Active Users:182 Time:18/05/2024 03:27:06 PM
I will have a go at responding as well gban007 Send a noteboard - 06/05/2020 12:18:31 AM

View original post
I am a small business owner. The governor of my state informs me that for whatever reason, my business has been deemed nonessential. I am therefore ordered to close my doors until further notice. Where is the due process? My livelihood has been stripped away with no recourse, no accountability. And the solution proposed is the government should hand me money?

Just because the john hands you $1,000, doesn’t mean you didn’t just get fucked.


What is the due process you are mentioning here? Consultations, ability to submit / lobby etc to confirm what should and shouldn't be deemed nonessential? Concern could be that if following this process, it could take too long and things spiral out of control in meantime, or are you thinking immediate action is close down, but with opportunity to pursue ability to open up afterwards if then deemed essential? I think the latter seems fair.

However, with the whole due process thing, part of it potentially is also around what is legal as such - your talk about due process suggests that perhaps there is supposed to be a due process, and so what they are doing is illegal - if so, is there recourse to the courts?

I'm in NZ, and there has been some testing in the courts of our lockdown, with some questions remaining as to the extent our laws allow for the lockdown and enforcement of it. (I'm probably not understanding it well, but there are some suggestions that potentially the health people can basically put through a lockdown, but it isn't enforcable as such, so more a strong request).

Otherwise, if it is legal, then sounds like more a system fault that needs to be explored somehow?

Otherwise, for specific circumstance, and we are struggling with here too, I would like to think if they have forced you to shut down, that you should be able to get either insurance or payout that will cover the cost of shutdown.

I.e, something like:

Revenue during period would normally be $200k
Costs during period would normally be $150k
Costs actually incurred are $50k
So should be assistance to tune of $200 - (150 - 50) = $100000. If the $1000 provided is arbitrary and doesn't apply to the above, then yeah, I don't think what they are doing is sufficient.

***editing because can't math

This message last edited by gban007 on 06/05/2020 at 12:54:38 AM
Reply to message
Safety at what cost? And who is paying for it? - 04/05/2020 01:51:07 PM 475 Views
Almost like not having good government comes at a cost, huh? - 04/05/2020 03:19:02 PM 225 Views
the Democrats and others on the American Left have never been friendly to small businesses - 04/05/2020 03:46:38 PM 202 Views
This may have been true at some point... - 04/05/2020 04:49:41 PM 178 Views
yes, we will see. - 04/05/2020 05:54:26 PM 193 Views
Yes, it is worse in India, and even worse in other places - 04/05/2020 06:43:39 PM 193 Views
The death rate is not a fixed number *NM* - 05/05/2020 02:11:53 AM 76 Views
No shit. *NM* - 05/05/2020 02:18:49 AM 78 Views
I meant the rate of death if infected, is not a fixed number *NM* - 05/05/2020 02:19:48 AM 90 Views
Neither is the number of unemployed. *NM* - 05/05/2020 02:22:47 AM 92 Views
We have tools that can impact that number, we can not do so for the death rate. - 05/05/2020 02:34:19 AM 169 Views
My late wife’s sister and her husband are both self employed - 05/05/2020 03:07:46 AM 203 Views
But that is entirely a fixable failure of the system... - 05/05/2020 03:26:25 AM 191 Views
Oh please - 05/05/2020 04:01:34 AM 207 Views
Then I fail to see your point... - 05/05/2020 05:57:20 AM 178 Views
I am not going to play this game mookie. - 05/05/2020 03:29:52 AM 176 Views
NYC is a poorly run cruise ship and not an example of what could happen everywhere else. - 05/05/2020 03:54:13 AM 202 Views
That's some prime nonsense - 05/05/2020 05:58:45 AM 180 Views
Here’s the deal and the point my two repliers are missing. - 05/05/2020 04:29:36 AM 211 Views
We ban businesses and fields of the economy all the time. - 05/05/2020 04:41:33 AM 184 Views
Were freon and incandescent light bulbs banned by executive order without new legislation? - 05/05/2020 04:49:00 AM 179 Views
You can not always complain to the manager Mookie, sometimes there is no manager and we must act to - 05/05/2020 05:00:00 AM 204 Views
This is NOT Europe. - 05/05/2020 05:13:55 AM 184 Views
- 05/05/2020 06:02:51 AM 182 Views
I will have a go at responding as well - 06/05/2020 12:18:31 AM 339 Views

Reply to Message