Active Users:271 Time:03/05/2024 07:56:51 PM
Re: And some other counter-arguments Tamyrlin Send a noteboard - 24/11/2009 03:22:36 AM
RJ said once that he would probably reveal who killed Asmo in the PoV of the killer. That would mean an Eelfinn PoV, and by chance that is Asmo's killer. Doesn't seem that likely and obvious.

Plus, RJ said that the DO couldn't transmigrate Asmo, because of how he died AND where he died. Usually Balefire alone would prevent transmigration. There is no reason to believe that the Finn used a weak balefire ter'angreal.

Besides that, shortly before Lanfear fell through the doorway, she wanted to kill Rand and his girls. She still wants to kill Rand in WH. Why should - only a bit later - her priority be to wish for Asmo's death?

Finally, that Cyndane says she was held by the Finn probably indicates that they captured her and she didn't get any wishes. Otherwise she could have wished freedom like Mat did. Apparently Moiraine also didn't get any wishes, since she knew beforehand that she would fall into Finnland, but is still imprisoned.


Sorry,Etzel, meant to get back to this earlier - in essence I agree that the a Finn Assassin is highly unlikely mostly because no one has been talking about it yet we've been told that the answer is out there and has been discussed. That being said, I don't believe it would be hard to get a PoV at the very least from the Finn leadership or from Cyndane regarding what the Finns did (can you post the quote that RJ said he was likely going to use the PoV, I can't remember reading that one).

Technically, while a devious way to explain balefire, where and how is well how balefire works. It kills someone by burning out their thread from the Pattern therefore affecting "where" that individual died. RJ has said that a small enough burst of balefire would not be enough time to prevent the DO from transmigrating a soul, so a small burst of balefire would not be enough. Therefore, balefire still fits the where/how quote.

As to what Lanfear would do if given the chance, after being burned out (if that happened) is difficult to pin point. She meant for Asmodean to die, that was always part of her plan. Why would she leave a Forsaken class channeler at Rand's side helping him now? I don't see why she wouldn't, after she had a moment to compose herself and reassess her situation, seek to remove Rand's great advantage, especially considering her death might be imminent. Why not go to the Dark One with the gift of killing a traitor to prove that she is redeemable, especially considering her precarious situation?

As to why Lanfear may or may not have won her freedom, if you recall the Finns consider Mat wise for asking for leavetaking but not wise for not setting the price, terms and conditions of this deal. In Lanfear's case, if she got her wishes we have some options. One, she knew she would likely be forfeiting this life but decided she'd take the gamble and get her wishes instead of guaranteeing her freedom. Two, she also made the mistake of not setting the terms and was not lucky/wise enough to ask for her leavetaking and therefore was held by the Eelfinn, as she mentions she was. Of course, it is possible that something in the pact with the Finn stipulates that any damage done to the doorway voids the pact and they can do with any that enter at their discretion. I see any of those three as possibilities that still fit what we know so far as having occurred.

