Active Users:304 Time:09/05/2024 11:44:24 PM
Yes - but so do the Eurosceptic English. Legolas Send a noteboard - 09/05/2015 09:27:39 AM

View original postWith the price of oil dropping, the only benefit to an independent Scotland would be gone. The impression I get is that the Scots are a bunch of radical Leftists and the UK would be well off without them. The corollary, though, is that they'd run their country into the ground within 2 years and someone (read: the UK) would have to pick up the pieces. Though one would have to ask if Northern Ireland would be under pressure in the case of an EU exit by the UK.

Scotland, Northern Ireland and Wales are all more pro-EU than England, that's one factor (though not the biggest) in the Scots' abhorrence of the Conservatives. I suspect that Cameron and Osborne might be a little less eager to promise the Europe referendum if it was held in England alone, where the Eurosceptics' chances are a good bit better - they're both smart enough to realize that while their Eurosceptics are an immensely useful tool to give Britain more power to reject EU decisions it doesn't like, actually leaving is a terrible idea.

I don't think the Scots are that radically leftist - first past the post always exaggerates such differences. But they are left of centre, definitely. The whole thing reminds me quite strongly of Québec actually - which has also shown that such things can turn around quite rapidly in some circumstances, provided of course that the separatists aren't needlessly alienated even further. Cameron played some dangerous games in that regard in the election - he'll try to undo the damage now of course, but not sure how successful he'll be.

View original postOf course, the entire EU is straining right now. The smartest people I've heard speak on the subject don't seem to think the EU will survive in its current form - it's going to end up having to be reduced to a glorified customs union. Forget the euro, too. Anti-EU parties are gaining ground in virtually every member state and the pressure will become too great to maintain the EU because it's not the United States of Europe.

I do agree it will have to change, and the same may be true for the euro, but dropping it entirely seems unlikely. The thing with the anti-EU parties is that essentially all of them are populist parties (whether left, right or far-right on some points and left on others) who fail to offer answers that are at all realistic. If one of them ever came to power, the country in question would be doubly screwed - once for leaving the EU and once for having been idiotic enough to vote a populist party into power without the slightest clue of what they would actually do when faced with the reality of government (a bit like Syriza in Greece, except that Greece would almost literally collapse if leaving the EU right now, so they have no choice but to stay in, at almost any price). The Eurosceptics in the Conservative party are a little better, but the party leadership knows well enough that actually leaving would be a bad deal for Britain - it's only threatening to leave that is useful.

Reply to message
David Cameron whoops ass..... - 08/05/2015 01:33:15 PM 2149 Views
This time you're not talking nonsense. - 08/05/2015 05:36:35 PM 669 Views
The UK election system is as much a mystery as is cricket..... - 08/05/2015 05:44:31 PM 672 Views
It's basically the same system as yours, you do realize? For Congress, anyway. - 08/05/2015 06:32:54 PM 619 Views
The Scots seem quite suicidal - 09/05/2015 04:29:31 AM 592 Views
Yes - but so do the Eurosceptic English. - 09/05/2015 09:27:39 AM 626 Views
The euro can only survive in one form - 09/05/2015 05:39:34 PM 683 Views
Devaluation isn't exactly what you'd call a long-term solution. - 09/05/2015 08:38:54 PM 603 Views
Oh, I certainly don't support the populist parties - 11/05/2015 01:43:23 AM 493 Views
I agree, "far right" is a misleading label in some ways. - 11/05/2015 09:29:56 PM 652 Views
What fool or fools started the EU? - 09/05/2015 01:37:27 PM 515 Views
Because Europe was doing so well before then, right? - 09/05/2015 07:51:30 PM 626 Views
Re Scotland: - 10/05/2015 09:41:43 PM 622 Views
Yeah, it was tense enough from the outside... - 10/05/2015 10:42:53 PM 643 Views
So what is the SNP going to do if Cameron tells them (rightly) to sod off about another referendum? - 11/05/2015 01:45:16 AM 583 Views
Not the SNP so much as the people. - 11/05/2015 02:00:32 PM 696 Views
So the mob rules now, does it? - 11/05/2015 06:04:04 PM 621 Views
Significant devolution will happen, that's for sure. - 11/05/2015 09:07:00 PM 575 Views
Why? - 12/05/2015 07:10:31 AM 639 Views
I think that's enough Putin speeches for you for today. *NM* - 12/05/2015 06:37:23 PM 408 Views
I guess you haven't watched braveheart? - 13/05/2015 01:49:30 PM 601 Views
You are a sad sorry little man, and I pity you. *NM* - 15/05/2015 12:03:37 AM 440 Views
The US is made up of 50 nations - 12/05/2015 03:19:25 PM 531 Views
Indeed, but with the same two parties everywhere. - 12/05/2015 06:35:27 PM 588 Views
Wisconsin's drinking age - 13/05/2015 01:09:53 PM 663 Views
Texas has similar laws - 13/05/2015 01:44:29 PM 507 Views
I know. It's really sad that that's the most reasonable law anywhere in the US... - 13/05/2015 06:26:09 PM 641 Views
It's the same in Louisiana. - 14/05/2015 08:23:20 AM 578 Views
The states still can set the drinking age, incidentally. The feds can just withhold some funds. - 13/05/2015 02:55:51 AM 548 Views
They have still gutted the 10th amendment - 13/05/2015 01:47:53 PM 536 Views
I agree they've gutted it. I'm not sure how I feel about it. - 14/05/2015 07:37:22 AM 543 Views
Well your elected senators are not that stellar - 14/05/2015 01:38:37 PM 549 Views
What about open primaries like in California? *NM* - 15/05/2015 07:22:08 PM 304 Views
Texas kind of has open primaries - 18/05/2015 08:34:43 PM 661 Views
Three cheers for foodbanks! *NM* - 12/05/2015 02:51:06 AM 355 Views

Reply to Message