Active Users:303 Time:01/08/2025 07:32:35 AM
That's rather easier said than done though. Legolas Send a noteboard - 31/05/2025 08:12:34 PM

View original postIt's been confirmed that Mazrim Taim was supposed to be Demandred, but Jordan threw a tantrum like a five year old because everyone figured out what he naively thought was less obvious than it was.

Heh. That is childish indeed, though it wouldn't have made that much difference to the plot of the later books as far as I can see... excepting some very last minute shenanigans with the Sharans, if I remember the name right, Demandred was still mostly concerned with the Black Tower anyway even if he was a separate person from Taim.
View original postIf you really want to do Wheel of Time justice, you have to shit can everything after Lord of Chaos, the last fairly decent book in the series, and write 3 - and only 3 - books of Lord of Chaos length that finishes the series without all the superfluous horse names, interminably long "Faile is a prisoner of the Shaido" chapters, and make Mazrim Taim Demandred. THAT would be worth reading, if the right author could be persuaded. He could take chunks of what Jordan did write and then redo the Sanderson parts.

Think about it though, how many epic fantasy series of a scope remotely comparable to WoT do you know that were finished within the intended timeframe and without a serious drop in quality? The Malazan series, maybe, though some will argue about the quality, but that one had a different approach where it was never really telling a single story with a clear beginning and end anyway, so much easier to stop at any given point. Not many others.

It's much, much more difficult to satisfactorily conclude a series of that nature than to start it up, as we've also seen with Song of Ice and Fire, or as I already mentioned in an earlier reply writers like Rothfuss and Lynch who had immensely successful starts of series, twenty years ago, but are still stuck even today and probably won't ever finish them.

Of course there's tons of completed fantasy series with no obvious drop in quality, starting with LotR, but those are generally either shorter series with fewer main characters and plotlines, or longer series with a succession of shorter story arcs or even stand-alone books, rather than one huge epic arc.

In other words, what you say may make sense in theory, but in practice I'm not convinced there is anybody that could've done that.

Reply to message
Critical question, now that we've seen the show flop and get cancelled... - 25/05/2025 09:55:51 AM 420 Views
I don't really think anybody would be interested anymore... - 25/05/2025 09:07:34 PM 302 Views
Jordan knew he was going to pass away for quite a while..... - 26/05/2025 02:31:32 AM 287 Views
Ultra-long series have always been anomalous. - 26/05/2025 04:06:36 AM 294 Views
I'll have you know... - 26/05/2025 05:48:32 PM 287 Views
Re: I'll have you know... - 26/05/2025 11:05:02 PM 275 Views
even I knew to start with Gideon *NM* - 26/05/2025 11:11:18 PM 99 Views
Bah, it's been a while. I meant Gideon. *NM* - 27/05/2025 04:43:08 PM 104 Views
My nephew is listening to it just now - 26/05/2025 02:32:13 PM 279 Views
*NM* - 26/05/2025 05:44:27 PM 90 Views
Sanderson did a wonderful job with the final novels. - 26/05/2025 02:29:07 AM 298 Views
I feel the exact opposite - 26/05/2025 02:30:25 PM 298 Views
Re: I feel the exact opposite - 26/05/2025 10:26:46 PM 284 Views
Re: I feel the exact opposite - 27/05/2025 12:23:06 PM 284 Views
And FYI..... - 26/05/2025 02:34:43 AM 292 Views
Have fun with the interminable flashbacks in the next two clunkers, bud. - 26/05/2025 03:57:33 AM 278 Views
You seem to have some unusual rage directed towards Sanderson - 30/05/2025 11:05:58 PM 279 Views
I am so sick of hearing about how Sanderson saved WoT - 27/05/2025 09:58:45 PM 358 Views
I knew I'd find a kindred spirit in you, at least. - 28/05/2025 05:18:07 AM 275 Views
You would have to go back and fix the problems Jordan himself created - 30/05/2025 02:42:20 AM 289 Views
Very true. The series jumped the shark..... - 30/05/2025 11:10:33 PM 283 Views
That's rather easier said than done though. - 31/05/2025 08:12:34 PM 289 Views
No shit. In other news, the earth is a sphere. *NM* - 02/06/2025 03:02:05 PM 92 Views

Reply to Message