Active Users:476 Time:02/05/2025 09:29:22 PM
Re: That is true p hart Send a noteboard - 07/05/2010 03:54:51 PM
That is true now, because for historical reasons the Lib Dems managed to maintain that position of third party. It doesn't mean it would be that way if you actually had PR elections. UKIP and the BNP would see rather significant vote increases, and not all of it at the expense of the Tories. In addition, PR would put an end to the incumbency advantage that limits the losses of the big parties when they lose an election. If this election had been under PR, I dare say Labour would've gotten a fair few less votes than they got now, not merely fewer seats.

Of course, if your point is just about natural alliances, it's true that under PR, even with significant changes of the kind I described, the Tories would have a disadvantage in that the right-wing would be splintered in three parties, one of which is absolutely not viable for a coalition. But then, PR might also create changes within the parties, and perhaps force Labour and the Lib Dems to make the distinction between them a bit sharper, or even cause parts of parties to defect to others.


I would expect a splntering of all the major parties, since the nature of the current system forces people to generally go with what is a fairly crude match to their ideals as the parties try to control their warring factions. I was trying to use current voting trends in a very general way - the Tory side of the spectrum usually does much worse in elections that the Lib Dem/ Labour end, which I think reasonable to see as something that wouldn't be changed by PR.


None of this really happened in Scotland when we got PR, why is everyone sure it will happen in England?
Reply to message
Lib Dems: Up 1% of the vote, down 10% of the seats. - 07/05/2010 09:29:03 AM 1662 Views
Re: Lib Dems: Up 1% of the vote, down 10% of the seats. - 07/05/2010 09:45:23 AM 1108 Views
So what would you move to? - 07/05/2010 09:53:51 AM 949 Views
Re: So what would you move to? - 07/05/2010 02:55:32 PM 1047 Views
God I hate the British system - 07/05/2010 10:24:35 AM 1080 Views
It's an excellent morning. Conservatives are at 301 right now. *NM* - 07/05/2010 01:57:52 PM 560 Views
Are you counting the Speaker? *NM* - 07/05/2010 01:59:37 PM 604 Views
Indeed - 07/05/2010 02:22:37 PM 1109 Views
I love how they're calling that option "The Coalition of the Losers". - 07/05/2010 02:27:56 PM 1022 Views
They are? Where? - 07/05/2010 02:38:01 PM 1155 Views
On the lovely BBC. Paxman, Robinson, Dimbleby et al. - 07/05/2010 02:52:01 PM 1038 Views
Ah, we have it on but with the sound turned down - the subtitlers must be skipping that phrase - 07/05/2010 03:13:57 PM 987 Views
The thing with PR is, the current vote results are a horrid predictor for PR vote results. - 07/05/2010 03:45:58 PM 1033 Views
That is true - 07/05/2010 03:53:51 PM 1043 Views
Re: That is true - 07/05/2010 03:54:51 PM 1064 Views
I'm sure it would be a setup for new elections in a few months if they did. *NM* - 07/05/2010 02:40:49 PM 560 Views
I suspect we'll get one of those anyway. - 07/05/2010 02:52:32 PM 1021 Views
What is the general consensus on who would win or lose from new elections? - 07/05/2010 02:57:04 PM 1170 Views
I've not heard any comment on this yet. I might have missed some. - 07/05/2010 02:58:00 PM 1047 Views
Not being talked about yet - I'd guess whoever is PM will lose though - 07/05/2010 03:21:23 PM 1171 Views
Re: Not being talked about yet - I'd guess whoever is PM will lose though - 07/05/2010 03:29:37 PM 1150 Views
King William IV indeed. - 07/05/2010 03:37:18 PM 1121 Views
Re: King William IV indeed. - 07/05/2010 03:40:41 PM 971 Views
Re: Not being talked about yet - I'd guess whoever is PM will lose though - 07/05/2010 04:04:03 PM 1055 Views
I suspect a great deal of the problem is George Osborn - 07/05/2010 04:09:51 PM 1064 Views
Re: I suspect a great deal of the problem is George Osborn - 07/05/2010 04:24:56 PM 938 Views
Yes. - 07/05/2010 04:26:50 PM 816 Views
Re: I suspect a great deal of the problem is George Osborn - 07/05/2010 04:28:45 PM 1012 Views
Re: I suspect a great deal of the problem is George Osborn - 07/05/2010 04:34:41 PM 995 Views
