Active Users:290 Time:28/01/2023 10:16:13 AM
Re: Iraqi Hopes SilverWarder - 16/04/2004 01:09:43 AM

With the downfall of Saddam many Iraqis had hoped for peace and representation of their interest. Is this what they got after his ousting? No. What do you think frustrated people do? You have to factor in that coalition forces are foreign poewrs on their home soil. Will they accept bullying by foreigners who claim to be helping? Do they deserve it? Is it representative of the stated purposes and intents of the coalition mission in Iraq?

No - they got a bunch of baathist remnants and foreign "Mujahideen" blowing crap up. Lovely.

Demonise the insurgents as you will, but I think it si entirely within the realm of possibility that iron fist will provoke greater fighting and sympathy for the insurgency. It will create/enforce the view of coalition force as "hypocrites and liars" amongst the populace of Iraq.

Don't think so - and as for all this talk of "demonizing" (you seem to like that word) they do that just fine on their own without my help. Kidnapping civilians, exchanging fire with troops who aren't attacking you and blowing things up aren't characteristics I associate with people who want law and order.

Wrong about Iraqi culture. Iraq is not Afgahnistan.

No, it's Iraq. That place where Sunnis, Shiites and Kurds have been slaughtering each other for a long long long time.

The Kurds may want a separate stae. This probably won't happen (most in Iraq are opposed to it, I imagine and Turkey probably won't either). As for the Sunni/Shia issue, youa re thinking like a westerner, now - when it comes to fighting between those groups it is infighting, never a fight for a separate state. Thus, Shia power might be feared for its possible consequences you won't hear calls for separate state.

Sorry - either I misspoke or you mistook me. I did not mean to imply that anyone (other than the Kurds) wants a separate state. The Shiites and Sunnis don't want separate states from each other (although there have been activists who have suggested it in the past) - they just each want to be the one running the show so they can abuse and/or kill the others. Nice.

Wannabe Ayotallah? Perhaps. But like Saddam? Not possible. He claims to have 10, 000 fighters in his "Mehdi Army", observers/experts/the coalition estimate less - perhaps as low as 3, 000. He couldn't hold power with a force like that. You are buying into coalition rhetoric trying to demonise Sadr and equate him with Saddam. He is a radical, certainly, but there is nothing to suggest his views are like that of Saddam.

Umm - I see. And you are ignoring the fact that an Iraqui court has a warrant out for his arrest for the assassination of another cleric, yes?

And 3000 or 5000 armed men are a nice core around which to build an army.


Silver Warder

Warder to Rebelaessedai

Risk everything - or gain nothing.
Geoffrey de Charney - 1356


Deeds - Not words

Remembering Joe (CrazedWeasel)




View/create new replies Sign up for a premium account to add posts to a list of favourites!
Italian Hostage Killed - 14/04/2004 10:51:11 PM 175 Views
It's a terrible situation - 14/04/2004 10:54:59 PM 20 Views
There needs to be a crackdown in Iraq. - 14/04/2004 10:58:56 PM 37 Views
Re: There needs to be a crackdown in Iraq. - 14/04/2004 11:15:43 PM 35 Views
An iron fist by foreign troops won't be appreciated - 14/04/2004 11:45:46 PM 27 Views
Don't be foolish - 15/04/2004 02:48:56 AM 20 Views
You're thinking in stereotypes - 15/04/2004 03:06:05 AM 15 Views
You're still thinking like a Westerner - 15/04/2004 09:56:24 AM 14 Views
Iraqi Hopes - 15/04/2004 06:22:28 PM 8 Views
Re: Iraqi Hopes - 16/04/2004 01:09:43 AM 8 Views
Re: Iraqi Hopes - 16/04/2004 01:45:58 AM 5 Views
Re: Iraqi Hopes - 16/04/2004 10:27:32 AM 7 Views
Re: Iraqi Hopes - 16/04/2004 02:30:44 PM 8 Views
simplistic psychology *NM* - 15/04/2004 06:01:24 AM 3 Views
Is there much of a difference between the troops are doing now... - 20/04/2004 05:56:16 AM 4 Views
Ack.... - 15/04/2004 04:39:39 AM 8 Views
Meet terror with terror... - 15/04/2004 09:09:58 AM 18 Views
That's wicked harsh - 15/04/2004 11:18:06 AM 19 Views
But terrorism flourishes only when it thinks it can accomplish goals - 15/04/2004 12:33:31 PM 12 Views
Insurgency does not equal terrorism *NM* - 15/04/2004 08:38:21 PM 6 Views
Those are very blurry lines *NM* - 16/04/2004 07:29:11 PM 3 Views
In some cases, very obviously - 16/04/2004 08:13:32 PM 3 Views
it wont work - 15/04/2004 08:18:31 PM 12 Views
Interesting post-Saddam policy you're suggesting - 15/04/2004 08:37:20 PM 7 Views
I was revisiting this post in my Your Threads... - 15/04/2004 09:17:36 PM 16 Views