Brief comments on Magic, Dumbledore, and The Epilogue.
Aemon Send a noteboard - 07/04/2010 07:13:55 AM
Magic
I agree with you on the magic being inconsistent, but my larger problem with it was that became too simplistic. The earlier books were full of new and unusual magic. In the later books, magic use seemed to be limited to unforgivable curses, along with the occasional stunning or disarming spell. I was hooked by a story about a kid living at a boarding school teaching magic, and the last few books basically threw that away entirely, with hogwarts (as well as study in general) dwindling into the background. Ah well.
Dumbledore
I hated the way in which Dumbledore died. I didn't care too much about his actual death, but I spent the rest of the series waiting for his death to mean something, or to be explained. Neither one ever happened. Dumbledore going down without a fight, begging Snape to do it. . .both were so completely out of character that I knew it had to be a trick. But it wasn't. It was just a very puzzling, anticlimactic death. Cedric's death was far more meaningful and dramatic, and we only knew him for a book or two. Dumbledore was Harry's mentor for the entire series, as well as the most powerful wizard in the world, and he got nothin'. Bah.
The Epilogue
Everyone I've talked to hated this, but I actually enjoyed it. It was cheesy, true, but I really like to see things get back to normal after big battles for some reason. Too many stories show you the fight, but very little of what everyone is fighting for. Always seems like you win the prize, but never get to find out what it is. Sure it might make a more dramatic ending to fade to black as the last arrow falls, but, darn it, I want to know if my gang got their happy ending or not.
I agree with you on the magic being inconsistent, but my larger problem with it was that became too simplistic. The earlier books were full of new and unusual magic. In the later books, magic use seemed to be limited to unforgivable curses, along with the occasional stunning or disarming spell. I was hooked by a story about a kid living at a boarding school teaching magic, and the last few books basically threw that away entirely, with hogwarts (as well as study in general) dwindling into the background. Ah well.
Dumbledore
I hated the way in which Dumbledore died. I didn't care too much about his actual death, but I spent the rest of the series waiting for his death to mean something, or to be explained. Neither one ever happened. Dumbledore going down without a fight, begging Snape to do it. . .both were so completely out of character that I knew it had to be a trick. But it wasn't. It was just a very puzzling, anticlimactic death. Cedric's death was far more meaningful and dramatic, and we only knew him for a book or two. Dumbledore was Harry's mentor for the entire series, as well as the most powerful wizard in the world, and he got nothin'. Bah.
The Epilogue
Everyone I've talked to hated this, but I actually enjoyed it. It was cheesy, true, but I really like to see things get back to normal after big battles for some reason. Too many stories show you the fight, but very little of what everyone is fighting for. Always seems like you win the prize, but never get to find out what it is. Sure it might make a more dramatic ending to fade to black as the last arrow falls, but, darn it, I want to know if my gang got their happy ending or not.
Harry Potter (the entire series)
- 06/04/2010 11:00:07 PM
2211 Views
Re: Harry Potter (the entire series)
- 06/04/2010 11:29:49 PM
1447 Views
Really?
- 07/04/2010 05:41:46 PM
1545 Views
I honestly think it's a combination of the two
- 07/04/2010 05:55:18 PM
1371 Views
I'll give you that....
- 07/04/2010 06:11:27 PM
1430 Views
It does seem logical that the series gets more teenager-oriented as Harry grows older.
- 07/04/2010 06:47:57 PM
1399 Views
Re: Harry Potter (the entire series)
- 07/04/2010 12:26:22 AM
1775 Views
I get where you're coming from
- 07/04/2010 06:19:13 PM
1542 Views
That's kind of the point though...
- 07/04/2010 08:44:26 PM
1429 Views
This is how I see it too
- 08/04/2010 12:43:03 AM
1586 Views
just a comment about your rich=bad
- 08/04/2010 02:05:32 AM
1563 Views
I agree with many of your points.
- 07/04/2010 12:44:31 AM
1666 Views
I have to dispute the concept of going "too far."
- 07/04/2010 06:32:47 AM
1384 Views
Hm, I don't know.
- 07/04/2010 11:08:12 AM
1435 Views
This is a lot like the argument I'm having with Joel on the CMB concerning original sin.
- 08/04/2010 07:21:39 AM
1364 Views
- 08/04/2010 07:21:39 AM
1364 Views
Where is this debate? I'd like to read it.
- 08/04/2010 05:18:38 PM
2037 Views
I should have put "debate" in quotes. It's about four sentences long.
- 08/04/2010 10:32:43 PM
1367 Views
- 08/04/2010 10:32:43 PM
1367 Views
More conversation on Snape.
- 07/04/2010 06:01:37 PM
1748 Views
His death wasn't very spectacular, but he did play an essential role...
- 07/04/2010 06:45:58 PM
1590 Views
Brief comments on Magic, Dumbledore, and The Epilogue.
- 07/04/2010 07:13:55 AM
1752 Views
Re: Brief comments on Magic, Dumbledore, and The Epilogue.
- 07/04/2010 06:09:20 PM
1585 Views
The movies are even worse about this.
- 07/04/2010 06:15:35 PM
1449 Views
Death doesn't actually happen in slow-motion fit for the cinema screen.
- 08/04/2010 07:24:31 AM
1405 Views
Re: Death doesn't actually happen in slow-motion fit for the cinema screen.
- 08/04/2010 03:27:09 PM
1423 Views
Harry Potter and Star Wars have two radically different approaches to this
- 07/04/2010 06:13:25 PM
1685 Views
When my son asked for his own set of Harry Potter books,
- 07/04/2010 10:26:37 PM
1465 Views
This is assuming of course...
- 07/04/2010 11:00:15 PM
1506 Views
I was most irritated by the ironic names
- 08/04/2010 05:38:59 AM
1571 Views
Re: I was most irritated by the ironic names
- 08/04/2010 10:07:40 PM
1955 Views
Exactly - it's not as obvious if you're a kid, then it seems clever and it's fun to decode.
- 09/04/2010 01:04:11 AM
1510 Views
