Basically, no DF would possibly say "Dark" when everyone else was saying "Light." Sure, it could be some double-bluff thing (I guess Hobo is pretty experienced?), but it seems more likely that the light had nothing to do with alignment, and the DFs just panicked.

Gher MAY be innocent, but his strategy reeks of divide-and-conquer tactics: He gets everyone going after a red herring, like the light/dark thing. Meanwhile, GHER of course knows who is and is not a darkfriend, so when he starts going after someone (ie, Hobo), his allies will suddenly start going, "Oh, right! Er, Hobo! Evil! Kill! Burn the Witch!"



I think we should nail Gher- he's the only one who's really been acting suspicious thus far.