Active Users:254 Time:12/05/2024 11:45:20 AM
No it isn't... fionwe1987 Send a noteboard - 25/02/2010 05:23:58 PM

Situations where there is actually no choice are exceedingly rare, and the situation Lan was in was not one of them. He did not have to keep the ta'veren from the Shadow. He did not have to bring them to Baerlon or the Stag and Lion. There are any number of hypothetical situations in which the Stag and Lion could have avoided burning, but they didn't, so Lan justifies the burning by saying that the fact that it burnt proves that it was a worthwhile sacrifice.

Lan's situation was indeed one with no choice. They had to run from Baerlon, and they had to scare off the Whitecloaks. All this lead to the inn being burned down.

They had to sacrifice the inn to keep the Dragon alive, and since the Dragon was alive, the burned inn was a price worth paying.

Likewise, there are any number of reasons why waging war over a sandwich is stupid. The example was selected precisely for its stupidity. However, applying the same logic as Lan used in his situation, after the war has been waged, the fact that thousands died justifies the war for the sandwich. Even though there were any number of alternatives. The argument is expressed after the fact to justify whatever you just did as having a worthy cause, as demonstrated by the price that had to be paid to achieve it.

That would be true if the saying was:
"The fact that the price was be paid is proof that it is worth paying."

That isn't the case, though.

Actually, now that I think about it it's like the argument for the existence of gods based on martyrs. It goes 'nobody would have endured so much suffering for a god that wasn't real, therefore their god is real'.

No it isn't.
Reply to message
What were your biggest "WTF?" moments? - 24/02/2010 05:17:21 AM 1707 Views
Re: What were your biggest "WTF?" moments? - 24/02/2010 07:29:39 AM 860 Views
I don't think you got what he said... - 24/02/2010 03:03:19 PM 838 Views
Re: I don't think you got what he said... - 24/02/2010 03:38:00 PM 602 Views
Can't agree with that. - 24/02/2010 05:33:01 PM 706 Views
Re: Can't agree with that. - 24/02/2010 06:40:24 PM 616 Views
But in Aviendha's case... - 24/02/2010 08:10:55 PM 555 Views
Re: But in Aviendha's case... - 24/02/2010 09:00:01 PM 513 Views
That's true. *NM* - 24/02/2010 11:51:03 PM 294 Views
So this is the last sandwhich? - 24/02/2010 11:43:37 PM 541 Views
Your argument is irrelevant. - 24/02/2010 11:58:45 PM 628 Views
No it isn't... - 25/02/2010 05:23:58 PM 521 Views
Re: No it isn't... - 25/02/2010 06:27:36 PM 651 Views
Re: No it isn't... - 25/02/2010 07:48:54 PM 500 Views
This debate about Lan's one liner has gone far too long. - 26/02/2010 04:49:45 PM 649 Views
Re: No it isn't... - 26/02/2010 06:44:10 PM 571 Views
Re: No it isn't... - 02/03/2010 06:34:59 PM 606 Views
WTF Moment - 24/02/2010 07:34:52 AM 730 Views
I don't get these - 24/02/2010 03:18:44 PM 971 Views
These were I found surprising/confusing on my first read - 24/02/2010 03:52:12 PM 769 Views
If you think her "Magic Tight Rope Dancing Skills" were confusing - 24/02/2010 04:05:18 PM 829 Views
Indeed. I've learned a bit of juggling too (from same person) - 24/02/2010 04:19:40 PM 647 Views
Thom said he had the fastest hands he had ever seen - 24/02/2010 05:15:05 PM 655 Views
oh, well in that case it's totally plausible - 27/02/2010 12:50:47 PM 607 Views
Another from Mat: - 24/02/2010 05:06:15 PM 654 Views
Actually, this one is not so much - 24/02/2010 06:40:06 PM 723 Views
The most important thing to take away from this is... - 24/02/2010 07:00:18 PM 611 Views
A few: - 24/02/2010 03:27:56 PM 727 Views
Good ones. - 24/02/2010 03:54:37 PM 696 Views
To be fair. - 24/02/2010 05:26:34 PM 791 Views
Re: To be fair. - 24/02/2010 06:52:25 PM 566 Views
Re: What were your biggest "WTF?" moments? - 24/02/2010 03:49:44 PM 721 Views
Re: What were your biggest "WTF?" moments? - 24/02/2010 04:24:45 PM 700 Views
Re: What were your biggest "WTF?" moments? - 24/02/2010 04:34:27 PM 594 Views
Re: What were your biggest "WTF?" moments? - 24/02/2010 05:26:59 PM 572 Views
Re: What were your biggest "WTF?" moments? - 24/02/2010 06:33:50 PM 731 Views
Re: What were your biggest "WTF?" moments? - 24/02/2010 08:35:19 PM 536 Views
Re: What were your biggest "WTF?" moments? - 24/02/2010 08:54:34 PM 704 Views
Hmm... - 27/02/2010 09:55:59 AM 580 Views
realy? - 27/02/2010 12:53:05 PM 527 Views
My WTF - 27/02/2010 11:04:22 AM 577 Views
Good call. - 28/02/2010 07:22:47 AM 511 Views
In hindsight, just about everything from the frist 3 books - 27/02/2010 01:11:25 PM 680 Views

Reply to Message