But see, that's where things start to get referred back to Tolkien.
Tom Send a noteboard - 12/12/2011 04:30:12 AM
The only language creation that has come close to Tolkien in its depth or realism is Klingon for the Star Trek universe. Everything else is poorly executed. And why is language creation even something that people look at? Because of Tolkien. Usually, instead of language creation one sees a nauseating array of bad portmanteau words.
World creation is honestly one of the worst areas of the fantasy genre as a whole, however. It's worse than language creation because so many more people try it, and it always nearly fails. Tolkien used Beowulf and Old English symbols and ideas to fashion a world that had a depth and flavor that has been unparalleled. Science fiction has the benefit of imagining other worlds in addition to our own (rather than instead of), so the reader usually doesn't get bad maps and terrible cultures.
Look at some of the more popular authors and you will see terrible world creation. Jordan's world is awful and makes no sense from a geographic, cultural or historical perspective. Cultural identities and distinctions depend not on natural barriers, innovations, East-West cultural cross-fertilization as opposed to North-South, or the ability to hold onto certain pieces of real estate, and everyone speaks the same language, which bears no correlation whatsoever to its predecessor.
Martin is, if anything, worse. He just dropped down England, increased its size and messed around with its history, replacing Hadrian's Wall with a huge ice wall and the Scots with crazy wild men...er...well, he changed their name at least, and threw in some dragons. Everything else is just terrible - the Free Cities, the whole thing, it all just sounds like he had a bad case of diarrhea when writing the other cultures.
Let's not even waste our time discussing Brooks, Goodkind, Zelazny, the D&D hacks (Salvatore, Weis & Hickman), Moorcock or the other usual suspects. It just goes downhill from where we started.
It's really once someone starts into the formulaic world-building and bad-language-system creating in fantasy that one is really inviting the negative comparisons to Tolkien.
World creation is honestly one of the worst areas of the fantasy genre as a whole, however. It's worse than language creation because so many more people try it, and it always nearly fails. Tolkien used Beowulf and Old English symbols and ideas to fashion a world that had a depth and flavor that has been unparalleled. Science fiction has the benefit of imagining other worlds in addition to our own (rather than instead of), so the reader usually doesn't get bad maps and terrible cultures.
Look at some of the more popular authors and you will see terrible world creation. Jordan's world is awful and makes no sense from a geographic, cultural or historical perspective. Cultural identities and distinctions depend not on natural barriers, innovations, East-West cultural cross-fertilization as opposed to North-South, or the ability to hold onto certain pieces of real estate, and everyone speaks the same language, which bears no correlation whatsoever to its predecessor.
Martin is, if anything, worse. He just dropped down England, increased its size and messed around with its history, replacing Hadrian's Wall with a huge ice wall and the Scots with crazy wild men...er...well, he changed their name at least, and threw in some dragons. Everything else is just terrible - the Free Cities, the whole thing, it all just sounds like he had a bad case of diarrhea when writing the other cultures.
Let's not even waste our time discussing Brooks, Goodkind, Zelazny, the D&D hacks (Salvatore, Weis & Hickman), Moorcock or the other usual suspects. It just goes downhill from where we started.
It's really once someone starts into the formulaic world-building and bad-language-system creating in fantasy that one is really inviting the negative comparisons to Tolkien.
But you might also praise a book for doing certain things well in the spirit of Tolkien, things that are not necessarily derivative. Such as language creation or good world-building, both of which can make for a great setting and story without rehashing the same old shit all over again. All too rare, I will agree.
I had forgotten about the Battleship movie, and now I'm sad that you reminded me.
I had forgotten about the Battleship movie, and now I'm sad that you reminded me.
Political correctness is the pettiest form of casuistry.
ἡ δὲ κἀκ τριῶν τρυπημάτων ἐργαζομένη ἐνεκάλει τῇ φύσει, δυσφορουμένη, ὅτι δὴ μὴ καὶ τοὺς τιτθοὺς αὐτῇ εὐρύτερον ἢ νῦν εἰσι τρυπώη, ὅπως καὶ ἄλλην ἐνταῦθα μίξιν ἐπιτεχνᾶσθαι δυνατὴ εἴη. – Procopius
Ummaka qinnassa nīk!
