She's never put it to the test.
So? Are you saying she's wrong? That's not what the context seems to indicate.
No it did not. I you read it properly, the poster confused what Moghedien did to Birgitte (forcing her to think of herself as a child) and what she threatened to do with Nynaeve.
Yeah. I thought he meant simply destroying Elaida's mind to make her forget.
Nothing suggests Egwene could destroy Elaida's mind the same way without a similar struggle of wills, and unlike Mesaana Elaida knows nothing of TAR or how to control it, and so no such struggle of wills with Egwene could happen.... Against Egwene, Elaida would have no control of TAR at all. She'd fall under Egwene's control long before her mind snapped.
That's if Egwene follows exactly the same procedure. Bair talks of a WO who lost her mind facing something stronger in TAR. The implication is that this wasn't a person, but something in TAR itself. Egwene could use something like that, I think.
Of course, Egwene would not even snatch her into TAR for moral reasons, let alone try to control her (that would all fall under compulsion in her book, and we know what she thinks of compulsion) but that's beside the point: nothing in the books suggests it's possible to use TAR to alter specific memories of someone permanently in a way that would hold outside TAR (short of coupling TAR with Compulsion).
Actually, it can be extrapolated. If you can indeed Heal yourself, as Slayer suggested, then it should be possible to compel. From the way RJ has written compulsion weaves, he clearly sees it as a weave that physically alters/damages the brain. Physical changes in TAR hold in reality, so a powerful Dreamer who can imagine that kind of damage on another in a precise manner should be able to imagine another person compelled to her specifications.
TOM SPOILERS 5 Imaginary Dollars to whoever can tell me why Egwene didn't find Elaida's dreams,
- 30/01/2011 10:18:03 PM
1450 Views
Where have you got the idea Egwene or any Dreamer could do this? *NM*
- 30/01/2011 11:14:22 PM
417 Views
Remember Moggy fighting Nynaeve and Birgitte in TaR?
- 30/01/2011 11:30:37 PM
970 Views
But that's in TAR
- 30/01/2011 11:42:25 PM
716 Views
I meant "to locate Elaida *via her dreams* and pull Elaida into TAR"
- 31/01/2011 12:18:13 AM
805 Views
as to that the WO told her flat out that such things were evil and only done by the Shadow
- 31/01/2011 12:53:32 AM
723 Views
Need
- 31/01/2011 06:40:10 AM
764 Views
You are confusing being in TAR and finding/entering someone else's dream
- 31/01/2011 02:24:56 PM
805 Views
Even then... you've forgotten that....
- 31/01/2011 01:53:07 AM
833 Views
I read some of that differently. TaR tricks not working in the real world = destroying walls
- 31/01/2011 02:09:31 AM
806 Views
That is not true...
- 31/01/2011 08:27:33 PM
783 Views
Thank you very much! I was wondering if I had to do a massive re-read
- 31/01/2011 11:50:13 PM
637 Views
Re: That is not true...
- 02/02/2011 12:21:59 PM
771 Views
Well, I wasn't going to suggest that Eggy go full-hardcore and break Elaida's (Lightside) mind. *NM*
- 02/02/2011 11:24:18 PM
328 Views
On another note: I wonder if finding Elaida via her Dreams and then Skimming to her would work.
- 03/02/2011 07:27:08 PM
755 Views
Dream finding doesn't reveal location. We've been told this repeatedly. *NM*
- 03/02/2011 10:20:08 PM
307 Views
Re: That is not true...
- 03/02/2011 10:25:05 PM
1132 Views
Most Aes Sedai ward their dreams.
- 31/01/2011 01:49:49 AM
819 Views
You sure on that?
- 31/01/2011 02:29:43 PM
687 Views
They DO ward their dreams...
- 31/01/2011 05:56:51 PM
651 Views
Re: DO They ward their dreams...
- 02/02/2011 02:46:12 PM
603 Views
Re: TOM SPOILERS 5 Imaginary Dollars to whoever can tell me why Egwene didn't find Elaida's dreams,
- 04/02/2011 05:10:49 AM
658 Views