hmm... what a great question 
e. Galgan (I include my estimate for percent chance of others)
RabidWombat Send a noteboard - 05/10/2009 05:09:55 AM
e. Galgan (I include my estimate for percent chance of others)
RabidWombat Send a noteboard - 05/10/2009 05:09:55 AM
I usually don't like answering my own quick surveys; I would rather listen to what others say. This one was too irresistible, though.
a. Rand
No! Rand will be to busy with other stuff. He is too much of an analogy with FDR to be the equivalent to Eisenhower.
b. Mat
5 % chance: Tactics are best left to field generals not to the overall commander. His connection to the Empress may give him enough clout.
c. Perrin
15 % chance: Diplomatic skills and an ability to come up with an innovative large scale battle plan makes Perrin a logical choice as does his connections to the dragon reborn and his cooperation with the Seancen.
d. Bashere
15% Chance. He has negotiated with the Seanchen and his the requisite skills. The something dark that Min sees hurts his chances, though.
e. Galgan
30% Chance. The Seanchen will want one of their own in control. Chances are he knows his stuff and will be accepted by everybody.
f. Tylee
2% Chance. A darkhorse, but she is willing to work with the other side and something could happen to Galgan.
g. Logain
20% Chance. Min sees great glory in his future.
h. Rotation of great generals
0% Chance. It didn't work for the Aiel war.
i. Itulralde
2% another Dark horse
j. none
0% Someone will have to take some control even if it is for only a short time.
k. other
11% I forgot about Rhuarc and the other great general (the one in Shienar)
RabidWombat
a. Rand
No! Rand will be to busy with other stuff. He is too much of an analogy with FDR to be the equivalent to Eisenhower.
b. Mat
5 % chance: Tactics are best left to field generals not to the overall commander. His connection to the Empress may give him enough clout.
c. Perrin
15 % chance: Diplomatic skills and an ability to come up with an innovative large scale battle plan makes Perrin a logical choice as does his connections to the dragon reborn and his cooperation with the Seancen.
d. Bashere
15% Chance. He has negotiated with the Seanchen and his the requisite skills. The something dark that Min sees hurts his chances, though.
e. Galgan
30% Chance. The Seanchen will want one of their own in control. Chances are he knows his stuff and will be accepted by everybody.
f. Tylee
2% Chance. A darkhorse, but she is willing to work with the other side and something could happen to Galgan.
g. Logain
20% Chance. Min sees great glory in his future.
h. Rotation of great generals
0% Chance. It didn't work for the Aiel war.
i. Itulralde
2% another Dark horse
j. none
0% Someone will have to take some control even if it is for only a short time.
k. other
11% I forgot about Rhuarc and the other great general (the one in Shienar)
RabidWombat
Who will be the Captain General over all of the forces of the light during TG (quick survey)
- 05/10/2009 04:52:04 AM
1590 Views
hmm... what a great question e. Galgan (I include my estimate for percent chance of others)
- 05/10/2009 05:09:55 AM
674 Views
e. Galgan (I include my estimate for percent chance of others)
- 05/10/2009 05:09:55 AM
674 Views
You assume there will only be two armies: A vs. B. I think there will never be just two armies
- 05/10/2009 05:03:14 PM
618 Views
Re: Who will be the Captain General over all of the forces of the light during TG (quick survey)
- 05/10/2009 05:27:32 AM
807 Views
Mat's skills are better used by him being a field-general I think.
- 05/10/2009 05:54:29 AM
654 Views
Re: Who will be the Captain General over all of the forces of the light during TG (quick survey)
- 05/10/2009 10:22:17 AM
605 Views
Re: Who will be the Captain General over all of the forces of the light during TG (quick survey)
- 05/10/2009 05:19:46 PM
628 Views
What if Mat invent new non-channeling weapons instead of leading armie?
- 05/10/2009 06:24:18 PM
624 Views
None. There will be several battles and the light will have a different leader in each battle. *NM*
- 05/10/2009 02:09:12 PM
296 Views
As I already said above...
- 05/10/2009 03:23:50 PM
657 Views