I would just point out that I put skill and experience in the same category.
An unskilled or inexperienced fighter will have a hard time beating an experienced one. Alivia wasn't able to kill Cyndane because she didn't have any experience in the particular type of fight they were in. Alivia knows all about battlefield weaves; the type to take out large groups of soldiers. If Alivia and Cyndane had been fighting on the battlefield, Alivia would have probably killed Cyndane because she has so much skill in this particular area. When it came to dueling, however, Cyndane had much more experience, and Alivia wasn't able to win, despite her high power level.
If Lan ever fights Thom in a sword duel, Thom is going to lose. Thom doesn't have the skill that comes from years of experience in swordfighting. However, if Lan and Thom ever sit down to a game of stones, Thom will likely destroy Lan; in this particular area, Thom will emerge the victor. This analogy doesn't completely align with fighting. while fighting, how strong a person is gives him or her an advantage. However, if they are not experienced or skilled enough to know what to do with that advantage, that advantage is effectively lost.
So in a purely hypothetical situation, where an opponent who had only strength was fighting an opponent who was only strong, skill would win.
An unskilled or inexperienced fighter will have a hard time beating an experienced one. Alivia wasn't able to kill Cyndane because she didn't have any experience in the particular type of fight they were in. Alivia knows all about battlefield weaves; the type to take out large groups of soldiers. If Alivia and Cyndane had been fighting on the battlefield, Alivia would have probably killed Cyndane because she has so much skill in this particular area. When it came to dueling, however, Cyndane had much more experience, and Alivia wasn't able to win, despite her high power level.
If Lan ever fights Thom in a sword duel, Thom is going to lose. Thom doesn't have the skill that comes from years of experience in swordfighting. However, if Lan and Thom ever sit down to a game of stones, Thom will likely destroy Lan; in this particular area, Thom will emerge the victor. This analogy doesn't completely align with fighting. while fighting, how strong a person is gives him or her an advantage. However, if they are not experienced or skilled enough to know what to do with that advantage, that advantage is effectively lost.
So in a purely hypothetical situation, where an opponent who had only strength was fighting an opponent who was only strong, skill would win.
"Take the Gleeman!" Rand and Mat cried, throwing Thom to the Myrddraal. Then they ran away as fast as they could, and Thom's screams quickly faded into the distance along with any inconvenient feelings of guilt.
This message last edited by Yondaime on 09/02/2010 at 01:15:28 AM
Strength versus Skill in battle ... Skill wins.
- 07/02/2010 10:11:13 PM
1563 Views
Yes...1 OC fight trumps all the times when we have seen Rand's strength send Forsaken skill running *NM*
- 08/02/2010 04:10:28 AM
508 Views
The line can be blurry between Rand and LTT (most skilled channeler evaaaah)
- 08/02/2010 05:52:06 PM
828 Views
IMO, that had nothing to do with skill in the OP
- 08/02/2010 06:20:09 AM
933 Views
Well, Alivia could just have shielded Cyndane, no sweat, just like Rand shielding Verin...
- 08/02/2010 02:28:49 PM
2952 Views
I genereally agree
- 08/02/2010 05:32:24 PM
977 Views
This is too cut and dried...
- 08/02/2010 07:43:56 PM
856 Views
My intent was to show that skill makes up for strength differentials
- 13/02/2010 05:27:50 PM
747 Views