Active Users:399 Time:17/06/2025 05:36:56 AM
Realism alone is not the issue. Aemon Send a noteboard - 24/01/2012 03:42:21 PM
I think it has more to do with how well something is justified/explained. I could watch Superman pick up a car and think nothing of it. If a regular citizen did the same, however, I would complain. Why? Because normal people can't do that. Superman is a magical alien, and as long as I'm willing to accept THAT, then I have no problem with him picking up a car. The rules are altered such that magical aliens now exist, but from then on, the movie plays within those boundaries.

The same is true for Captain America. The rules are altered such that a sort of military super-science exists. From that starting condition, I can believe that Captain America can perform all sorts of superhuman feats. However, the rules state that he is still a person; I would complain if he jumped over a building in a single bound, or flew off into the sunset. Not because those things are any more impossible than some of the things he does in the movie, but because the rules don't allow that.

Now, as for Peggy Carter, the reason she's unbelievable is because she hasn't had her rules altered. She's a regular woman living on a regular planet with regular physical laws. The rules in play state that she cannot punch a large man to the ground. If she stumbled into a super-steroid-machine like the dear Cap'n, well, then the rules are changed, and I'm happy to watch her kick butt. ;)
Reply to message
A thought about women in action roles - 17/01/2012 10:42:28 PM 1513 Views
The actress in Haywire is a former MMA fighter. - 17/01/2012 11:13:03 PM 866 Views
Ok bad example - 18/01/2012 01:03:45 AM 805 Views
How many men did she beat in those fights? - 18/01/2012 01:47:04 AM 796 Views
Regular but fit guys still wouldn't stand a chance, I guess. - 18/01/2012 08:23:07 AM 769 Views
I don't know - 18/01/2012 02:21:24 PM 849 Views
Haywire may not be the best example - 17/01/2012 11:33:31 PM 852 Views
I thought she was an American Gladiator? *NM* - 18/01/2012 01:04:20 AM 360 Views
you're not wrong - 18/01/2012 05:37:51 AM 739 Views
Mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm, Crush. *NM* - 18/01/2012 08:31:06 PM 358 Views
You rarely ever see that kind of stuff in "realistic" movies... - 17/01/2012 11:53:33 PM 787 Views
What about Enough with Jennifer Lopez? - 18/01/2012 01:05:13 AM 716 Views
I've thought about it before. - 18/01/2012 12:22:29 AM 965 Views
So: Action roles should have bigger women. - 18/01/2012 03:29:38 AM 865 Views
Actually, Buffy is worse because it implies women need magic to be useful. - 18/01/2012 05:34:09 AM 868 Views
That's what you got from watching Buffy? *NM* - 18/01/2012 06:38:06 PM 403 Views
There's not much to get FROM Buffy *NM* - 18/01/2012 06:46:35 PM 358 Views
magic isn't what makes women useful - 19/01/2012 04:51:35 AM 752 Views
I really doubt the outfit did much to make Xena look big. - 18/01/2012 06:53:59 PM 719 Views
I challenge you to say that while wearing her costume. *NM* - 18/01/2012 10:03:09 PM 337 Views
I'm pretty sure I would look frumpy and ridiculous - 19/01/2012 12:37:07 AM 738 Views
Lucy Lawless is pretty much Amazonian. - 19/01/2012 09:28:11 AM 1076 Views
It's true that she's not as tiny as others. - 19/01/2012 05:46:59 PM 716 Views
"Not as tiny as the others" is about the best you can say for her. - 19/01/2012 08:54:03 PM 714 Views
of course she could - 19/01/2012 11:17:39 PM 683 Views
No. - 20/01/2012 03:55:20 AM 946 Views
aahahaha. this makes me laugh. *NM* - 19/01/2012 07:18:26 PM 366 Views
Re: A thought about women in action roles - 18/01/2012 04:13:27 AM 729 Views
The problem I had with that scene is what I call Buffy Syndrome. - 18/01/2012 05:10:59 AM 918 Views
Wellll - 18/01/2012 01:26:24 PM 756 Views
Re: A thought about women in action roles - 18/01/2012 07:50:28 PM 929 Views
She is some kind of super hero in super hero movie, is't she? *NM* - 19/01/2012 07:30:50 AM 376 Views
I don't think she's technically supposed to have super powers. - 19/01/2012 08:58:40 PM 718 Views
The Avengers are going to be such a lame team - 19/01/2012 09:13:18 PM 803 Views
This is exactly what I think of the movie as well - 19/01/2012 11:24:16 PM 823 Views
Contemplating the female action hero…let’s talk about Ripley - 19/01/2012 09:24:18 PM 854 Views
So did anyone actually see Haywire this weekend? - 23/01/2012 02:34:43 PM 794 Views
It just depends on how much you're willing to accept. - 23/01/2012 04:23:36 PM 749 Views
You're nitpicking and drawing an arbitrary line. All action is ridiculously unbelievable. *NM* - 24/01/2012 04:53:40 AM 455 Views
I tend to agree with you. - 24/01/2012 05:25:45 AM 739 Views
Realism alone is not the issue. - 24/01/2012 03:42:21 PM 709 Views

Reply to Message