Active Users:383 Time:01/05/2025 06:13:31 PM
Hmm. jh Send a noteboard - 05/02/2010 09:11:13 PM
1. Are there any books that should ever be censored? If so, why? If so, which ones? Who should decide what books are censored and for whom?


Not really. I suppose there might be some hypothetical case where censorship might be preferred, but I can't see any which I agree with just at the moment.

2. Should any books be withheld from libraries in high schools? If so, why? If so, which ones? Who should decide what books are withheld?


Perhaps. Schools have a duty to promote current societal values - at least here, and if certain books require a measure of formal training to make their role fit in the scheme required, I could say that it is not books which should be available in school - however, they should be available outside the school grounds. But a school has a mission; it should be allowed to restrict information contrary to that mission while on the grounds...

3. Name five books (aside from religious works) that you think have had a massive impact on the world, and at least one that is frequently overlooked on lists of that sort.


The Origin of the Species
The Wealth of Nations
Philosophiæ Naturalis Principia Mathematica
Das Kapital
The Communist Manifesto

That's five, right? You could make the argument that each of the above has influenced the world quite a lot.

4. Do you think any of the books you listed in point 3 should be read in schools as mandatory reading? Why or why not?


Perhaps not in its entirety, and certainly not principia, but the concepts should be familiar to students... I think there are better ways of expressing what was said in each of those books, given their historical nature, and a modern day perspective is likely more useful in treating with all of them.

5. Name five books (aside from religious works) that you think SHOULD be mandatory reading in schools (or at least "on the curriculum" if you don't like the word "mandatory"), and why.


No. I think this question is asking for a literary canon rather than books which impacted the world - those books are in general rather dull and/or highly specific and/or just plain wrong, which does not suit the purpose of a school to teach a wide variety of subjects in a non-academic fashion. In order to get the most from books which treat serious topics, you need training beyond what is possible in high school to attain. You'd be a lot better off from a teaching point of view if you could get the information across in some fashion where the original text is not the prime focus for reading. A literary canon is highly subjective, though, and I won't really touch that...

6. Do you think schools are too careful in choosing books due to pressure from those who would censor the curriculum? If so, which sorts of books do you feel are unjustly censored?


Nope, I do not. I have a feeling this might be a larger problem over in the USA, or in this case Germany where they are a bit sensitive about this whole killing six million jews thing.

7. Do you think schools place too much emphasis on particular themes or ideas when choosing their curriculum? If so, which ones?


Well, at least here, there is a bit much regulated in law which need not be... such as the promotion of a democratic society, and turning the students into well informed citizens. Too much of an emphasis on the community - which of course has its explanation in the fact that it would be self destructive not to impose a certain amount of conservatism on the next generations, but also is hampering to progress.

8. Are there any authors you would remove from school curricula who are presently well-represented? Why?


Heh, only boring ones. ;)

9. Are there any authors not represented that you would like to see added generally? Why?


Nope. A general rule would be that to limit a school's teaching by requiring a certain reading material is not a good way to go - general themes perhaps, local authors, sure, but not specific authors.

