Active Users:242 Time:12/05/2024 09:38:25 PM
Re: I agree with your disagreement to the kind of disagreement DomA Send a noteboard - 22/02/2011 04:43:57 PM
To bring it to a fine point: they wouldn't have time for a lot of the little interactions - imagine telling tEotW, and having time to choose the things that would get removed. Both TV shows and movies
suffer from needing to cut "character" material in order to keep their running time and still maintain all the elements that just advance the plots.

You'd think TV series with a full 22-ep run would never lack for time to tell their stories and feature their characters as well. Nope.

If you're a Farscape fan, you know that many first season eps clock in around 50 minutes, but the aired episodes are several minutes shorter. Hell, even the Simpsons' writers say that they lose a lot of the little gags they used to include. The reason is that the studios increased the amount of ad time by about 2 minutes. I don't know if that's why The Simpsons isn't so good anymore, but still...

So in tEotW, think about what you'd have to cut: all the little confrontations in EF at the start, and on Bel Tine. That stuff sets up the whole story, and the characters, as well as things to come in books 3 & beyond. Or how about you just pare down the amount of audible dialogue given to Padan Fain?

That would risk making him a ludicrous plot irregularity, long before he actually became a ludicrous plot irregularity.

The multiple confrontations with the Whitecloaks do a lot to advance Mat and Perrin and Egwene and Rand (and his "sickness";). It even gave Nynaeve and Moiraine and Lan some important moments. These would probably be gone.

And all the people that the characters meet? The ones who meet them and maybe march them off to a queen? Or give them a ride? Or turn out to be DFs?

There would just be a massive amount of stuff to remove. You'd need a really fine hand to even try to keep any of the series' spirit and still tell the story. And I'm only considering the first book...

It's not quite as impossible as DomA thinks, I should say. The best example I can think of: The Count of Monte Cristo is a really good movie, and the unabridged novel is a 1500 page hardcover! In Dumas' book, it's about 500 page before the first revenge is taken - and it's a freaking revenge story. I guess if they could get the people that adapted that, they might do a good job. But the job would be made more difficult by trying to explain elements of a slightly alien, totally-fictitious world.


Monte Cristo is also a very linear story (and for all its episodes, a very simple one), with the secondary characters existing only to serve its plot. It's not all about the number of pages... A lot of Dumas's novels adapt really well to the screen (though most productions of them have sucked, especially of the Three Musketeers) because they're serials, written to be read one episode a week. Most chapters are either a story unto themselves, or built to a cliffhanger. They're structured that way, they're the ancestors of radio and later TV serials! It's very easy to cut or merge minor characters in Dumas. They rarely have a storyarc of their own, and appear only to fulfill a plot related role. You just have to fill the plot role differently and you can cut or merge any.

WOT is inspired by those serials, but Jordan has multiplied everything. WOT is far more complex than any Dumas novel. It branches out into subplots at every turn, and those subplots very often come back to play a role in the main storyline later on.

Of course, if you give someone 8 x 22 episodes it would be possible to write a very decent adaptation for TV. But that's the easiest part, to write the script. It's unrealistic for a whole lot of other reasons. One is because of the size of the cast - just securing so many people for the recurring small but key parts (Verin, Siuan, Sheriam, Elaida, Cadsuane, the Forsaken, Taim, Berelain and so on and so on - the list of those you don't want to cut but that appear only episodically, a few episodes per season, is enormous). It would cost a fortune, and managing the schedules of all these guest stars (who forcibly work on other productions...) would be nightmarish - enough so to discourage networks to produce a show like this. TV shows tend to keep to a minimum the recurring guest stars that they must have available for specific episodes for good reasons. Guest stars aren't kept under contract, you can't be sure they'll be available to film when you need them to film. You can manage a few, which a lot of shows do, but in WOT most of the minor parts are recurring. The only way you can secure secondary actors so they stay available for your show is by paying them a lot, and that's just not done.

The other reason why the option of a regular TV show is unrealistic is that no major network will commit to a "niche" show like this for prime time and with prime time budget, and the networks that could (eg: SyFy in the US) wouldn't have anywhere near the budget for a complex production of this type. While artistically adapting WOT would be possible, realistically it's not possible unless you put on rosy glasses and invent yourself an universe where WOT will suddenly have the wide mass appeal of Desperate Housewives or Lost, or where specialized networks will suddenly commit the kind of budgets the leading series of the networks have.

Another major road bump to adapt something like WOT for TV is that down the line it becomes four different series. It would be terribly difficult, logistically and otherwise, for any show to run in parralel four (Perrin's, Mat's, Egwene's, Rand's - and later Elayne's) story lines. There's just not enough time in an episode for that - you can have an A story and a B story at most (or you run into the same sort of problems that happened with Heroes) If you start alternating between 2 storylines a week and the two others the next, you'd frustrate the audience. If you think Jordan had problems with this, it would be nothing compared to what would happen if this happened on a TV show.
Reply to message
So any news about the EoTW film? - 20/02/2011 07:59:36 PM 1268 Views
the film rights change hands every few years, it's unlikely anything will ever happen *NM* - 20/02/2011 08:42:57 PM 257 Views
that's probably a good thing. - 21/02/2011 01:58:36 AM 699 Views
Length - 21/02/2011 04:57:49 AM 635 Views
WoT could lose half its content and not overly suffer. - 21/02/2011 07:56:28 AM 641 Views
Re: WoT could lose half its content and not overly suffer. - 21/02/2011 02:24:07 PM 626 Views
Kind of disagree - 21/02/2011 03:12:50 PM 533 Views
Blurgh.... Please dont... - 21/02/2011 04:58:48 PM 576 Views
Re: Kind of disagree - 21/02/2011 05:17:42 PM 638 Views
I agree with your disagreement to the kind of disagreement - 21/02/2011 05:34:34 PM 588 Views
Re: I agree with your disagreement to the kind of disagreement - 22/02/2011 04:43:57 PM 567 Views
Re: WoT could lose half its content and not overly suffer. - 22/02/2011 11:41:58 PM 520 Views
That's actually not a bad idea - 23/02/2011 08:38:28 AM 504 Views
Re: That's actually not a bad idea - 23/02/2011 10:47:42 AM 472 Views
LOL *NM* - 22/02/2011 02:17:30 AM 253 Views
The one that came out last week? *NM* - 22/02/2011 03:37:07 PM 259 Views

Reply to Message