Active Users:887 Time:02/11/2026 01:51:58 AM
Re: Elaborate on Brandon Stark Werthead Send a noteboard - 19/04/2013 09:49:37 AM

View original post
Where do you get that Brandon raped Ashara?

Brandon is a hothead, which we knew from previous books. He's also not a nice person, as we got from Barbry's description of him in ADWD. We know from ASoS that Brandon went to talk to Ashara 'on Ned's behalf' during the Harrenhal tourney during the Year of False Spring. We know he went after what he wanted and he was only marrying Cat because of his father's wishes, not because of his own desire.

Selmy is also vehement in his anger with "Stark" who dishonored Ashara, got a daughter on her (so, definitely not Jon Snow's mother) and she killed herself as a result. He is 100% not talking about Ned. Barristan and Ned got on very well in AGoT and even in ADWD itself he stands up for Ned to Daenerys, telling her he stood vigil for Ned in the Great Sept of Baelor even though he was on the run himself. The chances of him doing that for someone he thought was an honourless person who'd effectively killed an innocent woman are non-existent.

Reply to message
ASOIAF: Hopefully a spoiler-laden thread - 16/04/2013 10:52:45 PM 2291 Views
Re: ASOIAF: Hopefully a spoiler-laden thread - 18/04/2013 12:09:11 PM 1495 Views
Elaborate on Brandon Stark - 18/04/2013 09:40:17 PM 1240 Views
Yes, please do. - 19/04/2013 12:40:05 AM 1503 Views
Re: Elaborate on Brandon Stark - 19/04/2013 09:49:37 AM 1320 Views
How does that equate to rape? - 19/04/2013 01:54:27 PM 1233 Views
Still not buying it. - 22/04/2013 09:09:09 PM 1639 Views
BAM! Consider him rebuffed. Good job - 22/04/2013 10:56:59 PM 1648 Views
Re: ASOIAF: Hopefully a spoiler-laden thread - 19/04/2013 01:06:19 AM 1831 Views
Can we really suspect that? - 19/04/2013 01:44:07 PM 1426 Views

Reply to Message