10. Is there ONE book (aside from religious works) that you think EVERYONE should read? If so, what book and why?


The count of monte cristo. To annoy you. :D

Honestly, though, there are a lot of books which I feel is the basis for a good cultural understanding, but if people don't have the same goals as me with their reading, I will not be arrogant enough to say that some things are for everyone.
"People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realize how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world" - Calvin.
This message last edited by jh on 05/02/2010 at 09:15:38 PM
Reply to message
Censorship, promotion of books and dissemination of ideas. - 05/02/2010 05:15:17 PM 1440 Views
Interesting post - 05/02/2010 06:19:06 PM 954 Views
I agree. One Shakespeare is sufficient. *NM* - 06/02/2010 06:42:51 AM 351 Views
Oh, fun! You mentioned the 语录 by Chairman Mao... - 06/02/2010 06:35:21 PM 857 Views
Tough Subject, censorship - 05/02/2010 07:24:39 PM 946 Views
tough questions - 05/02/2010 08:26:30 PM 921 Views
I never saw the humour in Dilbert... - 06/02/2010 06:28:57 PM 943 Views
I actually ran into this in high school. - 05/02/2010 08:33:10 PM 1089 Views
I found that we covered a lot about American Indian issues in US History. - 06/02/2010 06:23:16 PM 871 Views
we coverd most of those things as well - 06/02/2010 08:08:22 PM 1024 Views
Anyone interested in German history in particular and European history in general should read it. - 05/02/2010 08:47:14 PM 1052 Views
I think jane austen and the brontes would be good to leave in - 06/02/2010 03:44:10 AM 790 Views
They could read Pride & Prejudice & Zombies instead. *NM* - 06/02/2010 04:03:34 PM 341 Views
They could. It'd be very educational. - 06/02/2010 04:37:23 PM 713 Views
What about... - 18/02/2010 06:57:56 PM 1148 Views
Hmm. - 05/02/2010 09:11:13 PM 923 Views
Love the survey. - 05/02/2010 09:42:29 PM 1040 Views
Interesting. Do you really think that Nineteen Eighty-Four is plausible? - 06/02/2010 10:13:56 AM 885 Views
It doesn't have to be plausible as a whole to be relevant. - 06/02/2010 08:28:20 PM 880 Views
I agree entirely - 06/02/2010 10:32:07 PM 973 Views
You raise an interesting point. - 06/02/2010 06:06:20 PM 881 Views
Re: Censorship, promotion of books and dissemination of ideas. - 05/02/2010 11:09:41 PM 1013 Views
Nietzsche as mandatory reading - that's a fun idea. - 06/02/2010 06:00:29 PM 928 Views
Re: Nietzsche as mandatory reading - that's a fun idea. - 06/02/2010 06:03:59 PM 933 Views
Re: Censorship, promotion of books and dissemination of ideas. - 05/02/2010 11:47:08 PM 1004 Views
Re: Censorship, promotion of books and dissemination of ideas. - 06/02/2010 12:11:06 AM 880 Views
I agree with most of that. But to quote our eminent Camilla... - 06/02/2010 10:30:15 AM 984 Views
I agree on the Shakespeare (and mentioned that below). - 06/02/2010 05:54:50 PM 882 Views
Re: I agree on the Shakespeare (and mentioned that below). - 06/02/2010 06:05:48 PM 991 Views
I don't think high school students need to discuss possibilities for staging. - 07/02/2010 01:36:03 AM 830 Views
I think there is value to discussing staging - 07/02/2010 01:52:47 AM 835 Views
nice post - 06/02/2010 01:27:23 AM 855 Views
Re: nice post - 06/02/2010 01:29:34 AM 866 Views
A lot of people think von Clausewitz is important. - 06/02/2010 05:51:44 PM 789 Views
More than Sun Tzu? *NM* - 06/02/2010 08:31:44 PM 323 Views
Sun Zi was relatively unknown in the West until recently. - 07/02/2010 01:30:06 AM 841 Views
Sure, but he could still have influenced world history by influencing Asia... *NM* - 07/02/2010 01:35:17 AM 356 Views
Doubtful. - 07/02/2010 01:41:01 AM 856 Views
Tom, you did not just write that - 07/02/2010 10:12:40 AM 905 Views
The Mongols are not East Asian. They are Central Asian. - 07/02/2010 03:06:19 PM 874 Views
Neat. - 06/02/2010 06:41:37 AM 1122 Views
Brave New World is an excellent choice. - 06/02/2010 05:15:15 PM 811 Views
Re: Censorship, promotion of books and dissemination of ideas. - 06/02/2010 01:44:07 PM 974 Views
I agree that Shakespeare is over-emphasised. - 06/02/2010 04:29:16 PM 743 Views
Before responding to others, I'll post my own responses - 06/02/2010 04:26:53 PM 999 Views
Re: Before responding to others, I'll post my own responses - 06/02/2010 10:34:10 PM 822 Views
Hmm. - 06/02/2010 11:33:02 PM 886 Views
New Zealand has culture? - 07/02/2010 03:25:28 PM 1043 Views
Which book of his would you recommend ? - 09/02/2010 04:20:15 PM 834 Views
The Whale Rider is lovely. - 10/02/2010 02:36:01 PM 753 Views
Re: Censorship, promotion of books and dissemination of ideas. - 07/02/2010 11:52:02 PM 932 Views
Re: Censorship, promotion of books and dissemination of ideas. - 08/02/2010 03:14:24 AM 1109 Views
Re: Censorship, promotion of books and dissemination of ideas. - 11/02/2010 10:58:23 PM 977 Views

Reply to Message