Active Users:172 Time:17/05/2024 10:43:32 AM
Re: I thought that at first, for Luke Duke Send a noteboard - 19/04/2015 06:41:09 AM

View original post
But a few have remarked to me that looking more closely the hand/arm look too small to be Hamill's (it looks like a woman... THAT could be Carrie Fisher), while what you suggested was a shot of Leia I rather think is a shot of the young female lead receiving the lightsaber.

It could make sense.. .Leia got post ROTJ a lightsaber from Luke which she never trained with/used, but as she suddenly senses the Force in her daughter and sends her to find the reclusive Luke to convince him to train her/return to Leia because the force is "awakening", she gives her the lightsaber That would be very SW... if the lead/jedi trainee character is the girl, then the "quest giver" figure (ie: the Ben character, if you wish) needs to be her mother or a mother figure, sending her to "Yoda" (Luke). This would also be a replay of ANH to an extent, with Leia sending someone on a mission, with R2.

It wouldn't be too mythological for that figure to be a man, for a girl hero. It would also make sense for Lucas to have toyed with the idea of a female lead for the last trilogy, as the Hero's journey and its archetypes are different for women, and unlike the male ones with the OT/PT, he had not exhausted them yet with Leia and Padmé.


Plausible. But, if as you say "Leia got post ROTJ a lightsaber from Luke which she never trained with/used" why would she have a mechanical hand? Loss of limbs seems to generally occur in the SW universe during lightsaber combat. Also, is it likely that another Skywalker member loses their right hand? (As I type that question, I think the answer is that's it wouldn't be out of the realm of possibility.)

I just think that with the voice-over speaking about Anakin as they show Vader's mask, it makes sense that as Luke is talking about himself the scene would show himself, and the same with Leia.

Reply to message
New trailer for Star Wars 7; looks legitimate - 16/04/2015 10:38:46 PM 835 Views
My goodness that looks like the original trilogy so much! - 16/04/2015 10:53:00 PM 504 Views
just that Luke is gay - 19/04/2015 10:44:14 PM 495 Views
Re: New trailer for Star Wars 7; looks legitimate - 17/04/2015 04:07:20 AM 572 Views
Very good educated speculation..... - 19/04/2015 05:28:50 PM 553 Views
I hope they keep giving away as little as possible - 17/04/2015 10:05:45 AM 507 Views
It looks like they will - 18/04/2015 02:17:45 AM 557 Views
Re: It looks like they will - 18/04/2015 07:10:18 PM 567 Views
I thought that at first, for Luke - 19/04/2015 01:55:25 AM 622 Views
Re: I thought that at first, for Luke - 19/04/2015 06:41:09 AM 623 Views
Re: I thought that at first, for Luke - 20/04/2015 03:13:46 AM 665 Views

Reply to Message