The problem I'd have with that draft for votes idea...
Burr Send a noteboard - 03/09/2012 04:28:34 PM
... is that it would leave the only ones left with voting rights being the ones least in opposition to the push for war, though the war is itself something that should be accountable to voting rights.
It simply isn't possible to fairly equate being willing to fight a war with having skin in the game. Hell, even if the war is guaranteed to be just and necessary, there are still some problems with the rigor of such an equation: e.g., a) there are different ways to have skin in the game other than being willing to fight, and b) a person might be theoretically willing to fight, but be so opposed to the current war strategy or implementation that they think the war that is just and necessary isn't the one being implemented. Such a person should be able to attempt to do their part to change the nation's course, regardless of whether or not they are legally drafted. Accepting that, it just brings us back to the normal question of whether a person should be involuntarily drafted.
It simply isn't possible to fairly equate being willing to fight a war with having skin in the game. Hell, even if the war is guaranteed to be just and necessary, there are still some problems with the rigor of such an equation: e.g., a) there are different ways to have skin in the game other than being willing to fight, and b) a person might be theoretically willing to fight, but be so opposed to the current war strategy or implementation that they think the war that is just and necessary isn't the one being implemented. Such a person should be able to attempt to do their part to change the nation's course, regardless of whether or not they are legally drafted. Accepting that, it just brings us back to the normal question of whether a person should be involuntarily drafted.
||||||||||*MySmiley*
Only so evil.
Only so evil.
This message last edited by Burr on 03/09/2012 at 04:36:05 PM
Anybody here ever studied the founding fathers of America?
- 30/08/2012 07:34:28 PM
835 Views
Slave-owning, mysoginist, wig-wearing members of the landed elite?
- 30/08/2012 07:51:33 PM
576 Views
No, never, not even briefly. 
- 30/08/2012 07:57:39 PM
592 Views
- 30/08/2012 07:57:39 PM
592 Views
What? Nooooo way
- 30/08/2012 08:06:30 PM
593 Views
- 30/08/2012 08:06:30 PM
593 Views
My US history class was an hour long and I always got distracted by a butterfly or something.
- 30/08/2012 08:50:39 PM
531 Views
Did you just kinda compare yourself to the founding fathers?
- 30/08/2012 08:08:40 PM
634 Views
- 30/08/2012 08:08:40 PM
634 Views
Not positively, but I have often thought they were a bad influence on me. 
- 30/08/2012 08:21:48 PM
618 Views
- 30/08/2012 08:21:48 PM
618 Views
Funny, my reaction to sentences like those is nearly the opposite.
- 30/08/2012 08:11:34 PM
570 Views
Fair point; it is revealing that none of the Bill of Rights amendments have multiple sections.
- 30/08/2012 08:39:24 PM
605 Views
You're projecting. *NM*
- 31/08/2012 12:48:12 AM
268 Views
I am aspiring.
- 31/08/2012 01:09:40 AM
717 Views
As a personal aside ...
- 31/08/2012 01:43:45 AM
647 Views
Like I say, maybe I invest too much in online posting.
- 31/08/2012 02:02:58 AM
691 Views
- 31/08/2012 02:02:58 AM
691 Views
Re:
- 31/08/2012 02:27:00 AM
669 Views
Re: Re:
- 31/08/2012 02:37:35 AM
675 Views
Well
- 31/08/2012 02:54:25 AM
681 Views
It does get repetitive too often.
- 31/08/2012 05:07:41 AM
684 Views
Doesn't really matter. You're gonna keep doing it. 
- 31/08/2012 05:16:23 AM
631 Views
- 31/08/2012 05:16:23 AM
631 Views
I did. They smelled of mahogany and death. They looked scabby and skeletal.
- 31/08/2012 12:35:44 AM
618 Views
Don't forget Hamilton! The creator of the American economy..... *NM*
- 31/08/2012 05:19:50 AM
318 Views
... and big government.
- 01/09/2012 01:54:20 PM
508 Views
I don't really buy that.....
- 01/09/2012 08:33:28 PM
558 Views
Hamilton loudly and often advocated a central bank, national debt and active federal government.
- 01/09/2012 08:41:50 PM
756 Views
I think the entire Age of Enlightenment is fascinating
- 31/08/2012 06:32:23 PM
540 Views
You realize you just made a great argument for intelligentsia rule, right?
- 01/09/2012 01:48:58 PM
628 Views
- 01/09/2012 01:48:58 PM
628 Views
I would want better intelligenstia first
- 01/09/2012 02:48:28 PM
698 Views
Ah, the old uneducated>miseducated argument.
- 01/09/2012 03:39:07 PM
646 Views
*wonders if we could test*
- 02/09/2012 02:45:10 PM
529 Views
no there is a better reason why it wouldn't work
- 02/09/2012 02:58:18 PM
667 Views
I listen to some of supposed intellectuals talk and I am unimpressed
- 02/09/2012 02:53:21 PM
562 Views
Being well read does not make one smart, but does facilitate it to a great degree.
- 02/09/2012 04:32:05 PM
515 Views
I like the Starship Trooper approach
- 02/09/2012 05:04:17 PM
623 Views
I run very hot and cold on that one.
- 02/09/2012 06:28:44 PM
717 Views
The problem I'd have with that draft for votes idea...
- 03/09/2012 04:28:34 PM
634 Views
What was that again about "you have a right to your own opinion, not your own facts"?
- 03/09/2012 06:39:01 PM
681 Views
Ah, right; I had forgotten our previous discussion of conscriptions termination in the '90s and '00s
- 03/09/2012 06:48:28 PM
613 Views
If you worked with more engineers you might change your opinion on the science degree part
- 04/09/2012 03:00:16 PM
560 Views
Maybe; I would likely just conclude horse sense is uncommon everywhere, but less so in engineers.
- 05/09/2012 12:11:58 AM
475 Views