Probably; as discussed in Brams thread it should never be seen as predictive, let alone prophetic.
Joel Send a noteboard - 21/08/2011 11:55:09 AM
Evolution is the affect of natural selection and like it or not we are part of nature. The actions and behaviors of birds affect how they evolve and the actions and behaviors of humans affects how we evolve. Evolution isn't a ladder where some creature are higher than others it is simple the result of selection. There is a real question about how our technology will affect our evolution but if we select for dumb and lazy then that is evolution as just as much as selecting for fast and smart.
Evolution does a great job at tailoring species to survive their environments, but change that environment too much and all the gradual changes that enhanced survival for millennia can become a real detriment. We all know about the prevailing theory that an asteroid killed the dinosaurs with a "nuclear winter" style apocalypse, but let's not kid ourselves: The next ice age had pretty dire implications for stupid building sized exotherms. On the other hand, most modern mammals would've overheated and run themselves to death escaping those dinosaurs amid the rainforest like conditions in which they lived. If we accept that view of evolution as more description than destiny it's just one more reason not to argue mans achievements are any kind of evolutionary verdict.
I also still contend that a 200,000 year old species that takes at least a dozen years to reproduce (often twice that) doesn't give much basis for conclusions about evolution anyway.
Once we've survived the end of the ice age and interglacial that spawned us maybe we'll be able to make some definite statements, but "if the previous period [interrupted by numerous frigid spells lasting hundreds of years] was more typical than the present one, the period of stable climate in which humans flourished—inventing agriculture and thus civilization—may have been possible only because of a highly unusual period of stable temperature." In that case we're back to "humans aren't a triumph of evolution, we're a freakish anomaly."
Honorbound and honored to be Bonded to Mahtaliel Sedai
Last First in wotmania Chat
Slightly better than chocolate.
Love still can't be coerced.
Please Don't Eat the Newbies!
LoL. Be well, RAFOlk.
Last First in wotmania Chat
Slightly better than chocolate.
Love still can't be coerced.
Please Don't Eat the Newbies!

LoL. Be well, RAFOlk.
This message last edited by Joel on 25/08/2011 at 09:31:11 PM
If ever there was a reason to cut greenhouse gas emissions
- 19/08/2011 10:14:00 AM
1030 Views
I've seen Start Trek, I know the real threat is you killing whales.
- 19/08/2011 10:34:08 AM
684 Views
I know
- 19/08/2011 10:36:22 AM
630 Views
- 19/08/2011 10:36:22 AM
630 Views
You make a fair point
- 19/08/2011 11:22:53 AM
610 Views
There's so much wrong with that
- 19/08/2011 01:08:57 PM
662 Views
"They don't recycle; kill them all. "
- 19/08/2011 07:11:15 PM
639 Views
- 19/08/2011 07:11:15 PM
639 Views
Very Space Hippy
- 19/08/2011 10:39:10 PM
674 Views
- 19/08/2011 10:39:10 PM
674 Views
It's still debatable whether we've abandoned the evolutionary ladder.
- 19/08/2011 11:16:58 PM
777 Views
You'll welcome to debate that with a biologist, it's not my specialty or interest
- 20/08/2011 04:46:43 AM
718 Views
I've seen a lot of mainstream biologists suggest human evolution may be mostly mental now.
- 21/08/2011 11:32:48 AM
732 Views
Neither of us are biologists though and it's not really relveant anyway
- 21/08/2011 01:21:06 PM
714 Views
I'm not ignoring it, just wondering why over half the planet ignores it and lives in misery.
- 21/08/2011 01:55:53 PM
707 Views
If you have occassion to spend time in those places you'll know why
- 21/08/2011 02:38:44 PM
608 Views
How does literal mud huts as the norm respresent living standards rising "a lot".
- 22/08/2011 12:29:35 AM
792 Views
You seem to have cherry-picked what you wanted to hear out of my comments
- 22/08/2011 01:07:10 AM
501 Views
"It's a stability thing, not a Western greed thing" seemed to encapsulate your comments.
- 22/08/2011 03:10:17 PM
640 Views
Only if you really cherry pick them
- 23/08/2011 02:48:08 AM
654 Views
This seems to have descended into an insoluble partisan debate.
- 23/08/2011 07:43:07 PM
714 Views
*rudely butts in*
- 23/08/2011 04:38:33 AM
691 Views
American companies don't go to China SOLELY to screw the working class, no;that's largely incidental
- 25/08/2011 08:03:05 PM
770 Views
we should abdon the myth of the evolutionary ladder
- 20/08/2011 11:49:35 PM
543 Views
Probably; as discussed in Brams thread it should never be seen as predictive, let alone prophetic.
- 21/08/2011 11:55:09 AM
653 Views
Well, for this context I think the use is okay
- 21/08/2011 11:59:19 AM
646 Views
That's an interesting point about the NEED for fossil fuels as a stepping stone to advanced culture.
- 21/08/2011 12:33:59 PM
735 Views
Not a need, just an edge
- 21/08/2011 02:06:23 PM
541 Views
There's industrialization and then there's industrialization.
- 22/08/2011 12:53:35 AM
880 Views
If you were more familiar with engineering you'd not say something like that
- 22/08/2011 01:53:33 AM
914 Views
I dispute that industrialization is primarily about non-agricultural production.
- 22/08/2011 03:10:19 PM
830 Views
Well you can argue that with a dictionary I suppose
- 23/08/2011 03:50:52 AM
658 Views
I'm not above that, but the dictionary definitions I've found are disappointingly self-referential.
- 24/08/2011 02:25:21 AM
595 Views
That tends to be the case, it is a kinda vague term outside of specific context
- 24/08/2011 09:12:19 AM
758 Views
Tends to moot that part of the debate though.
- 26/08/2011 12:31:21 AM
883 Views
and we wonder why so many people ignore "scientist"
- 19/08/2011 01:17:38 PM
670 Views
Think it's better to ignore "reporters on a slow news day," to be honest *NM*
- 19/08/2011 02:38:23 PM
251 Views
Hypothetical aliens are perfectly wise
- 19/08/2011 06:24:13 PM
565 Views
You may be confusing aliens with God.
- 19/08/2011 07:08:01 PM
614 Views
- 19/08/2011 07:08:01 PM
614 Views

