Active Users:348 Time:07/07/2025 01:51:27 AM
Tolkein is an excellent example why I usually dismiss literary critics/critiques HyogaRott Send a noteboard - 23/01/2012 05:57:51 PM
As you explained so well, Tolkein's work was considered not quite up to snuff, and a interesting curiosity by the "experts". HOWEVER, it actually turned out to be one of the most influential collections of prose in the past 100 years. This is so often the case that I have very little regard for the self-proclaimed experts, and what is defined as a classic. Literary experts are actually only an expert on what was. They judge something new, by how its construction compares to something old, with no regard to how it may impact and excite future authors and readers. Often, they even hold a works popularity with the masses against it. Even though it is the popularity of an author's work that can (may/will) direct the future of writing.

Oddly enough, art critics err in the opposite direction, often praising something solely because it is new, even if it has little to nothing unto itself that is praiseworthy.

Movie/play critics probably balance to two extremes the best, but it still all boils down to a person's opinion; and mine is the only opinion that is "right" for me.
Reply to message
1961 Nobel Finalists: J.R.R. Tolkien - 19/01/2012 09:27:46 AM 1108 Views
It's difficult to assess Tolkien's relative merits then 51 years later. - 19/01/2012 02:41:52 PM 739 Views
Yes, Edwardian prose does not thrill me - 19/01/2012 02:58:00 PM 705 Views
Re: Yes, Edwardian prose does not thrill me - 19/01/2012 03:34:02 PM 564 Views
Re: Yes, Edwardian prose does not thrill me - 19/01/2012 03:45:07 PM 668 Views
Yet Jung personally was contemptuous of Joyce - 19/01/2012 06:41:58 PM 551 Views
Tolkein is an excellent example why I usually dismiss literary critics/critiques - 23/01/2012 05:57:51 PM 808 Views
There's a lot more to it than that. - 23/01/2012 07:20:30 PM 678 Views
True - 23/01/2012 07:57:42 PM 664 Views
You can't dismiss his impact, even if you do not like his storytelling. - 23/01/2012 07:40:19 PM 731 Views
Who is dismissing that he influenced millions well after 1961? - 23/01/2012 07:54:27 PM 660 Views
That's an odd argument - 23/01/2012 07:51:49 PM 747 Views
Not really - 23/01/2012 10:35:39 PM 596 Views
Eh... - 24/01/2012 12:40:37 AM 624 Views
Depends on what you see as the point of literature. - 24/01/2012 08:14:07 AM 582 Views
the point of literature. - 24/01/2012 01:30:28 PM 689 Views
NO - 24/01/2012 02:05:11 PM 565 Views
Re: NO - 25/01/2012 02:54:57 PM 559 Views

Reply to Message