*MySmiley*
ἡ δὲ κἀκ τριῶν τρυπημάτων ἐργαζομένη ἐνεκάλει τῇ φύσει, δυσφορουμένη, ὅτι δὴ μὴ καὶ τοὺς τιτθοὺς αὐτῇ εὐρύτερον ἢ νῦν εἰσι τρυπώη, ὅπως καὶ ἄλλην ἐνταῦθα μίξιν ἐπιτεχνᾶσθαι δυνατὴ εἴη. – Procopius
Ummaka qinnassa nīk!
*MySmiley*
Aren't the Tolkien comparisons getting a little...old?
- 09/12/2011 09:51:39 PM
3028 Views
The comparison bothers me, but not because Tolkien isn't relevant.
- 09/12/2011 10:05:22 PM
1880 Views
Only when shit works are being compared to him
- 09/12/2011 10:22:26 PM
1775 Views
Larry,
- 10/12/2011 01:13:18 AM
1793 Views
Snide dismissal that will be passed off as for his own entertainment.
- 10/12/2011 04:55:43 AM
1714 Views
Well-deserved condescension.
- 11/12/2011 03:54:27 AM
1863 Views
You're sure about that?
- 11/12/2011 04:20:26 AM
2052 Views
Re: You're sure about that?
- 11/12/2011 05:25:08 AM
1776 Views
Re: You're sure about that?
- 11/12/2011 06:03:02 AM
1651 Views
i think you shouldn't judge a whole world's school programs on your school
- 11/12/2011 06:42:30 AM
1682 Views
- 11/12/2011 06:42:30 AM
1682 Views
If you're arguing that children should be able to read genre fiction, fine.
- 11/12/2011 08:52:27 PM
1579 Views
Well, I suppose it depends on the type of genre being read
- 11/12/2011 09:36:16 PM
1813 Views
How often do you hear the challenging writers mentioned at this site?
- 12/12/2011 02:03:05 PM
1543 Views
Only when you, me, and a couple others write reviews
- 12/12/2011 04:21:14 PM
1958 Views
Oh, it was the same as it always is
- 12/12/2011 05:23:56 PM
1631 Views
Much of the actual "Classics", that is, Greek and Latin originals, kids would eat up.
- 12/12/2011 03:13:03 AM
1556 Views
You're upfront and honest about it; he isn't. The difference matters to me. *NM*
- 11/12/2011 05:18:42 AM
923 Views
this is a bit off topic, but out of curiousity...
- 11/12/2011 06:28:35 AM
1766 Views
I've discussed this dozens of times at this site. Perhaps you've missed all of the posts.
- 11/12/2011 08:57:44 PM
1710 Views
mk I'll go look. I probably did miss it (or at least don't remember it!)
- 11/12/2011 09:08:02 PM
1670 Views
I have a successful career that was inspired by the video games I played as a child. *NM*
- 11/12/2011 05:52:21 PM
950 Views
Now let's get all the people who just pissed their lives away with video games and see the %.
- 11/12/2011 08:58:42 PM
1824 Views
The majority of players neither waste their lives nor make a career out of it.
- 11/12/2011 11:29:29 PM
1704 Views
Yeah, sorry, I don't think you could say that with a straight face in real life. *NM*
- 12/12/2011 04:13:52 AM
890 Views
Then you have a closed mind on the subject. Ironic, considering your stance on edification. *NM*
- 12/12/2011 05:47:50 AM
830 Views
No, just with respect to you. *NM*
- 12/12/2011 02:00:15 PM
883 Views
Tom, you pulled the "Say that to my face!" line. You lost the right to talk about respect. *NM*
- 12/12/2011 03:20:15 PM
925 Views
Once again, I really don't care what you think. *NM*
- 12/12/2011 03:37:40 PM
877 Views
Did I imply that you did? My apologies. I'd hate to insinuate that you'd stoop that low. *NM*
- 12/12/2011 04:13:25 PM
844 Views
As well read as you seem to be, you think you'd be smart enough...
