View original post
Though it isn't clear if that is speculation or from a source. My guess is speculation but I think straying close to the time of the LOTR is more likely because anything else and most fans would be lost. A young Aragorn would be very doable and relatable with a great love story that we never see the beginning of. But the Silmarillion? The story is just too complicated and it doesn't have hobbits or wizards our really even dragons until near the end. Most people who are not serious fans would not even recognize it as the same story as LOTR. Most of the people I know who are not serious fans never finished the silmarillion.
Though it isn't clear if that is speculation or from a source. My guess is speculation but I think straying close to the time of the LOTR is more likely because anything else and most fans would be lost. A young Aragorn would be very doable and relatable with a great love story that we never see the beginning of. But the Silmarillion? The story is just too complicated and it doesn't have hobbits or wizards our really even dragons until near the end. Most people who are not serious fans would not even recognize it as the same story as LOTR. Most of the people I know who are not serious fans never finished the silmarillion.
Sloppy journalism all around covering this story. The Aragorn story would be tough since we have a conception of what he is like. I think they will be forced to go further back in time. Something like The Fall of Gondolin could work. Depends what the execs at Amazon think people want to see.
Amazon Making a LOTR Universe Show (Prequel)
- 13/11/2017 08:17:44 PM
1327 Views
Sounds like a disaster waiting to happen.
- 13/11/2017 08:51:39 PM
889 Views
What would you have them make instead?
- 13/11/2017 11:47:34 PM
864 Views
Uh, nothing, I guess? They've made movies of everything they could, and way too soon for remakes. *NM*
- 14/11/2017 06:37:41 PM
575 Views
This is illogical.
- 14/11/2017 06:43:11 PM
862 Views
Quotes from the best episode of stargate
- 14/11/2017 06:57:10 PM
887 Views
Apparently I am ruled less by fear than either of you.
- 14/11/2017 06:59:29 PM
854 Views
But that's how I see it. *NM*
So not looking forward to this
- 13/11/2017 09:11:32 PM
875 Views
It's a business. And businesses are inherently conservative about gambling.
- 13/11/2017 11:49:01 PM
905 Views
Yes there is some logic to it.
- 13/11/2017 11:57:04 PM
842 Views
Chances are good.
- 14/11/2017 12:23:08 PM
986 Views
The GOT tv show will still be there in a decade or so
- 14/11/2017 05:29:43 PM
876 Views
But by then you will be spoiled on how it ends.
- 14/11/2017 05:33:15 PM
885 Views
I didn't think it would end this way. / End? No, the journey doesn't end here. Death is just another
- 14/11/2017 06:49:38 PM
987 Views
You're starting to become Joel-like in the length of your replies.
- 14/11/2017 07:01:24 PM
852 Views
Sorry I get quotey when I get sentimental
- 14/11/2017 07:26:03 PM
874 Views
Nothing wrong with sentiment.
- 14/11/2017 07:35:01 PM
876 Views
Threadjacks in order to produce flexibility. American Gods 2017 next? Or should I wait and watch
- 14/11/2017 07:44:04 PM
892 Views
Oh gods. I had to stop watching that.
- 14/11/2017 08:28:39 PM
906 Views
I pulled a damookster. 
- 14/11/2017 08:28:40 PM
874 Views
- 14/11/2017 08:28:40 PM
874 Views
*NM*
Clips your Mookie card, only 7 more Mookies till you get a free Sub Sandwhich
- 14/11/2017 10:02:39 PM
841 Views
A Mook sandwich would be tastier.
- 14/11/2017 10:05:24 PM
885 Views
*NM*
Shame
- 14/11/2017 07:34:25 PM
828 Views
Literatedog likes it too.
- 14/11/2017 07:36:49 PM
842 Views
Evan Rachel Wood gets even better the further into the story you get
- 14/11/2017 07:41:31 PM
847 Views
I'm worried that they said Frodo is coming back
- 13/11/2017 09:37:49 PM
947 Views
I haven't seen anything about Frodo.
- 13/11/2017 11:49:50 PM
821 Views
The first paragraph of the article you linked
- 14/11/2017 02:04:13 AM
899 Views
Yeah, I see that now. Sloppy journalism.
- 14/11/2017 12:20:32 PM
858 Views
I was assuming they will ignore the Peter Jackson story line and cast
- 14/11/2017 03:30:12 PM
855 Views
Nooo
- 14/11/2017 06:26:01 PM
802 Views
there really isn't a scenario that doesn't have high a likelyhood of sucking
- 15/11/2017 03:14:46 AM
898 Views
You could go with Turin Turamber, And Beren and Luthien. *NM*
- 15/11/2017 02:34:16 PM
514 Views
Beren and Luthien would be great
- 15/11/2017 04:31:33 PM
801 Views
Also, if the network wants to go wild with Trump stand-ins they could do Numenor 
*NM*
- 15/11/2017 02:44:58 PM
507 Views
*NM*
- 15/11/2017 02:44:58 PM
507 Views
In related news, I shouted at the movie screen when a Black Panther preview came on
- 13/11/2017 11:57:58 PM
952 Views
possible theme music
- 14/11/2017 07:34:26 PM
862 Views
I feel I should know this.
- 14/11/2017 10:06:09 PM
843 Views
You got it
- 14/11/2017 11:39:46 PM
775 Views
Whether you're a goblin or whether you're a hobbit you're tired of the rings, tired of the rings *NM*
- 15/11/2017 04:27:12 AM
503 Views
I heard it was going to be a musical
- 14/11/2017 10:28:28 PM
821 Views
I really do love that version of ROTK.
- 14/11/2017 10:53:50 PM
829 Views
It's a guilty pleasure, isn't it?
- 15/11/2017 04:25:23 AM
784 Views
I have no guilt. I'm done with guilt over what I do like and don't like!
- 15/11/2017 01:12:50 PM
967 Views
I have to admit to being worried.
- 15/11/2017 08:46:57 AM
1463 Views
I think we all are. We have been with these characters for decades.
- 15/11/2017 01:15:12 PM
821 Views
Everything I hgave seen says a LOTR not a Hobbit prequel so I don't think you will get any first age
- 15/11/2017 02:42:50 PM
778 Views
Well, The Hobbit is a prequel.
- 15/11/2017 04:33:03 PM
839 Views
It's not really a prequel if it was written before the thing it's a prequel to, is it? *NM*
- 17/11/2017 04:19:35 AM
529 Views
I wish they'd make a Pern series instead.
- 15/11/2017 03:33:46 PM
1151 Views
A Temeraire series would seem easier to sell then "the main enemy is mindless space fungus". *NM*
- 16/11/2017 06:28:12 AM
496 Views