I'm entirely open to the idea that WF isn't a SK, but if anything, his Watcher claim set off alarm bells in my head because it was such a 'safe claim'. Why are you surprised no one has counter-claimed? I can't even remember us ever having a watcher role in play, if he'd claimed Tracker or something, yeah, I'd buy it, we've had those roughly half the games so no one wants to fake claim it, too risky, but Watcher? Just like Lie Detector, its so uncommon in the game series its safe, minimal risk of a counter-claim.

Normally, you'd react to this like I did. Its seems weird to me that him claiming Watcher like this not only draws no extra suspicion on him from you, but does the exact opposite. The role doesn't fit the character, maybe that's the norm but I'd like to get some vocal support of that before I brush aside what seems in of itself to smell funky. I'm also noticing a very close connection between one of the major characters you claim and Deadpool. Seriously, what has he said that could possibly have just waved away your doubts? "Yes, I am as Isaac suspected a character best known for homicidal tendencies and an alignment of chaotic neutral, I, a bad ass killing machine who is generally considered utterly insane by everyone, including myself, happen to have an investigative role that everyone recognizes but is very rarely used" Seriously, how can you possibly have adopted a "Oh, okay, he must be innocent" attitude about this? You take as a given that a dangerously paranoid character known to kill first and ask questions never can not possibly be a SK but is instead a Watcher? If I had to pick roles to fit the mercenary-assassin Deadpool, it would be Survivor or Serial Killer, watcher? Not likely, I doubt our roles perfectly match our characters but until someone shows some evidence otherwise I expect them to at least seem logical, mine is. I mean listing Cyclops as a role I wouldn't pick 'mason' of the top of my head but 'mason with these other X-men' would make sense, etc. Note that while WF listed his RC, he didn't give some flavor fluff paraphrase of why he has this ability, like "The Mod gave me the SPLOG, and I'm the cop".

Seriously, which of these two scenarios makes more sense -

1. Beet assigned the role of watcher to a character it really doesn't fit

2. White Flame is a SK and didn't know his character selections would so blatantly out him as a SK, on getting hit with it decided he needs to pick a RC to survive the low lynch thresh-hold of day 1 and picks a well-known but rarely used investigative role.

Now, if we go forward with the 'does your character match your role?' questioning and a bunch of people say no, and it starts looking like Beet essentially randomly assigned major characters to pre-designed roles, then it might be a different story but I think we should be looking into that first.