Active Users:268 Time:06/05/2024 04:41:59 AM
Definitely big maybes. DomA Send a noteboard - 26/06/2013 04:51:29 PM

View original postI just have a hard time believing Tyrion will safe the day in the big finale and die in the book (or vice versa).

That sort of thing could well happen. Martin is a "discoverer" who outlines but also leaves himself plenty of leeway to follow the characters where they want to go as he writes. The fate of characters in finales is most often determined by what feels right dramatically and often gets changed at the last minute (take RJ for instance. His notes outlined a few deaths, and had an end point for characters who survived, but he also left a lot of "I might do either" and it was left to Sanderson to decide). It's highly possible the show writers have different needs than Martin does for specific episodes toward the end, especially when you consider the fact the show's final conflict will be seriously limited in "epic scope" and will have to find other ways to provide great drama worthy of an 8-season build up.

Martin said HBO has an outline "without all the bells and whistles", which I took as a kind of reassurance to his readers that if HBO has to go their own way, their ending will follow the general outline for his final conflict but will not ruin all the book's twists and turns as in part they're created as he writes.

Of course I think everyone (incl. Bantam and HBO) hopes Martin finishes up in time and there's no need for a different last season to the TV series.

It would be a mess no matter what. Either it will be too close to the books and spoil them for the readers, or there will be many changes and it will be very distracting when you read (as it's far more introspective and active than watching a show... you have much more time to think), or people will get pissed off by the different outcomes in some arcs.


Your scheduling ideas of how it could end up working out after all make sense, but they rely on a lot of things: HBO waiting a little or even greenlighting a movie and Martin finishing Dream of Spring only two years after Winds.

More like almost three years, or more if he releases WOW in 2015 and does take too long a break before starting work on ADOS, but yeah it's definitely all very speculative.

The speed at which Martin writes varies a lot - four to six years per novel as happened with the problematic AFFC/ADWD is hardly his average writing speed even for ASOIAF.

I'm sure they're far more concerned at the moment with finding the most interesting ways not to get bogged down with the expansion the series saw with AFFC/ADWD than bothering about what they might or not have to do down the line if TWOW runs late, let alone if ADOS does.

This message last edited by DomA on 26/06/2013 at 04:54:24 PM
Reply to message
Future of Game of Thrones? - 23/06/2013 04:20:50 AM 922 Views
I believe this has been accounted for. - 23/06/2013 04:55:44 PM 668 Views
That would be quite an interesting dynamic..... - 23/06/2013 07:38:46 PM 654 Views
As a fan of the books ... - 24/06/2013 02:56:27 AM 805 Views
Re: As a fan of the books ... - 25/06/2013 03:53:32 AM 644 Views
Why would Tywin recognize Arya? - 26/06/2013 04:14:38 AM 648 Views
Re: Why would Tywin recognize Arya? - 29/06/2013 06:57:09 AM 546 Views
It may be a minority, but I feel the same way *NM* - 24/06/2013 02:08:42 AM 269 Views
I love the books, but.. - 24/06/2013 12:49:14 PM 680 Views
That's a valid concern. - 24/06/2013 05:09:23 PM 697 Views
Re: That's a valid concern. - 24/06/2013 10:06:19 PM 616 Views
Re: That's a valid concern. - 25/06/2013 03:56:18 AM 570 Views
Re: That's a valid concern. - 26/06/2013 02:00:09 AM 692 Views
Ug this would stink... - 29/06/2013 07:02:38 AM 565 Views
Re: Ug this would stink... - 29/06/2013 04:36:53 PM 542 Views
Whatever they do they better not cut two of my favorite scenes - 29/06/2013 11:53:25 PM 595 Views
Maybe. - 25/06/2013 11:53:28 AM 542 Views
Definitely big maybes. - 26/06/2013 04:51:29 PM 630 Views
Re: Future of Game of Thrones? - 24/06/2013 08:13:58 PM 602 Views
I'm not bothered if they have to finish the series pre-7 - 26/06/2013 04:03:40 AM 718 Views
Re: I'm not bothered if they have to finish the series pre-7 - 26/06/2013 02:46:31 PM 571 Views
Re: I'm not bothered if they have to finish the series pre-7 - 29/06/2013 07:05:59 AM 598 Views
This is the state of play as it stands now (spoilers from the books) - 29/06/2013 11:22:32 AM 700 Views

Reply to Message