Active Users:298 Time:16/05/2024 11:03:42 AM
Back to Messageboard Post New Thread Search Help Stats Rules
You bring up some great points. The Shrike Send a noteboard - 24/04/2017 03:04:01 PM

View original post
There are, from what I can see, two things that it would need to happen to make it good, or barring that, just competitive.

1) It would have to have the financial backing to make it good. Half the reason why Game of Thrones is as popular/good as it is can be traced back to the financial mojo that HBO has. Big production money brings potential for great things. From visual effects, top tier actors (not necessarily big names, but actually good actors), writing/adapting scripts or screenplays, and the list goes on and on. Money makes that happen.

2) Something to set it apart. I'll go back to Game of Thrones. A big chunk of why the show has been successful is the fact that it isn't predictable (to mainline people). We've read the books, and we know that it can go anywhere. However, part of the allure of the show is that most didn't know that. The people that I watch the show with were shocked when Ned died...or the Red Wedding...or when Joffery is poisoned...or when Tyrion kills his father Tywin....etc. Some twists they saw coming...other's not so much.

The Wheel of Time has no such twists or turns. It's not until 5 books in, when a main character gets "killed". And even then, she's actually alive and they rescue her 6 or 7 books later.

***
Can it be done? Could they pull it off? Absolutely But to do it right, and for it to be received warmly by the fans (let alone the general public), they have a serious mountain of work to do.

~Jeordam


Number 2 especially is worrysome. I saw what they did with Shannara on MTV and one episode was enough to turn me off. Without something amazing to depict that world, the lack of significant plot twists will mean no buzz will surround the show.

HBO would be a good fit given that they will want to try to recreate the success of Game of Thrones now that the show has a firm expiration date.

Reply to message
Sony Will Bring The Wheel of Time to TV The Shrike - 20/04/2017 03:28:21 PM 827 Views
Oh. Great. Because they did such an awesome job with Spiderman. Cannoli - 20/04/2017 03:45:45 PM 556 Views
I remain cautiously optimistic. The Shrike - 20/04/2017 04:46:46 PM 453 Views
huh aerocontrols - 20/04/2017 04:29:34 PM 469 Views
It could still be many years before we see anything The Shrike - 20/04/2017 04:47:16 PM 426 Views
I got the first two WoT books for Christmas when I was 17 aerocontrols - 20/04/2017 06:28:42 PM 509 Views
You just have to keep your expecations realisitc random thoughts - 20/04/2017 04:30:00 PM 475 Views
That's hard to do with this particular set of books/show The Shrike - 20/04/2017 04:48:07 PM 510 Views
I would probably feel that way about Thomas Covenant random thoughts - 21/04/2017 12:40:23 AM 506 Views
Hating Wheel of Time as much as I do now, I hope they cancel it after seeing the pilot *NM* Tom - 20/04/2017 05:15:10 PM 269 Views
*sniffs* *NM* The Shrike - 20/04/2017 05:26:15 PM 256 Views
Casting decisions ruin a lot of adaptations for me damookster - 20/04/2017 05:34:05 PM 497 Views
Not since Hugh Jackman has such a mismatch in actor to character height been made aerocontrols - 20/04/2017 06:22:33 PM 520 Views
Didn't see it. Was that the black Annie version? *NM* damookster - 20/04/2017 07:29:25 PM 244 Views
yes *NM* aerocontrols - 20/04/2017 07:40:53 PM 222 Views
Richard in "Legend of the Seeker" is another one Cannoli - 21/04/2017 11:39:32 PM 529 Views
It will be interesting to see who they use. The Shrike - 24/04/2017 03:00:58 PM 504 Views
Re: It will be interesting to see who they use. aerocontrols - 24/04/2017 03:31:50 PM 461 Views
This makes me nervous. *NM* nossy - 20/04/2017 10:33:46 PM 304 Views
Why? Could anyone possibly fuck it up worse than it already has been? *NM* Tom - 21/04/2017 05:20:38 PM 233 Views
I have a lot of love for 1-4ish, which we have to watch before we get to the parts I dislike. nossy - 22/04/2017 08:38:39 PM 508 Views
I stand by the assertion that 1-6 were great reads. Tom - 23/04/2017 12:32:34 AM 553 Views
They've rewritten aSoIaF and people have been generally happy. Maybe they'd be okay with this. *NM* Ghavrel - 23/04/2017 05:06:42 AM 252 Views
I started to have real issues during 5-6 nossy - 23/04/2017 10:08:08 AM 488 Views
They could do that. The Shrike - 24/04/2017 03:01:45 PM 509 Views
If Harriett is involved or has a veto we know the series is doomed to failure. Tom - 24/04/2017 03:30:35 PM 511 Views
It really could go either way.... Jeordam - 20/04/2017 10:43:51 PM 551 Views
You bring up some great points. The Shrike - 24/04/2017 03:04:01 PM 509 Views
Let me restate what you guys are both saying: Tom - 24/04/2017 03:25:56 PM 554 Views
Look at the bright, shiny, flashy goodness! Jeordam - 24/04/2017 10:24:05 PM 564 Views
Yeah, the lack of tits and ass will make it a hard sell (cross-pun intended) *NM* Tom - 25/04/2017 09:40:47 PM 308 Views
If it's good it'll be nice to watch, but can't say I'm that excited about it. Legolas - 20/04/2017 11:22:50 PM 512 Views
WoT + TV = Half-Assed Anonymous2000 - 21/04/2017 01:14:49 PM 532 Views
WoT + TV = Half-Assed *NM* Tom - 24/04/2017 03:31:41 PM 284 Views
I have to say that if the doctor-wife of Rob Stark isn't Faile, nossy - 23/04/2017 10:25:47 AM 498 Views
It will be wonderful....if they do it right. LiterateDog - 24/04/2017 08:48:45 PM 480 Views
Back to Messageboard Post New Thread Search Help Stats Rules

Reply to Message

Block Quote Paragraph Quote
Formatting
Smiley Codes