Active Users:204 Time:28/03/2024 08:59:09 PM
Perhaps you're doing it an injustice... DomA Send a noteboard - 23/03/2012 09:03:45 PM
Battle Royale is fantastic, and the cinema version is a real treat. I love it.



I loved the book, not as much the movie (it was an OK adaptation, but not stellar IMO. The satire aspect wasn't nearly as strong as in the book) perhaps because I read the book long before tracking down a copy of the movie.

I reacted exactly the way you did when I heard about HG (never heard of the books until recently), rolling my eyes and all.

However, I hear more and more reviewers very familiar with Battle Royale who are saying it merely uses the same basic starting idea but it's a mistake to think of it as a simple rip-off and rehash of BR (or King's The Running Man, which IRRC predated it), that it's a lot more to offer on its own than that (one reviewer said it's not even comparable to say, Gattaca vs. Brave New World, in terms of just rehashing ideas). So far all the reviewers I expected to shred that movie apart are saying many positive things about it - speaking of its intelligence notably, and about the book series as well. They also say it has just as much social relevance in today's US as BR had in Japan at the time (though they say that aspect is secondary to the fact it's a well told story with a interesting central character, that the fact it doesn't insult the intelligence of the viewer either is just a big plus).

They've made me tempted to watch it, though I'll most likely wait for home release.

Having only the reviews/commentaries to go by, what I'm puzzled about is how that movie, and it is made for the YA crowd at that, is acceptable whereas Battle Royale got banned and with much fuss at the time (I ended up tracking a HK release that had English subtitles, but after I had seen the movie in Japanese w/o ST). I know BR got banned from US (and therefore Canadian) distribution on the argument it wasn't an acceptable premise for a movie after Columbine (or was it another school shooting, can't recall for sure) the concept itself, not the graphic violence for which BR is hardly a summum - and BR still isn't allowed for distribution/showing in the US, and yet a major studio releases this movie with the very same "unnacceptable" premise without a fuss. Maybe HG isn't quite what I expect in the end, but the reviewers talks of it having the same social satire/condemn violence with violence angle that was behind BR. It sounds a little bizarre/hypocritical.


Reply to message
The Hunger Games - 04/03/2012 07:53:10 AM 2076 Views
I have got to read these. - 04/03/2012 11:46:49 AM 1062 Views
Oh yeah, they're super easy to read - 04/03/2012 06:58:03 PM 1210 Views
Interesting you say the second one is better. - 04/03/2012 01:00:39 PM 1258 Views
I actually really liked the third book - 04/03/2012 07:05:28 PM 1359 Views
I heard they were awful... - 05/03/2012 01:11:07 AM 1014 Views
I intend to read them at some point... and the government's name is pretty clever. - 05/03/2012 11:28:09 PM 1070 Views
Where's the divided opinion? - 06/03/2012 05:48:47 PM 1090 Views
That's not true - 07/03/2012 12:41:06 PM 1214 Views
It's anything like twilight only in the sense that it has a lot of fans. - 07/03/2012 03:36:43 PM 1067 Views
What about the fact it plagiarizes a better book and movie? - 10/03/2012 04:38:15 PM 941 Views
Which plagiarized Dune and so on and so forth. [Battle Royale plagiarized the Lotterry, etc, etc] - 12/03/2012 06:29:35 PM 1044 Views
You can't improve on perfection - 12/03/2012 06:36:38 PM 1019 Views
Hmm. - 30/03/2012 05:12:24 AM 1123 Views
More. - 06/03/2012 07:45:15 PM 1098 Views
First person present tense sounds horrible for me - 07/03/2012 12:42:12 PM 1163 Views
Even before reading on wikipedia, I thought, "this is a rip-off of Battle Royale." - 10/03/2012 01:33:55 AM 969 Views
Definitely can vouch for the movie. *NM* - 10/03/2012 07:55:32 PM 503 Views
Perhaps you're doing it an injustice... - 23/03/2012 09:03:45 PM 1034 Views
Possible explanations. - 23/03/2012 10:50:36 PM 1216 Views
Re: Possible explanations. - 24/03/2012 01:11:19 PM 1029 Views
The movie was just released on Blu-Ray. - 24/03/2012 05:20:51 PM 1009 Views
They were okay - 25/03/2012 12:58:30 PM 1018 Views
I have a question re: difference to the film - 29/03/2012 09:51:57 AM 1506 Views
(way too detailed) Answers. - 29/03/2012 06:02:38 PM 1130 Views
You know what I was thinking, watching the movies? - 30/03/2012 05:16:11 AM 1039 Views
You wouldn't make it out of the initial bloodbath. - 30/03/2012 03:50:08 PM 924 Views
Ha! - 10/04/2012 04:32:19 AM 1080 Views

Reply to Message