Active Users:329 Time:08/06/2025 01:37:13 PM
Re: Would you say it is still worth reading it? DomA Send a noteboard - 06/04/2011 01:24:27 PM
or should I look around for another one?

I have been meaning to read a Napoleon biography for some time. I was going to buy a Norwegian or Swedish one, but it was still too expensive last I checked.


Of the French ones, this one is a classic (I hesitate to say it's the classic, as I'm far from an expert on the period, and far less widely read on Napoléon than I am on the few last Bourbons and their time, but Castelot's 2 volumes are almost always mentionned when historians recommend books on Napoléon. The second one is the more read of the two volumes, by the way). It's from the Perrin publishing house, which is an excellent publisher of history. The collection at Perrin this one is from (the LAP) is in the more classic narrative style of the "great biographies", though, whereas their main collection and the other best known French publishers of biographies (Fallois, Fayard, Flammarion etc.) favour the more modern and more analytical approach (don't expect the analytical if very readable style/approach and the talent for synthesis of historian-biographers like Simone Bertière, Jean-Christian Petitfils etc., nor the dryer but savant approach of historians like Hildesheimer either (she's a specialist of Louis XIII and Richelieu, I just bought her new "Monsieur Descartes";). Castelot's work is more "academic" (ie: in the conservative style of the Académie Française) in the vein of Troyat, at least for this duology.

I enjoyed it a lot at the time, it's a good introduction to the period, through its central player.

If you're looking for a good synthesis on the wars, or the diplomacy of the era, or a good analysis of the politics or the military aspects, it's really not the right book (it might well exist, but I'm not aware of a single book that cover all those aspects and succeeds at it). The 2-volume biography is a synthesis of Castelot's 10-volume work on Napoléon and his time, so his more in-depth analysis of everything else around Napoléon is not in this work.

I don't know if it's been published in the Tempus collection (Perrin's excellent paperback collection) - some volumes from their most prestigious Librairie Académique Perrin collection remain forever published in a bound edition only. At 50 Euro for the set, it seems to be the case for Castelot's Napoléon.

Reply to message
André Castelot - Bonaparte (and on the reviewing of biographies) - 05/04/2011 08:54:03 PM 534 Views
I think you are right - 05/04/2011 10:05:55 PM 155 Views
Yeah. - 05/04/2011 10:26:42 PM 146 Views
Would you say it is still worth reading it? - 05/04/2011 10:32:23 PM 160 Views
Re: Would you say it is still worth reading it? - 06/04/2011 01:24:27 PM 229 Views
I am a fan of Bertière - 06/04/2011 01:37:50 PM 141 Views
Re: I am a fan of Bertière - 06/04/2011 03:25:31 PM 139 Views
Re: I am a fan of Bertière - 06/04/2011 03:41:07 PM 148 Views
His writing didn't strike me as particularly difficult. - 06/04/2011 06:48:05 PM 156 Views
Re: His writing didn't strike me as particularly difficult. - 06/04/2011 08:09:21 PM 149 Views
Re: His writing didn't strike me as particularly difficult. - 06/04/2011 09:42:33 PM 142 Views
Re: His writing didn't strike me as particularly difficult. - 07/04/2011 02:55:46 AM 132 Views
Re: His writing didn't strike me as particularly difficult. - 07/04/2011 08:19:52 AM 139 Views
Re: André Castelot - Bonaparte (and on the reviewing of biographies) - 06/04/2011 12:34:31 PM 755 Views
I was hoping you'd jump in. - 06/04/2011 07:31:02 PM 228 Views
Oh, and on a matter of vocabulary... - 06/04/2011 09:47:35 PM 148 Views
Re: Oh, and on a matter of vocabulary... - 07/04/2011 04:09:39 AM 149 Views
I don't see why biographies are more difficult to review than history books generally. - 06/04/2011 03:30:37 PM 231 Views
Hm, I suppose... - 06/04/2011 07:37:33 PM 148 Views
Oh, and on the profanity - 06/04/2011 03:37:17 PM 148 Views

Reply to Message