Active Users:2314 Time:01/08/2026 08:19:34 AM
They weren't the owners, that was the Republic/Senate Cannoli Send a noteboard - 19/12/2017 01:38:05 PM

View original post
Clones were slaves modified to not even have the will to resist their bondage.

The Jedi were actually the protectors of the clone soldiers. Not too many exploiters lead their victims from the front, wielding a defensive weapon that protects their supposed victims in the rear.

While the making and exploiting of clones is an abomination, they were already there. Master Dias is the sole owner of guilt in that regard. When it came to the wars, the Jedi's choice was to refuse to lead their slave army, which would not have prevented its deployment, except under the guidance of brand flag officers, in a state with no military tradition or institutional experience, which is a recipe for mass slaughter. At least the Jedi have the guidance of the Force. Accepting leadership of the clone armies is the best thing they can do for the clones, and should have enabled them to prevent abuses of military power or war crimes as well. The real problem for the Jedi is getting involved in the war in the first place, regardless of how it was being fought. That the Republic was willing to deploy slave soldiers to suppress functioning states from exerting their sovereignty should have been a clear warning that this ship of state is absolutely not one to whose mast you should nail your flag. But they did, and that was the cause of their downfall and what made them susceptible to the ploys of Sidious.

Also, in any slave system, the true owner/master of a slave is the one who can order him to murder other accused owner/masters. That would be the Supreme Chancellor, who has no known Jedi constituency.

Also also, free will is arguably a definitive function of a person. If it has no free will, it can't be a person, and therefore, not a slave.

Cannoli
"Sometimes unhinged, sometimes unfair, always entertaining"
- The Crownless

“Tolerance is the virtue of the man without convictions.” GK Chesteron
Deus Vult!
Reply to message
Star Wars E8 - The Last Jedi - Tomorrow!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! - 14/12/2017 06:11:46 PM 1131 Views
Let me know how it ends - 14/12/2017 11:52:15 PM 775 Views
It opened tonight. Just got back from seing it - 15/12/2017 04:57:22 AM 1063 Views
I found it very underwhelming to be honest. - 15/12/2017 06:57:39 PM 1047 Views
But you don't like anything..... *NM* - 15/12/2017 08:14:39 PM 346 Views
very minor spoilers - 15/12/2017 08:43:44 PM 708 Views
Big spoilers. - 16/12/2017 12:55:05 AM 863 Views
I think the two go hand it hand (still spoliers) - 16/12/2017 01:43:00 AM 764 Views
Fair point. - 18/12/2017 06:42:54 PM 843 Views
Agreed with everything you wrote here. - 18/12/2017 12:22:56 PM 773 Views
Well, I hope they are. - 18/12/2017 06:32:29 PM 736 Views
The story being pretty weak? - 15/12/2017 10:03:51 PM 805 Views
Well, in the computer games, for one. - 16/12/2017 12:29:31 AM 739 Views
I have mixed feelings about it. - 18/12/2017 12:18:05 PM 755 Views
I found it confusing, terrible and kind of boring *spoilers* - 16/12/2017 10:41:34 PM 805 Views
I very much agree with this review - 16/12/2017 11:06:55 PM 845 Views
Regarding number 7. - 18/12/2017 12:26:41 PM 832 Views
Good post..... - 18/12/2017 06:37:58 PM 731 Views
Re: Regarding number 7. - 20/12/2017 05:02:11 AM 1207 Views
The Jedi were slave owners - 18/12/2017 01:42:19 PM 704 Views
They weren't the owners, that was the Republic/Senate - 19/12/2017 01:38:05 PM 727 Views
stop making excuses for the slave masters - 19/12/2017 03:22:54 PM 635 Views
They are no different than Eisenhower, MacArthur or Pershing, all of whom led slave soldiers - 20/12/2017 12:09:33 AM 755 Views
draftees are not biologically modified slaves - 20/12/2017 02:49:33 PM 720 Views
No, they're just ill-prepared slaves - 21/12/2017 11:34:02 AM 752 Views
No the Jedi sucked - 21/12/2017 04:18:48 PM 736 Views
Re: No the Jedi sucked - 25/12/2017 03:39:25 AM 726 Views
I got up and walked out. *spoilers* - 18/12/2017 07:48:42 PM 777 Views
I'm confused. - 18/12/2017 08:19:48 PM 731 Views
You may have walked out a bit early... *NM* - 21/12/2017 09:41:00 PM 368 Views
It's kind of hilarious how divided opinion is on this movie... - 18/12/2017 07:53:12 PM 889 Views
That would explain much *NM* - 19/12/2017 07:15:36 AM 426 Views
I really liked it as a deconstruction of Star Wars. - 19/12/2017 10:34:59 PM 806 Views
You're going to have to elaborate on that one... - 19/12/2017 11:22:01 PM 851 Views
Re: You're going to have to elaborate on that one... - 21/12/2017 09:45:09 PM 700 Views
It is JJ Abrams and the idiot critics love him - 20/12/2017 02:51:06 PM 765 Views
Abrams didn't do this film. Rian did. *NM* - 21/12/2017 09:46:21 PM 393 Views
It's not real opinion that's divided. - 20/12/2017 02:59:59 PM 946 Views
Did anyone else think... *spoilers* - 20/12/2017 05:04:44 AM 1191 Views
Well it was original fan-fic...first half tedious, second half quite enjoyable - 21/12/2017 06:14:35 AM 946 Views

Reply to Message