Was Byar the whitecloack the hidden knife that would take Perrin by surprise?? And I'm not sure why she'd leave that dreamspike for so long in the same place. It wasn't like she needed it to keep Perrin in place while the whitecloacks still held hostages or were having his trial.


Could her appearance have been a retcon? I could buy her staging her death by careful planning, the Chosen are supposed to excel in such intricate plans. But making someone else do the weaves for her just because, stretches credibility, particularly since we're supposed to believe that an ordinary (black) Aes Sedai is able to weave Compulsion weaves complex enough to fool Nynaeve who had some experience with these weaves.