I'm sure he is - 07/05/2010 04:25:20 PM 1064 Views
Heh. - 07/05/2010 04:27:44 PM 1109 Views
Re: Heh. - 07/05/2010 04:43:18 PM 1105 Views
Re: I'm sure he is - 07/05/2010 04:40:07 PM 1044 Views
Cameron might be in trouble anyway. - 07/05/2010 06:25:14 PM 1151 Views
If they got PR as part of the deal it would be worth it - 07/05/2010 02:42:36 PM 1157 Views
Possibly. - 07/05/2010 02:53:28 PM 1175 Views
Re: Possibly. - 07/05/2010 03:00:55 PM 964 Views
I didn't mean from that point of view. - 07/05/2010 03:05:05 PM 1045 Views
Re: I didn't mean from that point of view. - 07/05/2010 03:18:57 PM 1055 Views
Short term pain for long term gain - 07/05/2010 03:02:51 PM 1141 Views
Re: Indeed - 07/05/2010 03:45:00 PM 1069 Views
Re: Indeed - 07/05/2010 03:59:41 PM 1167 Views
Here's what i would do to sink the Tories - 07/05/2010 04:06:10 PM 1031 Views
that does sound strange - 07/05/2010 10:57:10 AM 988 Views
The breakdown is pretty wack - 07/05/2010 11:07:20 AM 1002 Views
Tell me about it. - 07/05/2010 11:14:44 AM 1020 Views
I liked that as well - 07/05/2010 11:46:42 AM 1080 Views
I'm in the Cities of London and Westminster constituency. - 07/05/2010 11:56:04 AM 1049 Views
Not that I'd ever try to one-up you. - 07/05/2010 12:54:47 PM 1101 Views
- 07/05/2010 01:44:03 PM 978 Views
Re: The breakdown is pretty wack - 07/05/2010 03:23:32 PM 1024 Views
Same here - 07/05/2010 03:47:51 PM 974 Views
Re: Same here - 07/05/2010 03:56:46 PM 1127 Views
A simple change is all - 07/05/2010 01:16:16 PM 1067 Views
That's not a simple change. THIS is a simple change: - 07/05/2010 01:59:09 PM 1053 Views
Not that simple - 07/05/2010 02:45:00 PM 1007 Views
Because my school was a polling station we used to get the day off every polling day - 07/05/2010 02:51:18 PM 1167 Views
Show off - 07/05/2010 02:53:16 PM 1007 Views
Re: Not that simple - 07/05/2010 03:04:57 PM 1160 Views
Re: Not that simple - 07/05/2010 03:14:46 PM 1156 Views
Re: Not that simple - 07/05/2010 03:20:55 PM 852 Views
PR is hardly too difficult to implement and is much more democratic - 07/05/2010 02:48:01 PM 1033 Views
I hate the list system. - 07/05/2010 02:55:39 PM 1073 Views
There are many different versions - 07/05/2010 03:10:38 PM 993 Views
It's that bad i registered to moan. - 07/05/2010 02:53:37 PM 1075 Views
Conservatives win and the stock market plummets. j/k - 07/05/2010 03:40:11 PM 960 Views
Oh, and the other interesting thing will be seeing whether the Conservatives offer.... - 07/05/2010 03:57:52 PM 1130 Views
I like John Major - 07/05/2010 04:01:03 PM 1007 Views
There's only one the LibDems will be interested in though. - 07/05/2010 06:30:55 PM 1115 Views
But - 07/05/2010 08:21:11 PM 1052 Views
Isn't that the very definition of a coalition? - 07/05/2010 08:16:05 PM 1052 Views
OK here is the map of England by constituency, blue Tory, red NUlab - 07/05/2010 05:00:20 PM 1015 Views
So I'm just one of those upstart colonists....explain to me what is going on.... - 07/05/2010 05:26:59 PM 998 Views
Basically... - 07/05/2010 06:43:10 PM 1032 Views
And things are changing already - 08/05/2010 04:08:47 PM 1106 Views
To be fair, I don't know it makes for much of a change - 08/05/2010 04:20:26 PM 1125 Views
I thought they weren't allowed to do that if Brown isn't Prime Minister? - 08/05/2010 04:52:39 PM 1077 Views
The latter, I'd say. - 08/05/2010 05:43:23 PM 1370 Views
Brown is PM at the moment - 08/05/2010 06:16:48 PM 1002 Views
They certainly can. - 09/05/2010 04:37:46 PM 1099 Views
God, our system is fucked up *NM* - 07/05/2010 06:25:04 PM 590 Views
If i were the tories - 07/05/2010 11:28:43 PM 1052 Views
Sounds like the pressure is on for Cameron - 08/05/2010 02:01:49 PM 1103 Views
Hmmm - 13/05/2010 12:08:04 PM 1369 Views
Completely uncalled for! - 13/05/2010 01:12:05 PM 1181 Views
How was he supposed to know that at the time he made the post? - 13/05/2010 09:52:24 PM 1466 Views
Re: How was he supposed to know that at the time he made the post? - 13/05/2010 10:59:35 PM 1076 Views
Yes I jumped the gun on the 12 - 14/05/2010 09:53:49 AM 1052 Views
Re: Yes I jumped the gun on the 12 - 14/05/2010 10:45:35 AM 959 Views

Reply to Message