- 11/12/2011 06:20:06 PM
1648 Views
I thought I have made it clear that I don't care if people don't like me here.
- 11/12/2011 08:44:58 PM
1576 Views
Re: I thought I have made it clear that I don't care if people don't like me here.
- 12/12/2011 04:04:37 PM
1636 Views
That statement has just confused me.
- 12/12/2011 04:06:53 PM
1587 Views
Re: That statement has just confused me.
- 12/12/2011 04:14:27 PM
1591 Views
I never learned Hittite. I had a book on pre-order for a long time but never ended up getting it.
- 12/12/2011 05:41:03 PM
1546 Views
What you have made clear, I think, is the fact that you deal in generalizations and stereotypes.
- 12/12/2011 10:12:12 PM
1705 Views
There's an unintentional irony in what you say, alas
- 13/12/2011 12:44:26 AM
1626 Views
Tom, Dick, or Larry...you may use your true first name, but you're still an anonymous entity to most
- 13/12/2011 04:49:35 AM
1825 Views
With such comeback skills, you must have ruled the playgrounds as a kid, no?
- 13/12/2011 05:21:42 AM
1831 Views
There are no special snowflakes, are there?
- 11/12/2011 09:39:21 PM
1578 Views
- 11/12/2011 09:39:21 PM
1578 Views
There are many way of widening one's horizons and broadening one's mind.
- 11/12/2011 10:08:24 PM
1330 Views
What I don't like-
- 12/12/2011 04:28:55 AM
1685 Views
Why don't you name something, then?
- 12/12/2011 04:40:29 AM
1641 Views
Sure.
- 13/12/2011 07:30:56 AM
1473 Views
Mentioning Ender's Game pretty much shot your argument in the foot.
- 13/12/2011 02:02:59 PM
1577 Views
You dismiss the entire video game medium because many games lack value.
- 13/12/2011 03:59:11 PM
1727 Views
You're like the McDonald's paid advocate trying to say Big Macs are actually healthy.
- 13/12/2011 05:46:37 PM
1538 Views
I'll leave it up to others to define as they wish against their self-conceptions of me 
- 10/12/2011 10:52:54 AM
1693 Views
- 10/12/2011 10:52:54 AM
1693 Views
that's alright. I really have no desire to stroke your twit-ego. *NM*
- 10/12/2011 04:36:56 PM
723 Views
Considering the firestorm I appear to have touched off, that may be best.
- 12/12/2011 12:57:49 PM
1670 Views
I know, John
- 12/12/2011 04:27:04 PM
1571 Views
Re: I know, John
- 12/12/2011 05:06:26 PM
1635 Views
As I've said in the past, I'd be scared if anyone agreed with me anywhere approaching 100%
- 12/12/2011 06:33:52 PM
1554 Views
- 12/12/2011 06:33:52 PM
1554 Views
Re: As I've said in the past, I'd be scared if anyone agreed with me anywhere approaching 100%
- 12/12/2011 07:13:37 PM
1632 Views
- 12/12/2011 07:13:37 PM
1632 Views
Blurbs are not generally very original in their comparisons - would kind of defeat their purpose.
- 09/12/2011 10:42:17 PM
1662 Views
Maybe if so much of the genre weren't crap derivative works it wouldn't be so common. *NM*
- 11/12/2011 03:44:24 AM
855 Views
To be fair, a lot of it isn't.
- 11/12/2011 04:06:07 AM
1607 Views
I suspect that if it really isn't derivative it's not being compared to Tolkien in the first place.
- 11/12/2011 04:18:57 AM
1554 Views
That's true.
- 11/12/2011 11:08:01 AM
1537 Views
But see, that's where things start to get referred back to Tolkien.
- 12/12/2011 04:30:12 AM
1681 Views
The Tolkien fanaticism gets old. And yes, for me it is unreadable.
- 11/12/2011 11:37:53 PM
1613 Views
No, because the movies are very contemporary and relevant, thus he will remain so for quite a while.
- 12/12/2011 03:14:53 AM
1660 Views
Disagree all you want, but LotR is still the touchstone when it comes to works of fantasy.
- 12/12/2011 03:48:20 AM
1580 Views