Active Users:4140 Time:14/09/2026 12:46:45 AM
Re: The One Power: Sanderson's serious lack of understanding of the concept... RugbyPlayingAshaman Send a noteboard - 05/02/2013 02:54:58 PM

View original postThere is so much wrong with Sanderson's handling of the One Power in Memory of Light, but in a nutshell, what grates the most is his apparent belief that the strength of your willpower is directly related to how far you can "stretch" your strength limit in an emergency situation.

So much so that if a character is just "determined" enough, he or she can resist shielding attempts by sa'angreal wielding foes, or handle a running battle against entire circles of linked channelers etc.

Basically, if your need or desperation is great enough, you can launch dramatic ripostes against vastly overwhelming strength levels to drag out a fight until an advantage opens up to you.

This is in no way similar to the Cyndane situation at the Cleansing, where only vastly superior skill, knowledge and precision allowed Cyndane to resist Alivia's angreal enhanced strength.

The examples from aMoL are numerous, but essentially, various characters - on both sides of the Light/Shadow spectrum - survive vastly overpowering Power assaults simply through desperate last minute "parries" or sheer, bloody minded determination not to be shielded.

It is so jarring that it makes a mockery of the entire book. By his logic, Sorilea should be able to resist being shielded by Moghedien, simply because of her willpower.

He really has no concept, has he.


I had a mini-theory suggesting that strength and OP limitations had more to do with a block than anything else, so most channeler's limits have more to do with not needing to risk losing control as they clearly can exceed the amount that is safe for them to tap into - part of the initial lessons learned during the Novice years is how dangerously easy it can be to exceed your safe limits.

"Those who think they have no time for bodily exercise will sooner or later have to find time for illness."
This message last edited by RugbyPlayingAshaman on 03/06/2013 at 03:48:55 PM
Reply to message
The One Power: Sanderson's serious lack of understanding of the concept... - 31/01/2013 08:57:24 AM 1980 Views
Dont get me started - 31/01/2013 11:46:41 AM 1358 Views
Re: The One Power: Sanderson's serious lack of understanding of the concept... - 31/01/2013 01:28:07 PM 1302 Views
That is utterly incorrect. Rand's case is an evolutionary next step which doesn't apply in general.. - 31/01/2013 01:42:09 PM 1239 Views
Sorry, but it's not utterly incorrect. You can no more disprove it than I can prove it - 31/01/2013 01:49:11 PM 1295 Views
Channelers physically burn out when they exceed their limits. That's the proof. - 31/01/2013 01:52:50 PM 1064 Views
Re: Channelers physically burn out when they exceed their limits. That's the proof. - 31/01/2013 01:58:17 PM 1164 Views
Sorry. But that is simply an escape clause for Sanderson to change whatever rules he wants... - 31/01/2013 01:59:29 PM 1138 Views
Re: Sorry. But that is simply an escape clause for Sanderson to change whatever rules he wants... - 31/01/2013 02:11:26 PM 1164 Views
No, he did a crap job - 31/01/2013 02:19:18 PM 1087 Views
Re: No, he did a crap job - 31/01/2013 02:20:33 PM 1008 Views
Your level of satisfaction will inversely correlate to your depth of understanding of the nuances... - 31/01/2013 02:24:09 PM 1048 Views
LMAO - 31/01/2013 02:46:11 PM 1128 Views
As to that... - 31/01/2013 02:55:14 PM 1172 Views
Also the number of times Forsaken level channelers flung protagonists around with "Air weaves"... - 31/01/2013 02:18:05 PM 1212 Views
Sure, but - 31/01/2013 02:19:46 PM 1102 Views
Oh don't get me started on "Air weaves"...(1,2,3, and "start" ) - 01/02/2013 12:02:48 AM 1291 Views
I'm not so sure.. - 01/02/2013 12:30:57 AM 1258 Views
Re: The One Power: Sanderson's serious lack of understanding of the concept... - 05/02/2013 02:54:58 PM 1156 Views

Reply to Message