There are a couple of hints in the book that he's not dead, and he does seem to have a small hope, but in the last scene with Uriel, he seems pretty sure he's off to the afterlife. He says goodbye to Uriel as if its a final goodbye, and then
Then, moving briskly, lest my resolve waver, I opened the black door and stepped through.
Given the way my life has typically progressed, I probably should have guessed that What Came Next was pain.
Then, moving briskly, lest my resolve waver, I opened the black door and stepped through.
Given the way my life has typically progressed, I probably should have guessed that What Came Next was pain.
If he knew he was dead, wouldn't he have said "the way my life had progressed"? That he uses the present continuous is only more proof.
Then, he's getting his bearings, looking around. Looks up, sees Mab, she says she has work for him to do.
I stared at her dully, which was probably the only was I was capable of staring at the moment. Then I croaked, "I'm... alive?"
A few paragraphs later, he says, But... I got shot. And Told me... I was dead
There are quite a few more lines like that.
I stared at her dully, which was probably the only was I was capable of staring at the moment. Then I croaked, "I'm... alive?"
A few paragraphs later, he says, But... I got shot. And Told me... I was dead
There are quite a few more lines like that.
And they all have the feeling of being ridiculously theatrical. Read the parts before. He's thinking about his body, the aches and pains, and how he's starving, none of which make sense if he thinks he's dead. He was just putting on an act so Mab wouldn't know he expected to come back. That's how I read it, anyway.
I think this is one of those things where it's patently obvious to the readers, but the main character is completely oblivious until its explained to him. Which is a little unfortunate, but I guess we did have the advantage of knowing that more books were coming.
Well, it was obvious to us. But I also see clear signs that Harry was aware of it.
Ghost Story is out
- 26/07/2011 09:44:33 AM
1646 Views
What did you think of it?
- 26/07/2011 04:56:26 PM
1804 Views
The short version?
- 26/07/2011 11:12:10 PM
1190 Views
I agree. But I wasn't expecting anything more, so no big disappointment
- 27/07/2011 11:02:45 PM
1444 Views
Having thought about it for 24 hours *we're into SPOILER territory here on in folks*
- 27/07/2011 11:22:15 PM
1406 Views
Yeah, it also suggests future books will have less of some characters
- 28/07/2011 03:09:04 AM
1500 Views
Here There be *Spoilers* Quasi-Review
- 29/07/2011 06:25:36 AM
1467 Views
Re: Here There be *Spoilers* Quasi-Review
- 31/07/2011 03:13:38 PM
1377 Views
Woohoo! Finally finished it! ...not bad. I have two major questions about the plot (spoilers)
- 31/07/2011 05:24:44 PM
1293 Views
As I understand it
- 31/07/2011 06:02:39 PM
1373 Views
Yeah. The individual bits were awesome, but it does seem like it wasn't a very coherent whole
- 31/07/2011 06:11:25 PM
1222 Views
As to point 2...
- 31/07/2011 06:16:17 PM
1277 Views
Fair enough. Though I'm pretty sure your second paragraph is wrong
- 31/07/2011 11:34:05 PM
1188 Views
Nah...
- 01/08/2011 12:42:00 AM
1210 Views
Eh. I think you're projecting what we know to be true as readers
- 01/08/2011 03:59:04 AM
1227 Views
Not really...
- 01/08/2011 05:13:36 AM
1419 Views
Well
- 31/07/2011 08:45:17 PM
1203 Views
How would that do that?
- 31/07/2011 11:37:08 PM
1273 Views
Some things I liked: (Butters is basically Neville Longbottom, btw)
- 31/07/2011 06:08:39 PM
1456 Views
Re: Ghost Story is out
- 02/08/2011 02:16:19 PM
1275 Views
I'll be honest, I was expecting a different interpretation of next book's title
- 02/08/2011 02:29:10 PM
1174 Views
that would be cheating wouldn't it
- 02/08/2011 02:56:03 PM
1234 Views