Active Users:615 Time:22/05/2026 07:14:52 PM
Well, as for the part about young navelgazing characters... Legolas Send a noteboard - 29/01/2018 03:23:47 PM

View original postAnd the new style of fantasy is one of the things I dislike. I wanted to like the new Brandon Sanderson series but I found myself asking why when I am struggling to finish the third 1000+ page book when so little has actually happened that I care about. I don't need an in-depth back story on everyone one mentioned in the book and I don't need a half dozen central protagonist. If I want to read slow developing story line which focus on complex character development there is a good literature out there that I can read instead genre pulp fiction. This is coming form someone who actually enjoyed read The Sillmarillion.

Yeah, I can understand that.
View original postScience fiction has become stories of pretty twenty somethings struggling with their romance issue in a dystopian world that makes absolutely no sense and fantasy has become epic stories which focus on world building and developing as many characters as possible but where very little actually happens. Fantasy and science fiction used to be faced paced action stories and now they are bellybutton gazing romances where the fantasy has very little plot and science fiction has no science.

As for the age thing, though, I thought one of the more interesting aspects of the book is the many older PoV characters - including Simon, Miriamele, Eolair - and how they look back on the past, as well as how they interact with the younger ones. Clash of generations is very much a theme here, between various groups of characters. You may well say he's overdoing it with the PoVs because even within one geographical location / one main plotline, he goes for three or four PoVs rather than just one or two. But that does have its benefits in some ways, including this one - Simon and Miriamele's grandson Morgan may be a whiny teenager who seems to care for little but booze and women, but by reading about it from Simon's PoV, Miriamele's, his own, his sister's,... you get a more nuanced picture.
Reply to message
Review: Tad Williams' The Witchwood Crown - 28/01/2018 04:04:36 PM 510 Views
Great review - 29/01/2018 12:20:08 PM 317 Views
I didn't read the novella - looking at the summary, I'd say you don't really need to. - 29/01/2018 03:35:49 PM 310 Views
Sanderson is good. I like his work. - 30/01/2018 03:36:34 PM 282 Views
being old I dislike most new things - 29/01/2018 02:06:29 PM 306 Views
Well, as for the part about young navelgazing characters... - 29/01/2018 03:23:47 PM 320 Views
I did really like the first series - 29/01/2018 03:39:38 PM 289 Views

Reply to Message