Active Users:163 Time:20/05/2024 07:13:35 PM
Re: Nynaeve's new ability Datakim Send a noteboard - 18/11/2010 10:27:47 PM

Nynaeve can Heal the taint. This isn't a new ability despite what some people think.

EoTW (Dragonmount) - "A pity for you... that one of your Sisters is not here. I was never very skilled at Healing... but even one of them could only give you a few lucid minutes."


It is curious that Ishy claims that he is NOT skilled at healing. I wonder if maybe the damage caused by the taint can be more easily sensed and reversed through the use of the True Power, since it basically comes from the same source as the taint itself.

Nynaeve only saw the darkness after she became really experienced at delving. I wonder if the taint was basically some form of TP compulsion. I seem to recall that Graendal mentioned that TP weaves could be sensed by another TP user. That might explain how even the unskilled at healing Ishamael could heal LTT. He did not need to delve for the taint, as a TP channeler he could just see it outright.


Rand is shocked that Nynaeve can Heal the taint and he says that even in his Age, diseases of the mind were very hard to cure. That said, Lews Therin has no knowledge of the taint and the efforts to cure it, considering he was the first man ever to go insane.


There is also the question of whether or not the taint can truly be said to be a real kind of mental illness. As Nynaeve herself thinks, the taint seems to be more like the Dark Ones compulsion, than it is an actual mental illness such as Alzheimer's disease or the like. And since Nynaeve does not explain to Rand how the taint works, he would have no way of knowing that its basically closer to removing compulsion and that he arguably helped Nynaeve do it by explaining to her how compulsion is removed. Odds are that ironically, healing ordinary and natural forms of madness would be much harder.


It seems that very gifted Healers could probably remove the effect from a tainted male just like Nynaeve did. The problem is that the taint still existed on saidin, and within minutes of being Healed they would become tainted again. Its more than likely that they were even more open to the taint after being tainted once, and thus their ability to buy the man only a few lucid minutes. It thus became a self-limiting and futile exercise. In Nynaeve's case it's a wonderous cure, and in their case a silly one considering the disease was waiting to reinfest the man again.


It does seem likely that this is the explanation. Not discounting Nynaeves accomplishments, but what she did was basically pretty simple in the end. All that was required was sufficient experience in delving to sense the darkness(likely very common amongst the more skilled restorers), dexterity to remove the thorns and heal them(seemed pretty easy), and knowledge on how to remove compulsion with a counterweave (which was commonly known since even LTT/Rand who is poor at healing knew it to teach it to Nynaeve in tGS). It is simply impossible to accept that with all the Aes Sedai around, and everyone looking for a solution or cure for the taint, not a single restorer could do all those simple things that Nynaeve did.

It has to be a case where there is maybe some residual damage even after healing which causes the taint to drive you into insanity extremely rapidly as you say. Or, maybe the taint in someones mind would be connected somehow to the taint in saidin, and if saidin had not been cleansed the taint in peoples heads could not have been so easily removed. The bottom line is that either Nynaeves feat is only possibly thanks to the cleansing, or this is a massive plothole.

This might be a good question to ask BS actually.

Hmm. Then again, there is another more disturbing possibility. Where did the taint go? We know that during the cleansing, the taint in saidin was destroyed only since it was consumed by its opposite, the evil of Shadar Logoth. Did the taint in Naeff's mind really disappear into nothingness? Or did it perhaps go somewhere else. The whole reason saidin was tainted was because LTT touched the DO with saidin. What power did Nynaeve touch the taint with again? :) If Nynaeve goes insane from the taint in the last book, I called it! ;)
Reply to message
Nynaeve's new ability - 18/11/2010 01:41:38 PM 1506 Views
Nynaeve's healing seems more permanent, though. - 18/11/2010 02:19:06 PM 767 Views
Re: Nynaeve's healing seems more permanent, though. - 18/11/2010 02:59:17 PM 652 Views
Re: Nynaeve's healing seems more permanent, though. - 18/11/2010 10:51:02 PM 562 Views
Re: Nynaeve's healing seems more permanent, though. - 19/11/2010 09:37:23 AM 501 Views
Re: Nynaeve's healing seems more permanent, though. - 19/11/2010 02:37:37 PM 544 Views
Training kills spontaneous innovation - 19/11/2010 05:47:10 PM 451 Views
Re: Training kills spontaneous innovation - 20/11/2010 10:19:38 AM 500 Views
That's not my interpretation. - 18/11/2010 06:14:02 PM 675 Views
Re: That's not my interpretation. - 18/11/2010 07:11:02 PM 515 Views
Even if we were to accept that as true... - 18/11/2010 10:55:31 PM 469 Views
Maybe... - 18/11/2010 11:18:08 PM 433 Views
Could be... - 19/11/2010 03:01:35 AM 448 Views
None. - 19/11/2010 03:20:35 AM 460 Views
As you wish. - 19/11/2010 05:24:29 AM 443 Views
We're told exactly the opposite... - 19/11/2010 05:47:31 AM 496 Views
Exactly. - 19/11/2010 06:02:52 AM 453 Views
What are you arguing? - 19/11/2010 06:50:58 AM 444 Views
Though I dread doing this, perhaps an analogy? - 19/11/2010 06:16:30 PM 453 Views
You were right to dread... - 19/11/2010 10:02:05 PM 486 Views
Re: You were right to dread... - 20/11/2010 06:25:53 PM 465 Views
Re: You were right to dread... - 20/11/2010 08:18:53 PM 541 Views
Re: You were right to dread... - 21/11/2010 11:34:28 PM 571 Views
Re: You were right to dread... - 22/11/2010 08:36:24 AM 556 Views
Re: You were right to dread... - 22/11/2010 07:32:04 PM 551 Views
Re: Nynaeve's new ability - 18/11/2010 10:27:47 PM 778 Views
LTT was correct. - 18/11/2010 11:12:52 PM 674 Views
except, as noted, the taint was constantly reoccuring - 23/11/2010 08:09:08 PM 393 Views
Hmm. I think we don't have enough information. - 19/11/2010 07:40:30 PM 517 Views

Reply to Message