Active Users:370 Time:17/06/2025 08:20:07 AM
I had a couple of issues with the book that I could easily see being removed from the movie Brian Send a noteboard - 07/09/2009 07:01:40 PM
In other words...I may have to check that out.

It would depend on what you disliked about the book. It's essentially a greatly simplified version of the book's story, and the acting's pretty solid, with Julianna Margulies and Angelica Huston among others iirc.

My biggest issue was Bradley's overpowering method of pushing her own agenda and beliefs in the book. She tried creating this book with all these feminist ideas and ended up creating a bunch of female characters that were almost entirely loathsome, and male characters that were so incredibly stupid that you couldn't respect them. It seemed like by the end there were no characters left for you to sympathize with. I know that you're supposed to identify with Morgaine, but I found it impossible. There were a number of points in the book where you thought you had finally seen some sort of character growth, only to find you'd been bamboozled when two paragraphs later the character is back to being the same tired stereotype they've been through the entire book. Even Morgaine showed little or no growth from the start to the finish of the book.

I also wasn't a huge fan of the way that people would look at one another and basically be able to tell everything about them. There must have been dozens of times in the book where someone would look at someone else and fall in love, or know that they were in love with someone. It got old really fast.

The other thing I would have liked to see was a bit more work on the descriptions in the book. Bradley's style of description was quite lacking, with such simple descriptions as "the castle was old gray rock" instead of describing the castle itself. This is a common criticism of character driven works, but in the fantasy genre one comes to expect a bit more descriptiveness about the setting to help draw you deeper into the story...and this was sadly lacking. Bradley relied too much on the readers preconceived notions of Arthurian settings, and I think it was a big shortcoming in her book.

There was quite a bit more about the book that I hated, but I guess I could sum it up by saying that I don't really think it was the story that was lacking, rather I think it was the characters and the writing. Bradley is a quite capable author, I've read many of her Darkover books and enjoyed them, but I couldn't enjoy this book even though I went into it really wanting to. A little more subtlety, a little character growth, and some adequate descriptions and I might have enjoyed the book. As it is, I hated it. In spite of that I do actually intend to give it one more chance; I'm going to read through it again to see if I can't ignore, or at least put on the backburner, some of the things that bothered me so much the first time through.

