View original post
I started reading WOT after LoC was out and by the time I completed it, CoS was out. Looking back, obviously, LoC was the zenith of WOT. It was a remarkable series up until then.
Actually, at the time, I thought of LoC the way you think of WH below (absent the factor of disappointing books prior - I'd call tSR & tFoH the high point). Somewhat of a letdown, with an awesome ending scene (way better than WH's ending for my money - WH's high note is all about what the accomplishment represents than anything about the Cleansing in particular).
CoS was solid, but a step down. Had no problem with it, it had some set-up, but that was to be expected after DW and the end of 6. After a 2+ year wait, PoD was a huge disappointment. All set-up and barely any Rand. It was pretty bad. But okay, one clunker is forgivable.
That stuff, though, was some of Rand's best in the series. The whole Altaran campaign was, I thought, Rand's best plot in the latter half of the series.
Then came WH, which was once again mostly set-up and bad, but with a cool ending. It made me feel better about the series. Even though it was a long wait for a mostly boring book, the cleasing was a huge moment and it was great to read.
See, I enjoyed a lot of the other stuff enough that when Rand set out to begin the Cleansing, I was like "Oh, right. He said he was going to do that." I was more interested in the outcome of that event than the process. I really like Mat's & Elayne's stories in Winter's Heart.
And then, the worst book ever written in the English language came out. It was breathtaking in its awfulness. So even though looking back, the series jumped the shark in PoD, book 10 is what crushed my WOT spirit and soul.
I don't actually think it was bad. I might have been disappointed in the overall advancement of the story, but there was a lot of good stuff in there. Mat & Perrin could have moved further along their tracks, but OTOH, he did need to slow down to make some progress with Tuon and RJ really did blunder by linking up the timeline of three different PoVs. Largely, I think, because it doesn't mean very much to Mat or Perrin. We should have seen the effect among the two contending Aes Sedai factions who don't have Elayne throwing cold water on their panic and in the Black Tower. Elayne's plot in the book ends right before she might have been in a position to look into the latter and Egwene's comes up after the reaction is over and done. It would have been at least more interesting than Mat or Perrin blowing off their Aes Sedai companions. And it was in Egwene's plot that the Cleansing was best served, because we had jumped ahead, to where the sisters have found out what they can, and are now truly acting based on their mistaken beliefs. It was a consequential response to the Cleansing and the first, and maybe only, such we see and it worked perfectly with one of the major themes of WoT, regarding mistaken belief and reactions to it.
My buddy wrote this review, I can't say it any better:
Your buddy sucks.
Those who can appreciate great setup will really love this book. Personally, I thought the setup in books 8 and 9 were good ... but this was absolutely stupendous. Fans of total plot inertia will be in heaven.
It was a character book, not a plot one. But, yeah, it was a set up book, carrying on all the arcs that started in WH and concluded in KoD. The siege of Caemlyn, the attack on the White Tower, Mat's relationship with Tuon and Perrin vs Shaido.
Have you ever wondered how many stripes should be on the dublet of an important dignatary from Illian?
At least I can spell all the words in that sentence.
How many shawl twitches are appropriate when Aes Sedai negotiate momentous agreements? What kind of stool the general of an Aes Sedai army sits on, and how stable said stool might be? Well buckle up for a wild ride, amigo, because you're going to learn all that (and more!) by the time you've tediously slogged to the conclusion of this book.
It's details, and the details are what hooked you to get in this far. There're no fewer or more details in CoT than any other book. Considerably fewer, I am sure, because it's shorter, than tSR or tFoH.
Part of what really makes Mr. Jordan's worlds so unique are the wonderful characters which populate them. I like nothing more than to scratch my head in befuddlement as yet another Aes Sedai is reintroduced into the plot whom I can no longer recall.
So you admit your memory is the real problem here.
For anyone who wants to play along the rules are simple:
1.) Is the character you're looking up totally irrelevent? Take a drink.
2.) Do you have reason to suspect said character will remain totally irrelevent? Take a drink.
3.) Does the character twitch her shawl? Take two drinks.
4.) Is she looking "cross-eyed" at someone? Take a drink.
5.) Do you know the exact design of the embroidery on the fringe of her shawl? Of course you do - take a drink. For your own sanity, consider taking another.
Oh, wow. Five things that aren't true or didn't happen.
First off, Nynaeve is completely ignored. I suspect Mr. Jordan will make up for this oversite by indulging in an orgy of braid-tugging, yellow-shawled action in books 11-16, but you will be blessedly free of it in this tome.
Why does anyone bother if they don't like Nynaeve? They have no soul.
Secondly, Jordan has stopped even pretending to provide "setup" for future books with CoT. Nothing Of Any Signifigance happens - at all - in this novel. Nothing. There's not so much as a cliffhanger.
This is why everyone hated it - because it WAS cliffhangers! Perrin and Rand were about to sit down with who we thought were the penultimate bad guys, the guys chasing Mat, and whom the other half the main characters could never accept as friends. Egwene had just been captured. The stakes were ramped up for the Black Ajah conflict in the Tower and the Black Tower conflict and Ituralde's campaign both began. How do you miss all this stuff?
I can't wait for Volume 11.
I don't see how he ever appreciated it, since apparently it was full of nothing but random things taking place which came out of nowhere.