a lost cause. Or he may have joined the Band. The last would be the only case where glossing over him in the earlier books would work. In all others, his previous actions in the series would be good for the viewer to know.
True, that is a scene that can easily be given a miss. What's the point of showing her entry to the castle?
And you're right about the book to screen stuff, of course.
You can always introduce him then. And given the sort of realism Martin appears to be going for, dramatic rescues which are such staples of other fantasy are highly unlikely. In another series, Tyrion's agents would have rescued Jaime from Riverrun easily, Arya & Yoren would have swept Ned from the block, Arya & the Hound would have brought a timely warning of the Freys' & Bolton's treachery, and so on. But I think anything further Brynden could accomplish could be transferred to one of Lady Stoneheart's band, who would have similar motivations.
Rescuing Edmure is just one option. Another possibility is that maybe Robb named Jon his heir, and the Blackfish knew of this, and has gone North to his "King". Or maybe he's hunting for Arya or Sansa, having given up Edmure as a lost cause. Or he may have joined the Band. The last would be the only case where glossing over him in the earlier books would work. In all others, his previous actions in the series would be good for the viewer to know.
Game of Thrones casting question
- 14/05/2011 10:27:42 AM
1209 Views
Who? *NM*
- 14/05/2011 03:07:44 PM
410 Views
Strictly background character. An exiled tropical prince who hangs out at court in Kings Landing
- 14/05/2011 09:19:51 PM
994 Views
Then I am thinking of the wrong character
- 14/05/2011 10:13:27 PM
910 Views
Salladhor will likely be cast for Season 2.
- 15/05/2011 01:35:11 AM
1089 Views
*NM*
Re: Salladhor will likely be cast for Season 2.
- 15/05/2011 10:46:29 AM
833 Views
I would love Ralph Fiennes for Stannis.
- 15/05/2011 04:55:53 PM
919 Views
Funny how different people imagine things 
- 15/05/2011 11:08:46 PM
877 Views
- 15/05/2011 11:08:46 PM
877 Views
They could have a shootout for the role in the ruins of Stalingrad. But I think I know who'd win.
- 17/05/2011 02:22:01 AM
852 Views
*NM*
No Blackfish?
- 15/05/2011 10:53:18 PM
1100 Views
Doesn't look like it.
- 16/05/2011 10:51:17 AM
885 Views
Well...
- 17/05/2011 01:51:56 AM
1162 Views
You can get away without showing Riverrun in those scenes from aGoT
- 17/05/2011 02:20:44 AM
986 Views
Hmmm... I could swear...
- 17/05/2011 05:36:48 AM
1193 Views