Active Users:1896 Time:30/10/2025 07:09:36 AM
We have reached a rather bizarre point in the culture wars, it seems. Legolas Send a noteboard - 02/08/2024 09:47:40 AM

A far right politician like Giorgia Meloni - as Angela Carini, the woman who lost to Khelif, is Italian - actually had a more nuanced and reasonable take (“From my point of view, this was not an equal competition. I think that athletes who have male genetic characteristics should not participate in women’s competitions. Not because we want to discriminate against anyone, but to protect the rights of female athletes to compete on equal terms.”) than for instance JK Rowling or the official United Nations rapporteur on violence against women and girls (who for some reason felt she had to weigh in).

I also loved the dry comment in Politico's article about the controversy and the more hysterical reactions: 'Boxers, need it be said, are supposed to punch each other very hard.'


View original postI still don't have an opinion on how trans people or intersex people should compete in sports, but she is not trans. She is not tricking anyone. She is trying to be the person she has always been. She's owed sympathy, regardless of whether you think she should be competing or not.

The weird thing in this case is that the general Olympic position is, we leave these decisions up to the respective international associations of every sport because they are the best placed to judge at which point you get really unfair advantages, which testosterone limit there should be, etc. But then for some reason, Khelif had been denied entry in the world championships as a woman but was accepted at the Olympics, so the boxing association is saying, as far as we're concerned she shouldn't be there... then who decided in the end?

But yes, same for her as for Semenya, they just do the best they can with the body they have, like any other athlete.

Reply to message
After watching a few clips of the Olympic Opening Ceremonies from yesterday - 27/07/2024 03:01:21 PM 507 Views
be our guest ? *NM* - 27/07/2024 05:33:03 PM 172 Views
In France? It's something of a miracle they didn't. - 27/07/2024 08:46:55 PM 268 Views
True - 28/07/2024 01:49:12 PM 240 Views
Ah, but the - 30/07/2024 10:41:31 AM 241 Views
I'll start feeling bad for the French once they get rid of their absurd laïcité laws. - 30/07/2024 08:48:24 PM 247 Views
Re: I'll start feeling bad for the French once they get rid of their absurd laïcité laws. - 30/07/2024 09:01:16 PM 232 Views
I don't have any particular position on trans women in sports. *NM* - 31/07/2024 02:42:29 AM 117 Views
Okay, after today, I have an opinion, which is that this isn't about trans women. - 01/08/2024 09:42:50 PM 241 Views
Re: Okay, after today, I have an opinion, which is that this isn't about trans women. - 01/08/2024 10:47:41 PM 229 Views
Love you, mookster. <3 *NM* - 01/08/2024 11:37:29 PM 114 Views
*NM* - 02/08/2024 01:13:55 AM 115 Views
We have reached a rather bizarre point in the culture wars, it seems. - 02/08/2024 09:47:40 AM 251 Views
It really is an edge case - 02/08/2024 03:34:47 PM 252 Views
Funny thing is, she competed in the previous Olympics too and nobody batted an eye over it. - 02/08/2024 04:06:34 PM 235 Views
That's why combat sports have weight classes. - 02/08/2024 05:17:14 PM 233 Views
Every Olympian is an edge case. - 02/08/2024 08:53:15 PM 232 Views
You know, - 31/07/2024 03:31:24 PM 248 Views
Secular folks have no problem killing people. Maybe we should ban incels from being in public. - 01/08/2024 12:40:35 AM 212 Views
We are talking about France. - 01/08/2024 11:41:19 AM 257 Views
*NM* - 01/08/2024 01:02:30 PM 117 Views
*NM* - 01/08/2024 01:50:04 PM 116 Views
He's got a weird face. And a patchy beard! *NM* - 01/08/2024 09:36:17 PM 113 Views
Gurll... You so outrageous! - 28/07/2024 04:34:43 PM 265 Views
Dionysus and Apollon? *NM* - 30/07/2024 05:16:20 PM 210 Views
my bad *NM* - 30/07/2024 07:04:46 PM 130 Views
This question is seriously baffling me... - 31/07/2024 07:03:13 AM 244 Views
Re: This question is seriously baffling me... - 31/07/2024 10:35:07 AM 242 Views
I'm from one of those countries doing quite well at the Olympics - 04/08/2024 05:38:27 AM 334 Views
HOT TAKES French Pole Vaulter's Massive Penis Dashes Olympic Dreams THE WHOLE PACKAGE *NM* - 03/08/2024 11:59:06 PM 175 Views
He should have taped it down - 04/08/2024 02:50:22 AM 224 Views
return to tradition! (going greek) - 04/08/2024 03:15:57 AM 291 Views
I sympathize with the man. - 04/08/2024 03:28:17 AM 218 Views
*NM* - 04/08/2024 03:36:20 AM 174 Views

Reply to Message