Active Users:307 Time:02/05/2024 05:53:28 AM
Re: I wasn't too happy with the episode (book spoilers) DomA Send a noteboard - 04/06/2013 05:05:16 AM

View original postFirst, the titular song, I don't remember any lyrics being given during it being played or if that was even the right music, but they really should have emphasized that more by maybe having someone comment "Strange choice, that". TV isn't books, there is too much going on, and you can't pause to quick re-gg to read a sentence, so you have to spell stuff out.

By American on average want TV shows not to demand too much of its audience, but it makes for fast food TV at times too.

I think they put enough emphasis on a detail like this. They devoted a whole scene to provide to setting it up by having Cirsei explain the whole story and mention the song as she was issuing a memorable warning and a death threat to Joffrey's bride. The episode is named after the song to remind people of last week's scene. In editing they put a lot of emphasis on Cat realizing something is wrong with the music being played. To dispel any doubt/confusion about what attracted her attention and worried her, they cut to the musicians (who played badly... They were not pros), then there's the body language of Cat and Roose. The audience isn't supposed to recognize the melody, it's supposed to puzzle out what alarmed Cat, and at the latest when Roose sends the regards of the Lannisters realize the music that Cat recognized was "Rains of Castamere". The great acting did the rest - everything was decipherable on Cat's face, and Roose's. This begged for a bit of subtelty, only Cat in the room figured out the implication of that song being played, it should dawn slowly on the audience too, and the slow pace of that scene reflected all that.




I really wonder why they modified the book at all, beyond the name conflict with Jeyne Poole.

Martin had his reasons for having the whole thing happen offscreen (and far from characters who would have stopped Robb) and for having Robb risk repeating the sin of his father who supposedly sired a bastard. So Robb married Jeyne, whom he had defiled The whole thing was annoying and not very dynamic, as Martin wanted. He had no need for the relationship itself, unlike the TV series that needed material for Robb.

The TV show needed someone more like Talisa to provide an on-screen confidante to Robb that woul be neither Cat or an experienced bannerman and justify at the same time that Robb made such a stupid mistake. They weren't so succesful with the character (she stood out way too much as not a GRRM creation) but they needed someone who could follow the army and move around the camp without being sheltered in a tent with handmaidens and talking only to Robb and Cat. Thus the nurse... But they needed someone with more sophistication than a regular camp follower (usually whores, beside), so a foreign high born Robb could marry she was. I'm guessing the main reason for not making her a "more interesting" Jeyne was her background. They wanted her dead at the wedding, not to be stuck with someone the audience expect to keep following if she survived. Yet, they might want to include Westerlings later - they don't know this yet -, and the murder of Jeyne at the RW would have changed the picture. Changing her house would have been too obvious that she was destined to die at the RW (they wrote Talisa so we'd wonder what they were up to). Another reason is that Jeyne's background and story (eg: when, where how and why she ends up married to Robb) were too complex for the TV show (they didn't have time for this subplot that happened late and that would have been tedious and that happened off sçreen even in the book), with no real pay-off.


They also must have realized it would be much easier to get the viewers to sympathize with Robb falling in ve on screen (which was a reason for beginning early, in s2) than to have Robb pull a wife out of nowhere because in some offscreen episode he couldn't keep it in his pants and Stark honor demanded (and his dad supposed youthful mistake with lady added pressure) he married her.

I didn't think Talisa was much of a success, but i understand why they totally replaced Jeyne with someone who was more simple and practical for TV.

