Active Users:185 Time:19/05/2024 03:20:14 AM
It depends... Zeratul Send a noteboard - 17/11/2011 05:40:24 PM
I'm a total Sanderson fanboy, and even I wouldn't go that far. I dearly love Sanderson's other works, and I wouldn't say his WoT books are the worst of the series (especially because it's hard to account for which plot elements were his and which were RJ's- ugh, that Graendal thing still kind of bugs me), but I can't even imagine putting tGS or ToM above Winter's Heart, Knife of Dreams, Shadow Rising, Fires of Heaven, and maybe some others if I ever sat down and did a real ranking.

Weird.


Personally I think TGS is by far the best book in the second part of the series. It has its problems, but they are much less severe than those of book 7-11, in which Jordan lost control of the plot, let side stories get expanded to a ridiculous degree, and build most of the plot on the characters behaving stupidly and out of character at plot convenient moments instead of keeping them consistent. It's not the lack of action and battles that's the problem for me, I've never cared much about this stuff anyway.

The Shadow Rising and The Fires of Heaven are the best books in the series IMO, and Jordan at his best was better and polished writer than Sanderson for sure, but I honestly find it hard to understand those people who claim that Sanderson's books are clearly the worst and they drag the series down. TGS is much closer in quality to TFOH and TSR than CoT is to TGS, and ye, Cot is inferior to TGS, thanks for asking. ToM is much inferior to TGS IMO, but still easily better than books 8-10. The series was already dragged down by Jordan producing successive subpar books before Sanderson took over.
Reply to message
A rebuke to Cannolli's Sanderson bashing (and some counter bashing) - 16/11/2011 04:32:25 AM 1992 Views
"You do not read or watch "The Road" looking for a good laugh." - 16/11/2011 03:02:31 PM 803 Views
Fantasy is so much more than you think it is - 16/11/2011 03:19:53 PM 900 Views
Re: Fantasy is so much more than you think it is - 18/11/2011 02:09:30 AM 867 Views
Re: A rebuke to Cannolli's Sanderson bashing (and some counter bashing) - 16/11/2011 03:23:45 PM 1160 Views
+1 - 16/11/2011 03:37:26 PM 721 Views
Re: +1 - 16/11/2011 05:29:40 PM 905 Views
Are there really people who like Sanderson's WoT better than Jordan's? - 17/11/2011 03:44:53 AM 648 Views
It depends... - 17/11/2011 05:40:24 PM 745 Views
Re: It depends... - 17/11/2011 07:31:38 PM 822 Views
Uh... I like them more than some of his books? - 06/12/2011 09:51:59 PM 645 Views
+1 more - 17/11/2011 05:47:42 AM 876 Views
Re: +1 more - 17/11/2011 06:14:45 AM 738 Views
What do you mean by "abuses dialogue to carry scenes?" - 17/11/2011 03:38:03 PM 655 Views
Re: What do you mean by "abuses dialogue to carry scenes?" - 17/11/2011 04:34:30 PM 777 Views
A considered and mature response. Or some crude name-calling - read and find out which! - 17/11/2011 05:37:38 AM 875 Views
ha ha ha love your final metaphor *NM* - 17/11/2011 03:54:58 PM 349 Views
So do I !!! - 17/11/2011 06:15:24 PM 990 Views
Re: A considered and mature response. Or some crude name-calling - read and find out which! - 18/11/2011 02:40:04 AM 691 Views
Good point. Very well reasoned and articulate. - 18/11/2011 03:01:29 AM 780 Views
Re: A considered and mature response. Or some crude name-calling - read and find out which! - 18/11/2011 02:44:15 AM 654 Views
This is the stupidest thing I have ever read in my life. That B-Sand did not write. - 18/11/2011 03:02:45 AM 810 Views
*confused* - 18/11/2011 03:38:34 AM 753 Views
Yes, absolutely not. *NM* - 18/11/2011 06:18:32 PM 323 Views
Sorry for the double post *NM* - 18/11/2011 05:04:35 AM 881 Views
No way tGS and ToM are the worst in the series. Not the best, but not the worst. - 02/12/2011 06:20:43 PM 1109 Views

Reply to Message