That category is highly important. Discussion on strategy (what kind of questions do you ask, who do you suspect, etc) are essential to get forward. Discussion of the theme is also important: in the last game, anyone who added something about B5 lore would have contributed, as this helps people understand what kind of situation we have. In this game, it has helped determine that asking for coded names is not likely to help, as the scummers are not likely to lie anyway, and if they lie the odds of choosing the same name as someone else are infinitely low. It's not like we have a limited number of names (i.e.: the Scoobies, the cast from the Phantom) to choose from. Discussion of game mechanics might be a grey area, I agree, but is still helpful. I counted any discussion on the scum/town ratio for example.

In addition, your list has many people with only 1 or 2 posts. There is no way of distinguishing between those people. ST was discounted, as we try not to Lynch newbies on their first Day, unless they are caught in a lie or some such.

I would say, especially since the number of posts has more than doubled (indeed: poor Danny...), that the analysis can be done again, and that category E can be split in several groups. However, I'm not going to do that now, since there is more than enough to go on for now. But please be my guest. I have it from reliable information that you have some spare time.

That said: after Fox asked for more info, we have now heard from you and Hobo. I'm missing several: Yuna, Praziquantel, ranagrande, Sacrilicious Toast (+ Dannymac who's RBIRL). Please let us know your thoughts!