Active Users:301 Time:20/06/2024 03:53:40 PM
Really? Nobody else viewed it as simple allegory? Vodalus Send a noteboard - 28/01/2023 05:45:28 AM

The pesky kooks knocking at the cabin to proselytize are stand-ins for the Christian right’s attempts to impose their religious beliefs on others. The words and actions of the wackos correspond to religious dogma or superstitious mumbo jumbo, depending on your particular view of the subject, as well as religious extremism. The scenes of supposed apocalyptic eschatology are simply part of the content of the Bible. Not asking that important question comes across as less of an omission than it does to being rather key to the statement being made. Refusing to sacrifice one of their own a la Abraham and Isaac — or oneself a la Jesus — is the middle finger to (belief in) God. How well or fair this will be presented is another matter, but it sure seems like the concept for the movie came from an antitheist.

View original post
I went to see "Plane" which is the latest 'Gerard Butler gets in trouble and kicks butt' movie. And before the movie I saw a trailer I don't get them.

It was called "Knock at the Cabin". From what I gather from the trailer, it's about a couple with their daughter, staying in a cabin in the woods, either living there or on vacation, when a group of people barge in and take them prisoner. These people, led by Dave Bautista, claim they don't want to hurt them but they have to ask them to save the world. The family has to agree to sacrifice a member in order to prevent the apocalypse. They are told that each time they are asked and say "no" lots of people will die. We are shown images of a tidal wave and a plane crush, with the implication that these things are the result of the family's refusal to give in. The rest of the trailer is a montage of escape attempts and the newcomers looking sinister and the family having doubts with one of them maybe coming to share in the revelation that is driving the intruders.

Okay, so that's the plot, but what is the conflict? How is this different than any other horror/thriller about a family trapped in a remote location by a bunch of crazy people? The thing about millions of people dying... is that supposed to be the hook, that it raises a real question of what you would do in that situation? Because for that question to work, you need a reason to go either way. It should be a thing like "what would you sacrifice for the greater good" or "how far would you go to get something you really wanted or needed?"

And this movie does not ask that question. There is no appeal for the other side of the question. Morality is not a numbers game. Something is right or wrong, no matter how big the scale. Why would I care about a bunch of strangers instead of my family. I'm not the one making planes fall or tidal waves hit. If someone is doing that and wants a dead member of my family in order to stop, fuck him. This is the easiest question or request to say "no" to.

"Please pick a member of your family to die, with absolutely no gain to yourself, the incentive being strangers might die on a slightly different schedule."


Rest of the movie? Hello?

Reply to message
Movie trailers are not giving me much hope for the immediate future - 23/01/2023 10:11:01 PM 509 Views
The other correct answer is "the more annoying child", right? - 24/01/2023 08:49:15 PM 101 Views
Sounds like a thinly veiled “fuck you” to (Abrahamic) religion. - 25/01/2023 12:18:53 AM 112 Views
It’s an M. Night Shyamalan movie - 25/01/2023 05:27:19 PM 116 Views
Really? Nobody else viewed it as simple allegory? - 28/01/2023 05:45:28 AM 110 Views
Yes, I gave Shyamalan too much credit in believing he would not have such a dumb allegory - 01/02/2023 02:20:08 AM 107 Views
Movie reviews for it are out - 02/02/2023 05:43:01 PM 92 Views
Abraham didn't sacrifice Isaac - 01/02/2023 01:49:08 PM 84 Views

Reply to Message