Active Users:185 Time:17/05/2024 11:27:30 AM
Re: Well, clearly it's not meant to be accurate, otherwise they wouldn't take so much license DomA Send a noteboard - 22/03/2011 12:53:49 PM
But there will probably be quite a few people who will think that this is what really happened. So what is the point of such revisionism?


It's not "revisionism". It's a not a documentary, it's a drama - a fiction based on the life and time of Henry VIII. The writer sought to translate the essence of Henry VIII and his court - and of the Renaissance prince - in that show (with fairly relative success, IMO), in a way that would make sense and appeal to audience without much at all of a background on the period. He didn't seek perfect accuracy (no more than he did with the movies about Elizabeth), he sought to show an Henry that the audience would perceive and understand something like the way the contemporaries did - or at least in the writer's perspective on the Tudors, rather than this perception as a fat ogre that developped around him in later times. A lot of the aspects of the series arose from this angle, like the casting, the costumes (Elizabethan already), even the depiction of sexuality is "modernized" (again not to document sexuality in Henry VIII's time accurately, but to attempt to give the modern audience an impression of how sex was perceived in that time), the choices to alter many facts to focus the drama through the seasons and give Henry (and a few others) a coherent dramatic development you could otherwise get only from reading a in-depth biography.

It's more an impressionist and forcibly biased portrait of Henry VIII than a biography or an historic narrative. The historical background in the series is mostly there to flesh out Henry's character, anchor the drama and keep the audience entertained. The focussed a great deal more on some of the aspects of Henry's life that appeal to a modern mass audience (which excludes a great deal of renaissance politicking and religious subtleties) - and aspects they could carry and make evolve with some thematic coherence through the seasons.

I think the show's done a fair job at providing the general idea and keeping it all entertaining and (often) interesting, and at avoiding that "history class" feeling. Even though personally I disagree with a few aspects of this writer's take and perspective on the Tudors, his portraits of Elizabeth and Henry VIII are still interesting, as dramatic characters (for the most part, fairly well acted by the cast).

As for the show misleading people about real History... prftt... what does it matter if people who learn History through dramas on TV got their facts wrong? If the show sparked their interest enough they'll go to history books and start building their own impression of the man and this time. Otherwise they probably don't care much about History anyway, and not for Tudor England and Henry VIII in particular except as a great period and character to center an historical drama around (which, incidentally, was the avowed goal of the creators of the series).
This message last edited by DomA on 22/03/2011 at 01:12:56 PM
Reply to message
The Tudors - not particularly realistic - 21/03/2011 03:27:24 PM 841 Views
Erm. - 21/03/2011 03:45:56 PM 604 Views
Ok ok... Apparently Welsh people think that part is important, though - 21/03/2011 03:54:45 PM 457 Views
That is the Welsh for you *NM* - 21/03/2011 04:12:03 PM 195 Views
The costumes are apparently 30-50 years out - 21/03/2011 04:45:16 PM 466 Views
You haven't mentioned the worst error... - 21/03/2011 08:57:29 PM 588 Views
There's too many things wrong in the series to mention them all - 21/03/2011 09:30:39 PM 434 Views
It isn't exactly meant to be particularly realistic. - 21/03/2011 10:00:31 PM 456 Views
Well, clearly it's not meant to be accurate, otherwise they wouldn't take so much license - 22/03/2011 07:05:14 AM 475 Views
Re: Well, clearly it's not meant to be accurate, otherwise they wouldn't take so much license - 22/03/2011 12:53:49 PM 483 Views
Natalie Dormer IS INDEED enough reason to watch this show... - 24/03/2011 02:23:10 PM 526 Views
Here's an opinion piece on the topic - 01/04/2011 02:46:36 PM 506 Views

Reply to Message