But as I said - a Finn Assassin borders on loony.
Reply to message
Some interesting new RAFOs and information from BS - 23/11/2009 12:13:37 PM 2708 Views
Thanks! I hadn't made the connection between Rand's paranoya and the dagger wound. *NM* - 23/11/2009 12:50:42 PM 782 Views
Yes, and apparently... - 23/11/2009 02:35:12 PM 999 Views
I tried to suggest that Elaida had been corrupted by Fain and I was practically ridiculed - 23/11/2009 06:29:48 PM 1093 Views
me too - 23/11/2009 06:33:23 PM 1018 Views
Re: me too - 23/11/2009 06:43:40 PM 922 Views
Yeah, I remember that! *NM* - 23/11/2009 06:33:38 PM 492 Views
Very interesting read, thanks Tam! *NM* - 23/11/2009 01:17:06 PM 634 Views
Very interesting, but they wasted a lot of time on questions they knew would be RAFO. - 23/11/2009 02:17:47 PM 1102 Views
I think, though... - 23/11/2009 02:33:29 PM 1076 Views
He seems to indicate that RAFO doesn't necessarily mean we'll ever get an answer, though. - 23/11/2009 03:43:26 PM 1041 Views
Yeah, at least concerning... - 23/11/2009 03:56:02 PM 942 Views
Nice answers on Cyndane - 23/11/2009 04:06:20 PM 1261 Views
Maybe... - 23/11/2009 04:27:44 PM 995 Views
Less capable body...interesting. - 23/11/2009 05:11:16 PM 1100 Views
This idea originated... - 23/11/2009 05:43:21 PM 979 Views
Yes, I've often pondered on the body size and One Power strength link... - 23/11/2009 05:51:07 PM 907 Views
The rule is certainly... - 23/11/2009 06:01:41 PM 1175 Views
I like that idea...and I've explored it before... - 23/11/2009 06:07:29 PM 961 Views
It could in any case... - 23/11/2009 06:15:28 PM 808 Views
I don't really agree on the body size thing - 23/11/2009 06:20:22 PM 963 Views
Re: Yes, I've often pondered on the body size and One Power strength link... - 23/11/2009 06:08:04 PM 1033 Views
I think that... - 23/11/2009 06:14:29 PM 934 Views
Re: I think that... - 23/11/2009 07:35:34 PM 936 Views
I think it's a combination of the two - 23/11/2009 09:02:06 PM 952 Views
the details of the DO and Creator have never interested me much - 23/11/2009 04:06:20 PM 980 Views
Agreed... - 23/11/2009 04:29:13 PM 1076 Views
I like the Padan Fain questions. Also, Lanfear / Cyndane discussion was exciting. - 23/11/2009 05:12:14 PM 1790 Views
Lanfear/Cyndane angreal - 23/11/2009 05:17:35 PM 1417 Views
Re: Lanfear/Cyndane angreal - 23/11/2009 06:02:15 PM 1381 Views
that really wouldn't work - 23/11/2009 06:05:43 PM 852 Views
The Lanfear/Cyndane stuff is at least good - a few theories killed here - 23/11/2009 05:20:47 PM 1219 Views
I'm convinced Moiraine's going to enjoy a Gandalf effect with her strength... - 23/11/2009 05:49:07 PM 1283 Views
I'm also entertaining that idea - 23/11/2009 06:23:30 PM 969 Views
Hmm, but how? - 23/11/2009 06:26:00 PM 954 Views
The angreal being used while they fell through the doorway... - 23/11/2009 06:33:32 PM 801 Views
Yeah, "maybe"... - 23/11/2009 06:49:45 PM 814 Views
I have no idea - 23/11/2009 06:33:34 PM 830 Views
I think... - 23/11/2009 06:51:41 PM 917 Views
I'm not going to argue the theory, but, Moiraine won't give a crap about deference after her ordeal. *NM* - 23/11/2009 09:13:30 PM 492 Views
I agree to some extent - 23/11/2009 10:23:03 PM 790 Views
Says who? - 24/11/2009 07:02:30 AM 758 Views
Re: I'm also entertaining that idea - 30/11/2009 12:06:52 AM 806 Views
That makes one wonder... - 23/11/2009 11:57:55 PM 873 Views
Here's Cyndane's description from encyclopaedia wot: - 24/11/2009 06:15:31 AM 845 Views
Ah well. - 24/11/2009 09:39:20 AM 785 Views
Indeed... - 23/11/2009 06:06:23 PM 869 Views
It's a huge puzzle - 23/11/2009 06:30:03 PM 856 Views
Re: It's a huge puzzle - 23/11/2009 06:33:57 PM 892 Views
Can the Finn still channelers, though? - 23/11/2009 07:13:06 PM 751 Views
Re: It's a huge puzzle - 18/01/2010 12:16:38 AM 786 Views
The Likelihood, if she had been stilled - 23/11/2009 06:12:55 PM 1040 Views
But... - 23/11/2009 06:22:43 PM 747 Views
Re: But... - 23/11/2009 06:33:41 PM 1056 Views
Ok, the difference between stilling and burning out could be his loophole - 23/11/2009 06:42:39 PM 876 Views
Re: Ok, the difference between stilling and burning out could be his loophole - 23/11/2009 06:50:05 PM 903 Views
But if we assume... - 23/11/2009 07:06:32 PM 817 Views
Re: But if we assume... - 23/11/2009 08:13:09 PM 833 Views
Possible, I guess... - 23/11/2009 08:38:59 PM 819 Views
Re: But... - 18/01/2010 12:19:47 AM 1049 Views
and make the others get up their reports - 23/11/2009 06:23:40 PM 738 Views
Not necessarily... - 23/11/2009 06:48:51 PM 782 Views
read the discussons above - lots of speculation abou that - 23/11/2009 06:51:57 PM 734 Views
What if Lanfear's mind was transmigrated, but not her soul? - 23/11/2009 08:30:40 PM 874 Views
It seems that Lanfear may have been excluded as a candidate for killing Asmodean - 23/11/2009 08:02:48 PM 1017 Views
The Finns Killed Asmodean? - 23/11/2009 08:39:08 PM 1610 Views
But... - 23/11/2009 08:52:55 PM 819 Views
And some other counter-arguments - 23/11/2009 09:12:18 PM 910 Views
Re: And some other counter-arguments - 24/11/2009 03:22:36 AM 855 Views
It's a fun thought... - 24/11/2009 12:12:58 PM 845 Views
Hmm... - 23/11/2009 08:50:41 PM 982 Views
This may also explain how the Finns hung Mat from the Tree of Life - 23/11/2009 08:04:32 PM 888 Views
Stupid Question: What does MAFO mean? - 24/11/2009 01:41:00 AM 4151 Views
Maria And Find Out - 24/11/2009 03:03:48 AM 2169 Views
Mordeth - 26/11/2009 03:47:00 AM 744 Views

Reply to Message