Edit: though I say "feminist" I wouldn't exactly call what she's pushing as feminist ideology. Feminist ideology I have no problems with...I'm just not entirely sure what to call Bradley's agenda in this book, and I think it may have been what she thought feminism should be.
This message last edited by Brian on 07/09/2009 at 07:04:30 PM
Reply to message
So...what books DON'T you like? - 06/09/2009 04:57:28 AM 1909 Views
I have a couple I really disliked - 06/09/2009 05:28:38 AM 1310 Views
I agree. - 06/09/2009 05:49:28 AM 1309 Views
Ohhhh quotefail! - 06/09/2009 05:54:02 AM 1352 Views
I saw that. - 06/09/2009 06:03:29 AM 1188 Views
You actually read Monkey Bridge? - 06/09/2009 02:47:39 PM 1206 Views
Haha, I'm surprised anyone has heard of it here - 06/09/2009 04:43:59 PM 1190 Views
Some examples - 07/09/2009 08:25:37 PM 1114 Views
Political polemics, for one. Utopian novels, for another. - 06/09/2009 05:29:54 AM 1116 Views
People always recommend I read Ayn Rand - 06/09/2009 02:51:25 PM 1294 Views
I started The Fountainhead. It was pretty dreadful. *NM* - 06/09/2009 08:44:31 PM 693 Views
The Wanderer's Tale by David Bilsborough. - 06/09/2009 06:24:49 AM 1238 Views
YES! - 07/09/2009 06:10:29 AM 1134 Views
Oh, a lot of things. But I wonder. - 06/09/2009 07:00:34 AM 1264 Views
Re: Oh, a lot of things. But I wonder. - 06/09/2009 07:05:51 AM 1207 Views
! - 06/09/2009 06:50:42 PM 1225 Views
Re: ! - 06/09/2009 07:22:43 PM 1108 Views
Well, I do plan on reading it. - 07/09/2009 03:38:26 AM 1177 Views
In fantasy, Vellum and Ink were terrible - 06/09/2009 02:54:05 PM 1202 Views
Duly noted! - 06/09/2009 06:51:22 PM 1179 Views
Oh plenty - 06/09/2009 09:37:23 AM 1232 Views
I hated Wuthering Heights more than Jane Eyre, but I hated Jane Eyre, too. *NM* - 06/09/2009 02:54:49 PM 725 Views
I was never forced to read Wuthering heights - 06/09/2009 03:44:59 PM 1291 Views
I disliked both as well... more than disliked. *NM* - 09/09/2009 08:59:37 PM 739 Views
Well... - 09/09/2009 09:01:18 PM 1203 Views
I like all books I have ever read. - 06/09/2009 12:09:51 PM 1282 Views
You hated The Brothers Karamazov? - 06/09/2009 02:59:16 PM 1209 Views
Umm, yeah. - 06/09/2009 03:28:30 PM 1381 Views
Canterbury Tales by Chaucer. In Ye Olde English, it's harder to translate than ancient Greek. *NM* - 06/09/2009 05:07:49 PM 697 Views
Oh man, the prologue to the Wife of Bath was horrible. - 06/09/2009 05:11:39 PM 1143 Views
The Canterbury Tales are not Old English. They are Middle English. - 06/09/2009 05:59:59 PM 1300 Views
Edit: ignore this, what I had before was blatantly untrue *NM* - 07/09/2009 12:11:37 AM 712 Views
As I'm translating some ancient Greek right now, I call bullshit on that. *NM* - 06/09/2009 08:45:46 PM 657 Views
EDIT: Last post was basically equally bullsh*t - 07/09/2009 12:17:01 AM 1193 Views
I was going to, but I felt I had already been pedantic enough. *NM* - 07/09/2009 02:34:04 AM 715 Views
Jane Eyre. - 06/09/2009 05:13:27 PM 1217 Views
The Clan of the Cave Bear by Jean M. Auel - 06/09/2009 05:58:39 PM 1223 Views
Must remember this. *NM* - 06/09/2009 06:53:08 PM 683 Views
What do you mean? *NM* - 07/09/2009 10:43:58 AM 710 Views
Re: The Clan of the Cave Bear by Jean M. Auel - 06/09/2009 08:08:21 PM 1215 Views
well it was the best book in the series *NM* - 14/09/2009 04:37:27 PM 633 Views
Catcher in the Rye and Heart of Darkness, among the "classics." *NM* - 06/09/2009 08:15:12 PM 693 Views
Ooh! I second Catcher and the Rye. What a piece of garbage. - 06/09/2009 08:20:00 PM 1069 Views
I couldn't finish Heart of Darkness - 14/09/2009 04:39:00 PM 1242 Views
Vellum by Hal Duncan and The Years of Rice and Salt by Kim Stanley Robinson - 06/09/2009 08:16:12 PM 1267 Views
Hm. - 06/09/2009 11:20:40 PM 1180 Views
Dubliners and A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man - 06/09/2009 08:24:07 PM 1174 Views
I didn't mind Portrait of the Artist as a Young Dog...I mean Man - 07/09/2009 02:40:14 AM 1161 Views
Shame on you. Those books are truly Great. Especially Portrait. - 12/09/2009 10:52:40 PM 1209 Views
What? - 06/09/2009 08:28:17 PM 1345 Views
My problem with Wuthering Heights was the characters. - 06/09/2009 09:40:24 PM 1168 Views
Re: My problem with Wuthering Heights was the characters. - 07/09/2009 12:27:44 AM 1214 Views
Wait...you're a guy? - 07/09/2009 02:44:27 AM 1212 Views
Indeed. - 07/09/2009 03:01:59 AM 1222 Views
Stars in His Pocket Like Grains of Sand - 14/09/2009 04:41:16 PM 1393 Views
Oh, and maybe it was lost on me, but I never got much joy out of War and Peace - 07/09/2009 12:22:48 AM 1098 Views
War and Peace is pretty straightforward - 07/09/2009 02:43:25 AM 1231 Views
Jonathan Strange and Mr. Norell. - 07/09/2009 12:54:41 AM 1241 Views
Shame! Shaaaaame! *NM* - 07/09/2009 03:06:55 AM 641 Views
- 07/09/2009 06:13:26 AM 1136 Views
I'm not sure. - 20/09/2009 04:19:52 PM 1477 Views
It probably doesn't help but - 20/09/2009 06:17:34 PM 1564 Views
Don't flame me for saying it.... - 07/09/2009 04:49:40 AM 1294 Views
Nah. - 07/09/2009 05:18:23 AM 1146 Views
For me it was the other way around. - 07/09/2009 07:38:35 AM 1153 Views
You know, I kind of feel that way, too. - 08/09/2009 03:40:58 AM 1173 Views
One last one: Mists of Avalon by Marion Zimmer Bradley *NM* - 07/09/2009 07:44:48 AM 694 Views
*NM* - 07/09/2009 10:33:08 AM 668 Views
Awww man, I thought we got rid of you! *NM* - 07/09/2009 06:05:30 PM 634 Views
Have you ever seen the mini-series? - 07/09/2009 05:42:45 PM 1218 Views
I love really really bad TV movies sometimes....they make for lots of laughter - 07/09/2009 06:06:38 PM 1094 Views
Actually, you might like it. As in, think it's good. - 07/09/2009 06:11:14 PM 1144 Views
I had a couple of issues with the book that I could easily see being removed from the movie - 07/09/2009 07:01:40 PM 1085 Views
Yeah, you might like it then. - 07/09/2009 07:20:04 PM 1141 Views
A Confederacy of Dunces. - 08/09/2009 06:13:59 AM 1226 Views
Crap. That's two people now. - 09/09/2009 01:42:40 AM 1098 Views
Don't go by what I say. - 09/09/2009 03:11:17 AM 1181 Views
Anyone with more than half a brain wouldn't. *NM* - 09/09/2009 03:49:34 AM 697 Views
This sounds like a redshirt mission. *NM* - 14/09/2009 01:12:17 AM 689 Views
Re: Hardy - 09/09/2009 02:42:39 AM 1067 Views
Aw. I liked Confederacy. *NM* - 09/09/2009 06:15:10 AM 667 Views
That probably makes sense for someone from the area though. - 09/09/2009 08:02:23 PM 1170 Views
Oh, I forgot to mention Brave New World. - 08/09/2009 06:26:29 AM 1090 Views
Wha? - 08/09/2009 03:26:29 PM 1239 Views
Wha. - 08/09/2009 06:43:12 PM 1076 Views
*stands and applauds * Here here *NM* - 08/09/2009 08:19:53 PM 717 Views
The Road andOld Man and the Sea - 08/09/2009 04:16:11 PM 1113 Views
Time to give up your man card. *NM* - 12/09/2009 10:53:56 PM 666 Views
The great Gatsby and Romeo and Juliett. - 08/09/2009 08:24:23 PM 1154 Views
Word! - 08/09/2009 08:41:27 PM 1297 Views
Hitchickers guide to the galaxy and The Good earth by Pearl S. Buck - 09/09/2009 01:07:01 AM 1191 Views
Ah, man. I love both those books. *NM* - 09/09/2009 08:08:00 PM 705 Views

Reply to Message