Reply to message
Game of Thrones - Season 3, Episode 9 - The Rains of Castamere - 31/05/2013 04:36:30 AM 1696 Views
Spoilers. - 31/05/2013 02:49:52 PM 854 Views
Same *NM* - 31/05/2013 03:59:43 PM 422 Views
Yes. *NM* - 31/05/2013 05:45:51 PM 574 Views
I'm still surprised at how well maintained a secret it has remained given the nature of the Internet - 01/06/2013 05:39:06 AM 1075 Views
There's an interesting self-restraint thing going on - 01/06/2013 06:29:43 PM 984 Views
That's probably a good idea - 01/06/2013 07:48:52 PM 849 Views
Re: There's an interesting self-restraint thing going on - 02/06/2013 04:39:36 AM 777 Views
I'm going to make a Theon prediction (various spoilers) - 01/06/2013 12:52:04 PM 872 Views
You can find out now. - 01/06/2013 06:31:32 PM 883 Views
I think I'll hold off - 01/06/2013 07:50:32 PM 825 Views
I'm a spoiler junkie, but I'll wait for tomorrow night as well! *NM* - 02/06/2013 02:11:51 AM 553 Views
That sounds very plausible..... - 02/06/2013 02:10:47 AM 774 Views
Robb's wife is completely different character in the books - 02/06/2013 06:34:29 AM 798 Views
Interesting - so perhaps there may be a merging of sorts..... - 02/06/2013 06:58:24 PM 806 Views
Question - Balon Greyjoy? - 02/06/2013 07:17:34 PM 875 Views
Next week, I think. - 03/06/2013 03:03:31 PM 871 Views
Just watched the episode! Very well done.....spoiler. - 03/06/2013 03:05:33 AM 835 Views
Spoilers. Ah reading the comments on the FB page of GOT is filling me with glee. - 03/06/2013 03:14:45 AM 821 Views
+1 - Funny stuff! - 03/06/2013 03:27:29 AM 887 Views
As Tor.com said, still "NOT A PROPORTIONAL RESPONSE!" *NM* - 03/06/2013 03:04:25 PM 484 Views
Were it a different time - 03/06/2013 04:04:27 PM 789 Views
Robb had it coming, for he had no honor - 03/06/2013 05:31:01 AM 890 Views
Valar morghulis - 03/06/2013 06:39:38 AM 991 Views
I wasn't too happy with the episode (book spoilers) - 03/06/2013 10:06:24 PM 999 Views
Holy incredible knit-picking Batman..... - 03/06/2013 10:35:31 PM 771 Views
Some are nitpicks, others not so much - 03/06/2013 11:33:02 PM 933 Views
Re: I wasn't too happy with the episode (book spoilers) - 04/06/2013 05:05:16 AM 1004 Views
Re: I wasn't too happy with the episode (book spoilers) - 04/06/2013 01:08:46 PM 872 Views
Re: I wasn't too happy with the episode (book spoilers) - 04/06/2013 07:29:41 PM 847 Views
Re: I wasn't too happy with the episode (book spoilers) - 05/06/2013 05:02:40 PM 944 Views
Re: I wasn't too happy with the episode (book spoilers) - 05/06/2013 09:25:51 PM 827 Views
Season 4 is going to be very, very popular..... - 06/06/2013 01:18:01 AM 754 Views
Very likely... - 06/06/2013 09:31:03 PM 872 Views
I wasn't either. The RW scene was very anti-climactic. - 04/06/2013 05:09:30 AM 1135 Views
Anti-climatic is pretty accurate - 04/06/2013 01:21:10 PM 895 Views
Thank goodness there wasn't any silly slow-motion or camera tricks! - 04/06/2013 04:21:18 PM 909 Views
Agreed - 04/06/2013 07:27:02 PM 1042 Views
What did you think of Ned's last scene? - 05/06/2013 06:21:26 AM 1021 Views
It was fine, but I think a more realistic approach would have been more..... - 06/06/2013 01:14:53 AM 726 Views
I found that was really well done - 04/06/2013 01:58:48 PM 832 Views
That was no Ghost - 04/06/2013 03:11:38 PM 809 Views
You're absolutely right of course - 04/06/2013 05:57:42 PM 830 Views
Spoiler for season finale question. - 05/06/2013 01:55:29 AM 1061 Views
They definitely won't show it. - 05/06/2013 10:21:31 AM 802 Views
That's me guessing, not knowing, though. *NM* - 05/06/2013 10:21:56 AM 463 Views
*NM* - 10/06/2013 12:34:10 PM 499 Views
Yikes. That was crazy. - 05/06/2013 09:48:56 PM 732 Views

Reply to Message